AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Unhinged Killer

Page 79

by G.T. Dípè

Building a happy little family while knowing my profession could tear it apart because somebody wanted revenge, leverage, or simply a cleaner way to get to me—that wouldn’t have been love, but selfishness wearing its clothes. So, I accepted the simpler version of my future: no one gets close enough that losing them could become a weakness for someone else to exploit.

But then Pinehaven happened. Matthew Macaulay happened. And now, every sensible rule I ever made about surviving my own life has rotted away in seven months.

Because lying here now, on this stupid soft blanket in the middle of the woods while Matthew kisses the shit out of me, I know with frightening certainty that he could be my person.

I won’t let anyone, even his devil-forsaken father, take him away from me.

He’s mine.

Forever.

42

ANTHONY

—Butterflies by Tom Odell

feat. AURORA

My hand moves up Matthew’s back to the base of his neck, holding him there while I kiss him harder, and I feel the smile that forms against my mouth before he gives me one in return.

Without breaking the kiss, Matthew reaches blindly for the small bottle beside us, and I hear the snap of the cap opening somewhere near my hip. His mouth stays on mine while his fingers move to my hole, and the first slow circle around my rim sends a shiver through me that has nothing to do with the chilly night.

It could be that the kiss is distracting me, but when he pushes one finger inside me, there’s resistance for only a moment before I breathe out against his mouth and let him in.

“You’re so hot,” Matthew rasps against my mouth before dragging his lips along my jaw, then lower to my neck, kissing and licking his way down. “I’ve been dreaming about this since I set my eyes on you.”

Even now, after everything he has already admitted, part of me still reacts to that sentence with the same disbelief I felt the first time he told me he has been attracted to me since we met.

Maybe I’m the most oblivious person alive.

Matthew Macaulay—who looks like somebody designed him specifically to make other people question their self-control—spent those first weeks trying not to get hard around me, and I was busy interpreting half of his strange behavior as rich-boy eccentricity.

He told me later that there were moments he had to force himself to look away because he thought I might notice him staring, moments he avoided standing too close because he was afraid his body would betray him, moments when he had to remind himself that I was straight and might become uncomfortable if I realized what was going through his head.

The whole thing is funny now because he also thought I might judge him for being gay. Me? A man who has killed people for money. A man who spent months going into his room under a false identity because I wanted to touch him while still insisting to myself that curiosity was a perfectly sufficient explanation.

Who the fuck am I to judge anybody?

More importantly, has he actually seen himself?

Even looking at him now, with his hair falling messily over his forehead, lips swollen from kissing me, and his eyes dark with want, he’s easily the sexiest man I have ever seen.

“Fuck, you’re so tight,” Matthew says hoarsely.

His mouth curls against my neck before he sucks at the skin beneath my jaw, and then a second finger joins the first. He starts working his fingers, stretching me, and opening me up for him. He adds a third finger, and each time he brushes my prostate, pleasure skitters through me. My body is giving itself over to him, and so is the rest of me as my heart cracks open.

I have never spent much time wondering what it would feel like to be with another man because, before Matthew, there was no reason to. Women were simple and familiar. Desire happened, I acted on it, and afterward, life continued without anything significant happening.

Then Matthew came along and managed to make every category I had relied on feel inadequate. I still don’t know if I want men in general, but I do know that I want him.

I open my eyes and find him watching me, and that look nearly undoes me. There’s obvious lust in it, but there’s also affection, open and unguarded, and some part of me wants to look away because I’m still not used to being seen like this.

For most of my life, being kept around meant being useful to somebody so they had no reason to discard me. Victor kept me because I was good at my work, and Macaulay kept me because I was effective.

Matthew is the first person who makes me imagine being chosen for the sake of it. I need to get him out of danger first, dismantle whatever Macaulay started, and make sure nobody else gets near him. Then I’ll tell him everything about why I came into his life.

And I want him to choose me even after he knows the truth.