AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Christmas Legacy

Page 71

by Kimberly Thomas

“Is the narrator you?” Penny asked.

“Fiction is rarely that direct.”

“That’s not a no.”

He set the mug down. “Parts of him are me. The parts that are afraid of change. The parts that organize around grief instead of moving through it. Those are mine.” He rubbed his thumb along the edge of the table. “The parts that are braver than me, those are the fiction.”

Penny considered this. She ate the candy cane from her cocoa, biting it in sections, the peppermint crunching between her teeth. Then she set the stick down and folded her hands on the table.

“Are you and Sylvie dating?”

“We’re figuring that out,” he said.

“What does figuring it out look like?”

“It looks like two people who care about each other and have complicated lives and are trying to be honest about what they want.” He leaned back in his chair. “It looks slow and careful and probably confusing from the outside.”

Penny tapped her finger against the cocoa mug. “Does it mean you’re done loving Mom?”

The cabin went still. The wood stove settled. The wind moved against the windows, and a branch scraped the roof, the birch that needed trimming, the one he’d been putting off since October.

“No.” He leaned forward, his forearms on the table, his hands open. “Mom is part of our family. That doesn’t change. It won’t ever change. She’s in your face and your laugh and the way you read with your finger on the margin. She’s in this cabin and in those socks and in every single thing I’ve written since she died.” He reached across and covered Penny’s hand with his. “Caring about Sylvie doesn’t revise what I had with your mother. It doesn’t replace her. It doesn’t compete with her.”

“Then what does it do?”

“It becomes part of the life we have now. Alongside everything else. Not instead of it.”

Penny looked at his hand on hers. She looked at his bare ring finger, the pale band of skin still visible, lighter than the rest, the mark of something removed but not erased. She turned her hand over beneath his and squeezed once, hard, the grip of a child who was learning that love can expand without subtracting.

“Can I keep these pages?” she asked. She touched the manuscript stack with her free hand. “I want to read them again.”

“They’re yours.”

Penny gathered the pages and tapped them straight against the table one more time. She picked up her cocoa and the manuscript and climbed the loft ladder, her socked feet gripping each rung. At the top, she looked down at him.

“The setting is lonely,” she said again. “But the narrator hasn’t given up either. I think that’s the part that’s you.”

She disappeared into the loft. He heard her settle into bed, the creak of the frame, the rustle of pages, her reading lamp clicking on.

Liam sat at the kitchen table with his cocoa going cold and the candy cane dissolved to a pink stub in the dregs. He looked at the keepsake box on his desk, Catherine’s library pin, the hospital photograph, the wedding ring resting on its side beside both. The lid was closed. He hadn’t locked it.

He picked up his phone and typed a message to Sylvie: Systems test passed. Everything held. Dale at eight tomorrow. Penny read the opening chapter.

Three dots appeared. Then: How did she respond?

She said the house feels lonely but hasn’t given up. Then she asked if I’m dating you.

A pause. Then: What did you say?

I said we’re figuring it out.

Another pause. Longer this time. Then: That’s accurate. Also slightly terrifying. Goodnight, Liam.

Goodnight, Sylvie.

He set the phone on the desk and closed his eyes. Tomorrow at eight, Dale Hendricks would walk through the house one more time. Tomorrow evening, the doors would open. Tomorrow was Christmas Eve.

He opened The Hollows on the laptop. He didn’t write. He read, from the beginning, page one, the way Penny had just read it, with his finger on the margin. He read his own words the way a stranger would, looking for the places where the prose tried too hard and the places where it trusted the reader. He found both, and he left them where they were, because the manuscript was his and it was imperfect and the imperfection was part of the truth.