Page 80
Liam’s chest went tight. “What story?”
“Dad. The stovepipe story.”
He hadn’t told it in five years. Catherine had told it. Every Christmas Eve, a new chapter, made up on the spot, Penny in the loft and Catherine sitting on the ladder with her feet dangling, because the cabin had no chimney, only the black stovepipe going up through the roof, six inches wide, and when Penny was three, she had cried because Santa would never fit.
So Catherine had made up a Santa who kept trying anyway.
“I don’t know if I remember how it goes,” Liam said.
“I remember. I’ll help.” Penny was already climbing the ladder. “You have to sit on the step. That’s the rule.”
He climbed up behind her and sat on the third rung from the top with his feet hanging. The loft smelled like cedar and her strawberry shampoo. She got under the quilt, pulled it up to her chin, and looked at him.
“Last time,” she said, “Santa tried to come through the window, and he got stuck, and Gerald had to push him.”
“Who’s Gerald?”
“Dad.” Penny looked offended. “Gerald’s the ninth reindeer. The little one. He’s not in the real list because he’s too small, so nobody writes him down, but he’s the only one who fits in small places. Mom said.”
“Right. Gerald.”
“You forgot Gerald,” she said.
“I didn’t forget Gerald. I was testing you.”
“You were not.”
He leaned his head against the ladder rail. “So this year,” he said, “Santa lands on the roof of the cabin.”
“On the snow.”
“On the snow. And he’s had a lot of cookies tonight, because every house in Skaneateles left him cookies, and the Hendersons left him three dozen, and he ate all of them because he didn’t want to be rude.”
Penny grinned at the ceiling.
“And he looks at the stovepipe. And he thinks, this year I’m going to do it. This year I’m going down the stovepipe like a normal Santa.”
“No,” Penny said. “Nooo.”
“He puts one boot in,” he said.
“Dad.”
“He puts the other boot in. And he wiggles. And he gets as far as his belly button, and then he stops.”
Penny was laughing into the quilt.
“So Gerald has to climb up on his hat and jump up and down on it. And Santa goes down one inch. And Gerald jumps again. And Santa goes down another inch. And then, pop.” Liam clapped his hands once. Penny jumped. “Santa shoots all the way down into the stove.”
“Into the stove? Was it on?”
“It was banked. Low. Just warm enough to toast his behind a little.”
Penny laughed so hard she started coughing. He waited while she got her breath back. Her eyes were wet.
“Then what?” she said.
“Then he leaves your presents, and he tries to go back up, and he can’t, so he has to use the door like everybody else. But when he pulled himself out of the stove, one of his boots came off, and it’s still up there in the pipe.”