AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Christmas Legacy

Page 51

by Kimberly Thomas

Nancy rubbed her eye with the heel of her hand. “I thought you’d interrogate him. I told him you would.”

“I considered it.”

Nancy stared at her. Then a sound came out of her, short, rough, startled out of her chest before she could stop it. A laugh. Tired and reluctant and real. Sylvie’s mouth pulled sideways. She bit the inside of her cheek, but the laugh got through anyway, smaller than Nancy’s, caught between her teeth.

They stood in the hallway and continued to laugh, briefly, quietly, the sound dying out almost as quickly as it had arrived. It surprised them both. Nancy wiped her eye again, shook her head, pulled her cardigan tighter, and went upstairs without saying anything else.

Sylvie watched her go. Then she turned toward the front of the house.

Liam was at the base of the staircase, kneeling beside the railing he’d been reattaching. He had a drill in one hand and a level balanced on the banister, and he looked up at her as she came through the hall.

“How’s the railing?” she asked.

“Solid. Two more bolts and it’ll hold.” He set the drill down and rested his forearm on his knee. “How’s Evan?”

“Reasonable. Careful. Good with drainage.” She stopped beside him, her hand on the newel post. “Some things get harder the longer you postpone them.”

Liam looked at her. She held his gaze, and they both knew she wasn’t talking about the railing.

“Yeah,” he said. “They do.”

Sylvie let her hand slide off the newel post. She walked to the office and closed the door. Liam picked up the drill and turned back to the banister. The house held them both, each in their own space, while the December dark pressed against the windows. Outside, the porch light came on by itself. Delia had set the timer years ago, and it still turned the light on at the same hour every evening, whether anyone was home or not.

26

Liam

The house was quiet by midnight.

Evan had driven back to the inn after dinner. Nancy had gone upstairs early, moving slowly, one hand on the banister. Noah had carried Benji to the Lake Room at nine, Pickle tucked under the boy’s arm, his dinosaur boots dangling from Noah’s free hand. The volunteers were gone. The lights were off, except for the corridor and the porch.

Liam was on the porch because he couldn’t sleep and because the cabin felt too small tonight. He sat on the top step with his coat zipped to his chin, his boots leaving dark marks on the frost that had hardened along the wood. The sky was clear. The stars were out, actual ones, sharp and cold above the tree line, and the town’s Christmas lights were visible through the bare branches, a distant smear of white and gold along the lakefront.

He heard the door open behind him but didn’t turn around. He knew the sound of her footsteps by now. They were lighter than Nancy’s and quicker, as if she were always running a little late for something.

Sylvie sat beside him on the step. She’d put on her coat over pajama pants, and her feet were in the wool-lined boots she kept by the door. Her breath made small clouds in the cold air. She didn’t speak. She sat with her hands in her coat pockets and looked at the yard.

A full minute passed. Liam counted it by his breathing.

“Edinburgh isn’t the problem,” Sylvie said.

He turned his head. She was looking at the greenhouse, her profile sharp in the porch light, her jaw set.

“The residency, the writing, Scotland. That’s not the problem.” She pulled her hands from her pockets and pressed them together between her knees. “The problem is that you let me believe you were building something here while you had one foot somewhere else. You let me plan around a version of the future that was missing a piece. And I’ve already lived that, Liam. I lived it for six weeks in this house when I was twenty-one, and it almost destroyed me.”

“I know.”

“Do you? Because you sat on this porch four days ago and I asked you directly, and you said ‘I’m not going anywhere right now.’ That’s not a lie. It’s worse than a lie. It’s a true sentence designed to avoid a true conversation.”

He leaned forward and rested his forearms on his knees. She was right. Every word. The collar of his coat was cold against his jaw. He pressed his chin into it and looked at the steps.

“I wanted to be chosen,” he said. “By the program and by you. I wanted both, and I was terrified that saying it out loud would force me to choose. So I kept Edinburgh in a drawer and I kept showing up here and I told myself I was being practical when I was being afraid.” He turned to look at her. “I used Penny’s stability as a reason not to decide. She called me on it three days ago. She’s ten and she saw it before I did.”

Sylvie’s hands pressed harder together between her knees. “I’m not asking you to turn it down.”

“I know you’re not.”

“But your choice changes the shape of what’s possible between us. And pretending it doesn’t—that’s not honesty.”