Page 57
Sylvie looked at her sister. “Part of me does.”
Nancy nodded. She wrapped both hands around the mug of tea Sylvie had set out for her and held it without drinking. “Then make a real decision. One that still makes sense in February, after the decorations come down and the house is just a house again. One that’s based on what you actually want, not guilt, not anger at Mom, not because the town expects it.”
She paused. She looked at the recipe card on the table, and her thumb traced the edge of it: the butter stains, the flour, the handwriting they both recognized from grocery lists and Christmas labels and seventeen years of notes they’d found scattered through this house.
“Not because of Liam,” Nancy said.
Sylvie’s breath caught. “Liam isn’t why I’d keep it.”
“Good.” Nancy took a sip of tea. “He shouldn’t be why you sell it either.”
The kitchen was quiet. The snow fell past the window. The recipe card sat between the two futures, Julian’s clean numbers and Sylvie’s broken ones, and the cranberry bread stains on the card were darker than either column of figures, older, pressed deeper into the paper by years of a woman’s hands.
Sylvie picked up the recipe card and held it. She read the last line on the back, in her mother’s handwriting, added in pencil below the baking instructions:
Cool completely before slicing. I know you won’t. You never do.
She closed her eyes and held the card against her chest. Then she opened her eyes, set it back on the table, pulled the laptop toward her, and opened a new spreadsheet.
Nancy watched her. “What are you doing?”
“Finding the money.” Sylvie’s fingers moved across the keys. “The gap is real. Julian’s right about that. But I haven’t exhausted every option, and I’m not making a decision until I have.”
Nancy sat with her tea and watched her sister work. Outside, the snow thickened. The Christmas lights on the neighbor’s fence blinked their patient rhythm. And on the kitchen table, between a developer’s offer and a broken forecast, a recipe card held its place, butter-stained and flour-dusted and written in the hand of a woman who never waited for the bread to cool.
29
Liam
Noah was sitting at the kitchen table at six a.m., his phone in one hand and a piece of paper in the other, and he looked like he hadn’t slept.
The paper was a letter. Liam could see the legal header from the doorway, Elise’s attorney, a firm in Syracuse. Noah was reading it for what was clearly not the first time, his thumb pressing a crease into the margin where he’d been folding and unfolding the same corner.
Benji was still asleep upstairs. The house was quiet. Liam poured coffee and sat across from Noah and waited.
“Elise’s lawyer wants documentation of my living situation,” Noah said. He set the letter on the table and smoothed it flat with both hands. “A written statement from the property owner confirming my housing arrangement, the terms of the stay, and the condition of the space. Plus references.” He rubbed his eyes with the heels of his palms. “She’s filing for a formal custody agreement. I knew she would. I told her I wanted one too. But seeing it in a letter from a lawyer makes it feel like I’m being audited.”
Liam turned his mug a quarter turn on the table. “Can I ask what happened? You don’t have to tell me.”
Noah scraped at a dried coffee ring with his thumbnail. “Nothing dramatic. We got married young and we were bad at it. When she asked me to leave, I left. I didn’t have anywhere lined up. I thought I’d figure it out in a week.” He flattened his hand on the letter. “That was last spring.”
“And Ruby?”
“A teacher at Benji’s daycare gave me her number. I’d run out of couches. I didn’t want Elise finding out I had nowhere to take him.”
Liam picked up the letter and read it. The language was professional and specific, not hostile, not threatening, just the dry, careful prose of an attorney building a file. It asked for verifiable housing. Documented employment. A character reference from someone who could speak to Noah’s parenting.
“This isn’t an attack,” Liam said. He set the letter back on the table. “This is an attorney doing her job. Elise wants a custody agreement, and her lawyer needs to show a judge that both parents have stable living situations. That’s standard.”
Noah crossed his arms over his chest and gripped his biceps. “I know it’s standard. It just feels like I’m being asked to prove I’m a good father on paper, and paper doesn’t know anything about who I am at two a.m. when Benji’s scared and I’m the one who gets up.”
“Paper is how judges make decisions. And right now, paper is your friend.” Liam leaned forward. “You’ve got a signed housing agreement with the property owner. You’ve got documented employment, the invoices I’ve approved, the work log. You’ve got references from two contractors and a cabinet shop.”
“The letter asks for a character reference from someone who can speak to my parenting.”
“Ruby.”
Noah looked up. “Ruby barely knows me.”