AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Christmas Legacy

Page 69

by Kimberly Thomas

Tom McAllister and two volunteers from the school board were inside the safe section, on ladders, their hands full of paper stars and battery candles and fishing line cut to Nancy’s specifications. Each star had a position on Nancy’s chart. Each candle had an angle. Nothing was random.

Evan sat beside Nancy on an overturned crate, a clipboard balanced on his knee. He’d brought a printed calendar of medical appointments, parental-leave options from his firm, and a list of ob-gyn practices in the Syracuse area with ratings and drive times. The papers were organized in a folder with color-coded tabs, and when Nancy saw them she looked at him for a long time.

“You formatted it like Sylvie would,” Nancy said.

Evan turned a page. “That’s not an insult, I hope.”

“No.” Nancy pulled the folder toward her and studied the appointment schedule. “It’s just strange to find it useful.”

She made three notes on the calendar with her green pencil and handed it back to him, and they didn’t discuss it further. The ease of that, the absence of a larger conversation where a smaller one sufficed, told Sylvie more about where Nancy and Evan were heading than any declaration would have.

Mara arrived at two. She walked the path slowly, stopping at each of Nancy’s three markers, studying the installation through the glass. At the second marker, she crouched and looked up through the lower panes, where the deepest stars were visible, the ones hung closest to the iron crossbeams, catching the faint December light and holding it in their creased folds.

“There’s a sentence on one of the stars,” Mara said. She squinted through the glass. “Too small to read from here.”

“They all have sentences,” Nancy said from her chair. “Every star has a line written inside the fold. You can’t read them from the path. That’s the point. The details belong to the people who lived them.”

Mara straightened and looked at Nancy. She nodded once, a slow, weighted dip of her chin, and moved to the third marker without speaking.

By three o’clock, the installation was complete. The volunteers climbed down from the ladders and filed out through the side door, and Nancy asked Evan to help her stand so she could walk the path alone. She moved slowly from the first marker to the third, her eyes on the glass, her hand resting on her stomach. At the third marker she stopped and stood for a long time, looking at what she’d built.

Sylvie let her look. She stood at the first marker and watched her sister at the far end of the path, a small figure in a heavy coat with a blanket trailing from the crook of her arm, silhouetted against the greenhouse glass.

Inside, the parlor was warm. The volunteers had finished the final display arrangements: Walter’s seven photographs on the shelving, the paper village on the mantel with Penny’s repaired house in the center, the dining room table set for refreshments. Garland hung from the staircase. The tree was lit. The house smelled like balsam and the cinnamon sticks someone had tucked into the garland bows.

Sylvie found Nancy in the dining room, arranging their mother’s Christmas decorations on the sideboard. The ceramic nativity set, the painted wooden nutcrackers, the silver candlesticks that had been in the family since before either of them were born. Nancy was placing each piece with the same precision she brought to the lantern installation, measured, deliberate, each object given its own space.

Sylvie picked up the smallest nutcracker, a soldier, four inches tall, one arm chipped at the elbow. She’d broken it when she was nine, slamming a door too hard, and Mom had glued it back with the visible seam still showing because she said a repaired thing shouldn’t pretend it was never broken.

“I don’t know how to think about her now,” Nancy said. She was holding a ceramic angel from the nativity, turning it slowly between her fingers. “Before you told me about Dad, I had a version that made sense. She was difficult and loving and stubborn and generous, and the difficult parts were the price of the generous parts, and I accepted that.” She set the angel on the sideboard and adjusted its position. “Now I have a different version, and the new one has more information and makes less sense.”

Sylvie set the chipped nutcracker beside the angel. “You don’t have to reduce it to good or bad.”

“People keep saying that. It doesn’t help as much as they think it does.” Nancy picked up a silver candlestick and polished a smudge from the base with her sleeve. “She helped Mara. She helped families we don’t even know about. She kept women and children safe in this house for twelve years.” She set the candlestick down. “And she made us carry things we shouldn’t have had to carry. She used our labor without telling us what it was for. She asked you to lie. She kept me close by keeping me uninformed.”

“Both of those are true.”

Nancy was quiet for a moment. She lined the two candlesticks on the sideboard, adjusting the spacing between them with her finger.

“I still miss her,” she said. She said it flat, testing the sentence for accuracy, checking it against the new information and finding that it still held. “Even knowing what I know now. Even angry. I still miss her.”

Sylvie looked at her sister. Nancy was staring at the candlesticks, her jaw tight, her hand resting on the sideboard beside the angel and the chipped nutcracker, the Christmas decorations of a woman who had been dead for three weeks and present in every room of this house.

“So do I,” Sylvie said.

It was the first time she’d said it. Three weeks. Three weeks of her mother’s files and her mother’s secrets, her mother’s guest room, her mother’s chair, and she hadn’t said it once. Not to Nancy, not to Liam, not to herself. She’d organized around the grief instead of walking through it, and the walking-through had been waiting for her the whole time, patient, certain, refusing to be managed into a spreadsheet.

Nancy looked at her. Her eyes were red but dry, and her face held an openness that had nothing left to protect. “Do you regret leaving?”

“I regret the years we lost. Not the life I built.”

Nancy considered this. She picked up the ceramic angel and held it in her palm, studying the painted face, the chipped wing, the particular expression the artist had given it, serene and distant, the way angels look in paintings. Then she set it back on the sideboard and turned to face Sylvie fully.

“I regret staying in ways that made leaving feel impossible,” Nancy said. “Not the life I built either.”

They stood together beside the sideboard, the Christmas decorations between them, the nutcrackers and the candlesticks and the nativity and the thirty years of ornaments and objects their mother had collected and displayed and packed away and brought back out, every December, in a house that was never going to stop asking them to choose how much of her to keep.

Sylvie didn’t try to resolve it. Neither did Nancy. They stood with it, the anger and the love and the missing, all of it present in the same room at the same time, and the not-resolving felt more honest than anything either of them could have said to make it smaller.