AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Christmas Legacy

Page 40

by Kimberly Thomas

“That December, the Christmas I was twenty-one, I found out. I came home early from a holiday party and saw him in the parking lot of the Lakeside Inn with a woman I didn’t recognize. They were in his car. It was obvious what was happening.” Sylvie’s voice was steady, but her hands were trembling against the desk. She pressed harder. “I drove home and didn’t say anything. I couldn’t figure out who to tell or what to do, so I did nothing for two days. And then I told Mom.”

Nancy’s breathing had changed. Short, shallow pulls through her nose. “You told Mom.”

“I went to her in this office. I sat in that chair.” Sylvie pointed to the chair Nancy was sitting in. “And I told her what I saw.”

“What did she say?”

Sylvie closed her eyes for a second. She could still see her mother’s face, the way Delia had looked up from the desk and set her reading glasses down, folded her hands, listened without interrupting, and the way her expression hadn’t changed, hadn’t shifted, hadn’t cracked. Because she already knew.

“She already knew,” Sylvie said. “She’d known for months. Maybe longer. She told me she’d found out in the fall and that she and Dad were handling it privately.”

Nancy pulled her hand off the binder and pressed it flat against her chest, fingers spread. “Handling it how?”

“They were going to separate. After Christmas. That’s what the notation means, ‘Final decision after Christmas.’ Dad was going to move out in January. They’d agreed to get through the holiday season because the house couldn’t afford a scandal. They were already behind on the boiler payments, the vendors were past due, the second mortgage was under review.” Sylvie swallowed. “Mom asked me to stay quiet through Christmas. She said if people found out before the holidays, it would destroy the house’s reputation, and the house was all she had.”

Nancy stood up. The chair scraped back hard against the floor. She walked to the window and stood with her back to Sylvie, her arms wrapped tight around herself, her shoulders drawn up to her ears.

“Both of them knew,” Nancy said to the glass. “Both of them decided I shouldn’t be told.”

“Yes.”

“And you… you kept it too.”

“I was twenty-one. Mom was standing in front of me asking me to hold the family together through Christmas, and I didn’t know how to say no to her. I’ve never known how to say no to her.” Sylvie’s voice broke on the last sentence, a hairline crack she couldn’t plaster over. She pressed her hands harder against the desk. “I kept it through Christmas. And then Dad had the heart attack in February, and it never mattered anymore. The affair ended because he died. The separation never happened. And Mom rebuilt the story so that none of it existed.”

Nancy turned from the window. Her face was white. Her eyes were red. “She rebuilt it for me. She let me believe they were happy.”

“She let you believe the version that kept you here. The version that made this house feel like a safe place.” Sylvie’s hands lifted from the desk and dropped back down. “I couldn’t live inside that version anymore. That’s why I left.”

“You left because she asked you to lie.”

“I left because I did lie. For six weeks. I sat at that Christmas table and watched Dad carve the turkey and listened to Mom tell guests about their anniversary trip and I smiled and I passed the rolls and I didn’t say a word.” She was crying now. She hadn’t planned to cry, but the tears came anyway, sliding down her cheeks without permission. She wiped them with the heel of her hand. “I couldn’t stay in a house where loving someone meant agreeing to pretend.”

Nancy gripped the windowsill behind her with both hands. Her knuckles were bone white. She stared at Sylvie. Her face changed too fast to follow: anger, then disbelief, then grief. Something worse settled in after that, a slow understanding. Everything she thought she knew about her childhood was shifting, and none of it looked the way she remembered.

“So my entire relationship with Mom…” Nancy’s voice shook. “Was that manufactured?”

“No.” Sylvie wiped her face again. “No, Nancy. She loved us. I believe that. She loved us and she also used love to make impossible choices feel like the only option. Both of those things are true, and I’ve spent seventeen years trying to figure out how to hold them at the same time, and I still can’t.”

Nancy’s grip on the windowsill loosened. Her hands dropped to her sides. She stood very still for a long moment, and then her face crumpled, a fast, total collapse, chin dropping, mouth pulling down, the sound that came out of her closer to a gasp than a sob. She covered her face with both hands and held it there, bent forward at the waist, her shoulders shaking.

Sylvie stood. She crossed the room and poured water from the carafe on the credenza. She set the glass on the windowsill beside Nancy and stood close enough that their arms were almost touching.

Nancy took the water. She drank half of it in one pull, set it down, wiped her face on her sleeve, and pressed her wrists against her eyes. Her breathing was ragged.

“Do you think my whole life here was a lie?” Nancy asked, her voice muffled behind her wrists.

“I think Mom loved you. I think she also kept you close by keeping you uninformed, and I think she knew the difference and chose not to examine it.” Sylvie touched Nancy’s elbow, lightly, briefly. “Your love for her was real, Nancy. What she built with you was real. The parts she left out don’t cancel what she put in.”

Nancy lowered her wrists. Her eyes were swollen. Her nose was running. She looked like a woman who had been punched, which, in some ways, she had.

“I need to be alone,” she said.

“Okay.”

Nancy walked toward the door. She stopped with her hand on the knob and looked back. “I don’t forgive you for waiting seventeen years.”

“I know.”