Page 42
“The asking.” She looked at him. “The asking is what makes it wrong. Not my age, not the circumstances, not the money or the house or the holiday. She asked. That’s the act. Everything after that, the silence, the pretending, the years I spent trying to figure out what I owed her, that all flows from the asking. And nobody says that. They say she was in a difficult position. They say she was doing her best. They say I should understand why she made the choice.”
“An explanation can exist without becoming an acquittal.”
Sylvie went still. Her hands loosened on the step. She looked at him, and her face did something he hadn’t seen before: the composure didn’t crack; it dissolved. For three seconds, the armor was gone. She was just a woman sitting on a porch step in December, hearing the thing she’d needed someone to say for seventeen years.
“Say that again,” she said.
“An explanation can exist without becoming an acquittal.” He crossed his arms against the cold and held her gaze. “Your mother had reasons. Her reasons don’t make it okay. You can understand why she did it and still be angry that she did it. Those aren’t in conflict.”
Sylvie pressed her lips together. She breathed through her nose, once, twice, and her eyes filled. She didn’t wipe them. She let the tears sit there, blurring her vision, and she held Liam’s gaze through them.
“Thank you,” she said. Her voice was rough. “For not trying to fix it.”
“I can’t fix it.”
“I know. That’s why the thank-you means something.”
They sat on the porch together in the December cold. The sun moved across the yard, pulling the shadows of the birch trees slowly east, and the house was quiet behind them, quiet upstairs where Nancy was learning a new shape for her childhood, quiet in the kitchen where Benji’s crayon station sat empty and waiting, quiet in the office where a red ribbon lay on the floor where no one had picked it up.
The front door opened. Nancy stood in the doorway.
She was dressed. She’d put on shoes and was carrying an armload of paper lanterns, six of them, finished, each one assembled from panels of translucent paper she’d cut and folded and glued by hand. They were beautiful and fragile, and Nancy held them against her body with both arms, her chin resting on the top one to keep it from sliding.
“I’m going to the greenhouse,” she said. Her voice was hoarse. Her eyes were swollen. She looked like she’d been crying for hours, and she probably had.
“Nancy…” Sylvie started.
“I’m going to install these in the front section. The safe section.” Nancy’s arms tightened around the lanterns. “I can cry upstairs or I can work. I’m choosing work.”
She stepped past them, down the porch steps, carefully, each step deliberate, the lanterns shifting in her arms, and walked across the yard toward the greenhouse. Halfway there, she stopped. She adjusted her grip, pulling one lantern that was slipping back into place, and pressed her chin harder against the stack.
Then she bent forward. Her shoulders curled inward. One hand came up to grip the top lantern, and her fingers shook visibly against the paper. She stood like that for five seconds, bent, shaking, holding the lanterns and herself together through sheer stubbornness, and then she straightened. She pulled her shoulders back. She kept walking.
Liam watched her. Beside him, Sylvie had gone very still, her hands gripping the porch step, her knuckles white.
“Should I go after her?” Sylvie whispered.
“No.” Liam watched Nancy reach the greenhouse path and fumble with the key, the lanterns balanced on one hip, her free hand trembling as she worked the lock. “Let her work. It’s how she holds things.”
“It’s how I hold things too.”
“I know.”
Nancy got the door open. She disappeared inside, and through the glass they could see her moving between the crossbeams, hanging the lanterns one at a time, reaching up to attach each one to the fishing line with hands that were still shaking. She hung the first one, stepped back, and studied it. Even from the porch, through frosted glass and fifty yards of December air, Liam saw her face change as the lantern caught the morning light and glowed. Grief gave way to purpose.
She reached for the second lantern.
Beside him on the step, Sylvie exhaled. She released her grip on the wood and pressed her palms flat against her thighs. She watched her sister through the greenhouse glass, and her mouth moved, silent, the shape of a word she didn’t say out loud.
Liam didn’t ask what the word was. He sat on the porch railing with his coffee going cold in his hand and the wrench on the step beside him and the bright December sun on his face, and he watched both sisters from the only position available to him, close enough to see them, too far to reach them, and not sure which one needed him more.
23
Sylvie
Nancy collapsed on the greenhouse path.
Sylvie saw it from the kitchen window: Nancy coming back across the yard with an empty canvas bag over her shoulder, her boots leaving clean tracks in the snow, walking steadily. And then she wasn’t. Her knees folded sideways, and she caught herself with one hand against the frozen ground. The canvas bag slid off her shoulder. She didn’t get up.