AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Games We Play

Page 14

by Lyra Asher

My nose scrunched up as I gagged loudly, “Ew, no.” I wiggled my pointer finger at her before pulling the ties on my robe tighter. I needed to feel complete, like I wasn’t falling apart at the seams. The mention of Spencer and his teammates reverted my mind back to the topic I’d been trying to avoid. Of who I’d been trying to avoid. “No athletes or super douches. Specifically, no hockey players.”

I pulled the robe so tight I could feel it constricting my lungs on every intake of breath. “I hate hockey players.”

Daph pursed her cherry-red lips. “Hate is a strong word.”

“I know.” I let go of the ties, my breath releasing with them, but the anxiety still churned like an oncoming storm. “That’s why I said it.”

“You still have him blocked, don’t you?”

Him.

Finnegan Killian MacCallum.

The man I couldn’t escape, no matter how far I ran.

“I double checked as soon as we left the church,” I conceded. “If I had his number, I’d have blocked that too, but alas, we cannot have everything.”

She sighed, ignoring my attempt at humor to lighten the subject. Then she gave me that look.

The one where her eyes lasered into my soul, reading through the bullshit and digging until she found the truth I was denying.

She gave a shake of her head and stood up to straighten her skirt before grabbing her discarded mug. “You’re bound to run into him again, especially with Spencer’s season coming up around the corner.”

“Ughhhhh.” Stuffing my face into a pillow, I groaned in defeat. “I know, I know. I won’t abandon you to the puck bunnies.”

I just didn’t know how I was going to face him eventually.

At our re-encounter, I couldn’t even bear to look into his dark eyes again. It was too painful, too raw. All the memories of the past had bubbled up to the surface, so instead, I resorted to studying my manicure as if it were more interesting than him.

But the truth of the matter is that nothing was more interesting, entertaining, or alluring than Finnegan. He had been my best friend and enemy, my rival and ally, and then he was nothing.

But how could he be nothing when he had once been my everything?

It was far too complicated, too fucking hard to maneuver, and I didn’t know where to begin besides running from the entire situation.

Daphne returned to the couch, her designer leather satchel filled to the brim with designs slung over her shoulder. She pressed a soft kiss to my forehead, so kind and delicate compared to the rough exterior I always put on. “It’ll be okay, I promise.”

Standing up, I wrapped both arms around her and pulled her in for a tight embrace, only for a moment. Years later and I was still learning how to express affection that wasn’t overtly sexual. I could bang someone’s brains out, man or woman, but the soft touches? The kissing and cuddling?

Absolutely made my skin crawl.

I just never got a whole lot of affection growing up apart from my Nonna; even then, that was few and far between. She was great with praise, good with the pat on the back or kiss on the cheek but those deep, soul crushing hugs were a rarity. Whereas my mother’s version of affection usually involved throwing things at the wall or floor and not directly at me. Or a shocked look with that slow, serpentine smile when I didn’t fuck something up like I always seemed to.

But after years of friendship with Daphne, I was getting better with both giving and receiving affection because she was a hugger, a major love bug.

Pulling back, I smoothed her blonde ponytail, which had begun to frizz from rubbing against my furry robe. “Good luck today.” Daph shot me a dazzling smile, her excitement so palpable. “I know you are going to fucking crush it.”

“Always do.” She flipped her ponytail and winked before sashaying to the front door. “Text me your list, I’ll stop at the store on my way home.”

“You’re the best, Daph.” My phony bravado dropped as I wrapped my arms around myself. “I don’t know what I’d do without you.”

Her warm brown eyes twinkled as she said, “You’d survive.” Then she smirked. “You just wouldn’t have as much fun.”

And then the front door closed with a click, causing Darla to sit up on the couch in confusion as to why our best friend would abandon us on a freaking Sunday.

CHAPTER FIVE

scarlett