AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Games We Play

Page 3

by Lyra Asher

It was only a two hour flight from Rockaway, Oregon, back to mine and Daphne’s apartment in San Francisco, so traveling had never been the issue. It was this place. Every time I stepped foot back into the coastal town I’d left in the dust years ago, it was like a weight settled on my chest and a heavy cloud hovered overhead. There was no escape from the dread, not when every bruised memory came back with a vengeance and threatened to pull me back under until it drowned me once and for all.

My mother was gone but the relief she felt in my absence never came for me. I just felt this nothingness—that was an entire feeling all on its own.

Nausea continued to churn low in my belly as I wet my dry lips and swallowed back the sand clogging my throat. The anxiety would pass, it always did, however that reassuring thought did nothing to calm those nerves or settle my stomach.

My shaky fingers clasped onto the cornicello dangling from my neck, an eighteenth birthday present my Nonna had gotten to celebrate my diciottesimo and to protect me. It was believed to ward off malocchio, known as the evil eye to most; unfortunately, the shiny golden trinket did nothing to calm the storm raging in my gut.

Sometimes all you could do was exist, and even that was exhausting sometimes.

“Fuck,” a gruff voice bit out as the door swung open with a BANG! Chills skittered down my spine at the sound of the voice that had haunted my dreams for almost the entirety of my life. I would recognize it anywhere—the teasing tone that he used to shield his callous words. The way it dropped an octave when he said my full name. How annoyingly perfectly he rolled the R in Alessandro.

Like the first rays of sunlight peeking out after a storm, hope surged through me at the sound, the low tone stabbing my fragile heart. It was excruciating how much that sound could still affect me, even a decade later.

I tamped down that little flicker of optimism, a snarl beginning to form on my face.

He was the reason those damn photographers were here.

We could joke all we wanted about them being here for Spencer, but Daph’s boyfriend wasn’t as well-known as the captain and top scorer for the Bay Area Bisons. Finnegan MacCallum had led the Bisons to win the Finals not once, but twice, and was going for his third consecutive win this upcoming season. To our little town of Rockaway, he was a legend, but to me, he was just another self-absorbed athlete with too much money who needed a swift kick in his oversized, hockey-obsessed ass.

Popping up from my seated position, I clutched the flask to my chest in rage and turned toward the intruder, ready to give him the tongue lashing of his life. He started rambling, his deep voice as smooth as the whiskey on my tongue. “I’m so sorry, I didn’t know anyone was in he⁠—”

Holding my hand up for him to stop, he immediately snapped his mouth shut and stared at me with those large brown eyes, so deep they were almost black. They were always a startling juxtaposition to his loud, teasing personality; as deep as the midnight sky, yet his soul was made of pure sunshine.

They stayed fixed on me and he didn’t even blink as the air shifted from the charged energy. That crackling undercurrent was always present when he was in my proximity—like two magnets attracting, but we both held back.

The man was visually devouring me, his stormy eyes drinking in every inch of my unmoving form. I didn’t bristle against his stare or the way those obsidian eyes were lasering past my black dress and searing into my olive-toned skin, his gaze like a brand on my flesh. I felt bare to him in that second, my torment on full display with my blue eyes bleary with tears and mascara.

Even my carefully curled hair that Daph had spent a meticulous amount of time on had lost its structure, my natural waves kinking against the coils, making me a frizzy mess. I didn’t have time to even consider my presentation to him and how I couldn’t stand for him to see me weak like this.

I didn’t even have time to yell at him to get the fuck out, my words coming to a lull like a short circuit in my brain as Finnegan MacCallum stood before me. Dressed in an all black-on-black suit, fitted to his muscular and sunkissed frame, he was devilishly good-looking. His dark hair still had a bit of his natural curl to it, longer on the top and tousled like he kept running his hand through it nervously.

My gaze trailed up his physique … from the polished leather shoes to the loosened gray tie around his neck and—Yup, that suit is definitely custom-tailored. They probably took two of the legs and sewed them together to fit those tree trunk thighs … and holy mother of pearls.

Had he gotten taller?

Finnegan’s head tilted to the side as if he were studying me as intently as I was him. Hockey players were supposed to be intimidating and toothless, even balding at times from all that extra testosterone pumping through their veins. He was a behemoth of a man—but Finn didn’t fit into the typical stereotype.

He was luxuriously handsome with his perfectly straight nose, strong jaw, and broad shoulders. His grin was dazzling, always halfway a smile and halfway a taunt. Almost like an invitation to a game that I no longer wanted to play. Not when I knew the only winning move was to not play at all.

It didn’t matter if I wanted to or not, anyway; he had lost the privilege of having me in his life years ago. It was still so utterly shocking how twenty-plus years of friendship could end with one sentence, but Finnegan was known for defying logic.

Asshole or not, he was a gorgeous specimen of a human being. Most people found Finnegan MacCallum charming at first sight, but I happened to be immune to most kinds of bullshit.

My first instinct was to deck him in his too-pretty face, maybe knock a few of his gleaming white teeth out. My second instinct was also to punch him. Again. And then my third was to tell him to leave as I recalled how his sharp claws had raked over my heart, turning it into nothing but tattered ribbons.

I needed to put up my walls again, to set my boundaries before he destroyed those next.

I’d been running from him for almost a decade, and he wasn’t going to catch me now.

When those dark, lingering eyes of his met mine again, I snapped out of my slow, drunken haze and went with my third and final instinct.

“Save it, MacCallum,” I snarled. He reared back with shocked, soil-colored eyes, as if I had struck him with my words, but I kept going. “No one wants your bullshit apologies, so save it for someone who actually gives a fuck.”

CHAPTER TWO

finnegan

Fuck.