AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Earl’s Unlikely Little Family

Page 81

by Hanna Hamilton

“I would rather stand.”

“Sit down. I am an old woman, and I will not crane my neck up at you while we say what must be said. Sit.”

He sat.

For a long moment, she said nothing. She looked at her hands, then at the window, and then at him.

“You think I did it out of malice,” she said. “You have thought the worst of me from the first, and I have given you cause. But you are wrong about this, and I do not wish you to be wrong about it. So, I will tell you the truth.” She drew a breath. “I did not show her that document to destroy your marriage. Well, that is not quite honest. When I first came by it, that is exactly what I meant to do with it.”

“So, what was the purpose then?”

“Let me finish. I am not practiced at this, and if you interrupt, I shall lose my nerve.” She pressed her lips together. “You must understand something of my son. He was my only child. I loved him with my whole heart.” Her voice went thin. “And then he died. He and Caroline both, in one afternoon, and all I had left of him in this world was one small girl with his chin and her mother’s eyes.”

Sebastian could not speak.

“Phoebe is all I have of him. Do you understand? You have your sisters, your mother, and now, a wife. I have a cold house, a dead son, and one granddaughter. When Caroline’s will named you and not me, I thought, she will vanish into that family, and I shall become a stranger to her. An old woman she visits twice a year out of duty. I could not bear it. So, I fought you. I would have done anything to keep some part of my son near me. I am not proud of all of it.”

She took a deep breath.

“And I will tell you the rest.” She lifted her chin. “I went to your house meaning to part the two of you. I had the document. I knew what it would do. I thought that if I could prove the marriage a sham, the court would give me Phoebe, and I would have her, and that would be best for the child. And then I sat in your parlor and that little girl put a daisy chain on my head and took me by the hand to a gallery where you had hung my son’s portrait beside her mother’s, so they might look at one another. You did that. Not for me. You did it for her before you ever knew I would see it.” She shook her head. “A man who does that is not a man playing a part for a court. And she is happy there. I watched her. She is happy in a way I could not make her if I kept her a hundred years in this house. I saw it, and I knew I had been wrong. Taking her from you would not mend my grief. It would only make another child grieve.”

“Then why,” Sebastian said, and his voice was not steady now, “why did you show Emily that letter if you had changed your mind?”

“Because I believed she had a right to know.” Lady Hartley met his eyes. “When I first discovered those papers, I thought they were proof of everything I had suspected. That yours was a marriage of convenience, entered into for the sake of keeping Phoebe, and that you had already prepared for its end.”

She paused, looking down at her hands.

“But then I came to your house. I saw Phoebe with you and with Emily. I saw how happy she was and how naturally the three of you belonged together. I began to question whether I had been wrong about you. Indeed, I began to hope that I had.”

“Then why show Emily the papers at all?”

“Because I could not explain them away simply because I wished to believe better of you. The settlement was generous, certainly. You had made provisions for her comfort and security. But there was also that statement, prepared for the newspapers, speaking of a marriage that had come to an end and an affection that had not endured. What was I to make of that?”

Sebastian looked away.

“I did not know whether you had written those words because you meant to leave her or because you wished to protect her should she choose to leave you, and I thought that if I could not tell the difference, perhaps Emily could.”

Her expression softened.

“I told her what I had found. I also told her that I had not used it against you because I no longer knew what to believe. I hoped there was an explanation. More than that, I hoped she would ask you about it.”

She drew a weary breath.

“I did not foresee how deeply it would wound her. Nor did I imagine she would leave without speaking to you. I have spent so long looking for reasons to distrust you that I fear I have forgotten how much harm a suspicion can do, even when it is spoken without malice.”

She spread her hands.

“It was not only what you showed her that made her leave,” Sebastian said at last. “She found a letter I began in a moment of fear and never finished. She has taken it for a decision, when it was nothing of the kind.”

Lady Hartley studied him. “A letter?”

He paused, considering what to tell her and then cleared his throat. “I wrote it after Martin returned,” he admitted. “Emily and I had quarreled in the carriage. She was right to resent being treated as helpless, yet I heard only that she did not need me. We made our peace that same night. She trusted me afterward. Still, I had begun that wretched letter, and failed to burn it as I should have.”

“I see.”

“I have told her I love her,” he said at last, “but I married her because I needed someone to help me keep Phoebe, and Emily has never forgotten it. How could she? I gave her every reason to believe that was all she was to me.”

He rubbed a hand over his face before looking up again. “I would have married almost anyone to protect my niece, but Emily is the only woman I could ever have loved. Phoebe is the reason I married, but Emily is the reason I came to understand what a marriage could be. I have told her how I feel, yet somehow, I have never made her understand that I would choose her now, even if there were no child to protect and no duty demanding it.”