The Earl’s Unlikely Little Family
Page 62
“I am sorry,” he said.
“For what?”
“For all of it. This marriage was meant to be the thing that saved the guardianship. It was meant to make our household respectable beyond question. And instead, I have married you, dragged your past out into the light, and put it under that woman’s microscope. You would have been better off had I never done so. Had I never asked you to stay.”
“Stop.” Emily sat down beside him. “Do you truly believe that if Martin had never existed, Lady Hartley would have simply given up?”
He said nothing.
“She would have found another weapon. If not Martin, then something else. Your reputation. A rumor. A card debt from ten years ago. A woman you once danced with twice. She would have found something because the something was never the point.” Emily’s voice was steady. “The point is that she decided, long before any of this, that you were unworthy. Everything since has only been her looking for the proof.”
Sebastian was quiet for a long moment. And then, because he was tired, and because it was Emily, he said the thing he had never said aloud to anyone.
“Perhaps she is right.”
Emily turned to look at him, and he saw that he had surprised her.
“You cannot mean that.”
“Can I not? You have spoken at length about your guilt, your part in all of this. You have spoken badly of yourself and meant it, have you not?”
“And you have told me that I am wrong time and again.”
He gave a short, humorless laugh. “But we are different. You have been deceived into thinking less of yourself, even though others always saw more in you. I am the opposite. You must understand, no one has ever expected anything else of me. My whole life, I have been the amusing one. The one who could be relied upon for a joke and nothing more. I became Earl at fifteen, and I improved the estate, and I managed the accounts, and I did the thing properly, and still, to every soul in London, I remained Everingham, the charming rake. The delightful wastrel. Good for a dance and a laugh and very little besides.” He turned the quilt over in his fingers. “And do you know, I let them. I never once troubled to correct it.”
“Why?”
“Because it was easier.” The admission came out low. “If a man is expected to be nothing, he cannot disappoint anyone by being nothing. It is only when you try, when you let it be known that you are reaching for something more, that you can fail at it, publicly for all the world to see. Far safer to be underestimated. No one weeps for the fool who was never expected to be wise.”
Emily said nothing, only watched him, and somehow, her silence made it easier to go on.
“Caroline was the only one who ever refused to see me that way. My whole family found me diverting; Caroline found me… capable. She used to say it drove her to distraction, that I hid behind the jokes. And then she left me her daughter.” His voice roughened, and he let it. “She left me Phoebe. She could have chosen anyone, and she chose me. She trusted me with the one thing that mattered most to her in all the world. And if I lose Phoebe to that woman, then I will have proven, once and for all, that Caroline was wrong. That I was exactly what everyone always thought I was. And I will have failed the only person who ever believed I could be more than charming.”
The room was very still.
“Sebastian.” Emily’s voice was quiet, but there was nothing soft in it. It was firm, almost fierce. “Caroline was not the only person who believed in you.”
He looked at her.
“William has trusted you for years, not as an amusement but as his closest friend, his cousin, the man he stood up beside at his own wedding. And Phoebe…” Her voice caught, just slightly. “Phoebe is calmest in the whole world when you are in the room. She checks for you before she does anything new. She crawls into your lap without thinking. A child does not do that with a man she believes to be nothing but charming. Children know. They always know.”
He could not answer at once. He had spent so many years certain that the world saw straight through him to the emptiness he suspected lay beneath, so to hear it laid out otherwise by her, of all people, who missed nothing and flattered no one, was almost more than he could bear.
“You have spent so long insisting that no one sees you,” Emily said, “that I do not think you have noticed how many people do.”
He looked at her for a long moment.
“And you?” he asked at last. He had not meant to ask it. It came out anyway. “Do you believe in me, Emily?”
She held his gaze.
“I would not be sitting here fighting beside you,” she said, “if I did not.”
He reached over and took her hand, only for a moment, a brief press of his fingers around hers, and then he made himself let it go. “Thank you,” he said simply.
The house felt suddenly too small to hold all of it, and he could not sit in that room another moment with Lady Hartley’s words still ringing in his ears. He pushed back his chair.
“Come. I cannot think about that woman a moment longer. Walk with me.”