AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Earl’s Unlikely Little Family

Page 40

by Hanna Hamilton

“Right. May I speak to the both of you now?” Pritchard indicated the drawing room as if he owned the house, and Sebastian quickly nodded, walking with him into the space.

He placed himself by the fire and withdrew a graphite pencil from his case along with something that looked like a ledger.

“So, Lady Everingham. Let me ask you the obvious question. You were aware of Lord Everingham’s reputation when you agreed to marry him?”

Instantly Sebastian wanted to speak up again, but beside him, Emily gently pressed her leg against his, and the connection served to instantly calm him.

“Of course, I was aware of his reputation,” she said. “He is cousin to my sister’s husband after all. Besides, anyone who reads the scandal sheets should know that his reputation has been grossly over-exaggerated as scandal sheets like to do.” The man nodded. “Indeed. I have always known Sebastian to be, well, flirtatious but very respectful of the ladies in his company.”

“That is what your mother and sisters also said,” Pritchard said, and Sebastian looked up.

“You spoke to them?”

“Yes. I was at Rosebud Hall before I came here. They are, of course, biased, but I find that sometimes mothers, and especially sisters, have a habit of revealing things.”

For a moment Sebastian wondered what Eleanor and Anne could possibly have revealed to this man, but he pushed it to the side. They did not want Phoebe to end up with Lady Hartley any more than he did. Besides, they were fond of Emily. Both sisters had told him so themselves.

“Now, I will say something that has given me pause is the speed with which you were married. It was not a few weeks ago that you held a house party to find a wife—is that not true, Lord Everingham?”

Sebastian swallowed. “Yes, this is true. I did. And I did not find a single suitable candidate—because, I suppose, in the end, my heart already belonged to somebody else, even if my mind could not quite admit to it.” He looked at Emily, who smiled at him, and he found himself wishing with every fiber of his being that her smile was genuine. But this was pretend. They both knew this. They both knew that they had to be excellent actors.

“I see. And so, you decided to propose. How, exactly?” He turned toward Emily, who shifted beside him.

“Well,” she said, “it was rather sudden. We were out in the rain, you see, because Phoebe had⁠—”

Sebastian placed his hand on hers, stopping her, because he knew that she was bound to tell the truth—nothing but the truth—and the truth was not going to serve them very well. Especially not if the story of the proposal started with Phoebe being lost in the rain.

“I had planned a proposal for quite some time,” he said. “Lady Everingham came to the estate after I lost my sister. Only a few days afterward. She wanted to pay her respects because she knew my niece from previous engagements and had formed a bond with her. I must say, when she arrived, it helped me more than I could have imagined. Phoebe scarcely spoke to anyone before—not even to my sisters or mother. But she opened up to Emily.”

“Perhaps because I was able to help her find her doll,” she said and curled her fingers around his hand which the solicitor sitting across from them took note of. Pritchard’s pencil scribbled across the page, his eyes on their hands.

“Her doll?”

“It had become misplaced in the move, and she was quite distraught. It was with her when the accident happened.”

“I see,” the man said.

“In any case, Lady Everingham remained to help look after Phoebe as she adjusted. It became very clear to me that she was the right woman. In fact, a part of me knew it before. The two of us have shared quite a few cotillions together.” He smiled. “And I must admit that I always admired her. But seeing her here, with Phoebe, truly opened my eyes—and my heart.”

“I see,” the man said again. “And the proposal?”

He was impatient. That was not good.

“Well, the day I proposed to her was also the day I received one of the letters from the Court of Chancery, informing me that Phoebe was perhaps to be taken from me if Lady Hartley’s suit succeeded. Phoebe, unfortunately, overheard some of the conversation, and grew very upset. She rushed away, and Emily and I went after her and found ourselves trapped in a cabin.”

“Lady Hartley told me that the child was missing for hours upon hours in the rain.”

Sebastian had a laugh. “That is Lady Hartley. Over-exaggerating. We knew where she was. My sister had seen her leave. She had shown her a cabin that had belonged to Phoebe’s mother, and we deduced right away that that was where she had gone. She was alone perhaps fifteen minutes—no more. Not ideal, but I do not think that any guardian can say they have never lost sight of their charge.”

“And let us not forget,” Emily chimed in, “that the reason she was upset was because of Lady Hartley’s continued efforts to remove her from our care against Phoebe’s wishes.”

“Indeed,” Sebastian said, proud of Emily for being so forceful.

“We arrived at the cabin, and after we were there, the storm increased. I would say from a night drizzle to a proper storm. We found ourselves trapped there, and Phoebe seemed very contented in the little cabin, so we decided to stay the night rather than risk taking her out into the storm.”

He glanced up, skyward, momentarily worried that all this lying he was doing was going to receive swift divine punishment, but lightning did not strike him down. Thus, he continued.

“Emily was so wonderful with her. She comforted her and was by her side, and I could see how much Phoebe adored her in return. I knew in that moment that I had to propose to her. I was so concerned with finding the right woman to be at my side to raise Phoebe that I did not immediately see that the right woman had been at my side all along. In a way, it was inevitable.”