Page 29
“They’re not hard.” Penny set the skates on the bench beside the manila folder. “You just go forward.”
Sylvie took the skates.
She sat on the bench and pulled off her boots, tucking them beneath the seat with the organized precision she brought to everything. She laced the skates slowly, testing the fit, pulling the tongue forward and settling her heel back the way someone does who learned to skate as a child and whose body remembers the sequence even when the mind insists it’s forgotten. She stood and wobbled once and caught herself on the boards with one hand.
“Ready?” Penny was already on the ice, one hand extended across the railing.
Sylvie took it.
They made one slow lap together. Penny held Sylvie’s hand and skated backward the whole way, never once looking behind her, the way kids do before anyone teaches them to watch where they’re going. Sylvie’s strides were cautious, short, flat-footed, her free arm extended for balance, but by the second turn she’d found a rhythm, her weight shifting from blade to blade, her shoulders dropping from somewhere near her ears back to where they belonged.
Near the far turn, her right foot slid wide on a rough patch. She lurched sideways, caught the boards with her hip, and laughed.
The sound stopped Liam’s breath. It came out of her startled and unguarded, cracked open by surprise before she could compose it, a real laugh, full-throated, the kind that lives in the belly and escapes through the teeth. She didn’t try to hide it. It stayed, in her eyes, in the lines beside them, in the way her whole body softened for a single unprotected second.
He gripped the railing and watched her straighten up, brush the ice shavings from her coat, and take Penny’s hand again. He’d taught her to skate on the lake when they were twenty-one. Neither of them had known enough back then to be careful about any of it.
Noah arrived with Benji twenty minutes later. Benji was bundled into his puffy coat and a hat pulled so low it covered his eyebrows, giving him the appearance of a very small, very serious bank robber. He did not want to skate. He wanted to watch. Penny took him to the rubber mat beside the warming hut and walked him in his boots, holding both his hands, and Benji’s face split into a grin so wide that Pickle, tucked under his arm, was nearly crushed by the force of it.
Sylvie appeared at the boards beside Liam. She leaned her forearms on the railing, mirroring his posture, and watched Penny walk Benji across the mat. Noah stood by the warming hut with a cup of something hot, his shoulders looser than Liam had seen them since he arrived, the posture of a man watching his son laugh in a safe place and letting himself believe it for a minute.
The skating wound down as the temperature dropped. Families drifted toward the parking lot or the warming hut. Penny collected Benji from the mat and delivered him to Noah, and the five of them, Liam, Sylvie, Penny, Noah, and Benji on Noah’s hip, walked toward Cedar & Crumb for hot chocolate.
The town was lit for Christmas. Every shop window glowed. A horse-drawn carriage passed on Genesee Street, the bells on the harness marking time, and in the window of Hawthorn Mercantile, a model train circled through a miniature snow-covered town with a tiny church and a tiny general store and a tiny house with a wreath on the door. Benji pointed at it and informed Pickle that the train was going to the store to buy bananas.
Penny and Noah walked ahead with Benji between them. Liam and Sylvie fell behind, and the distance between the two groups widened without either pair deciding it should. The cobblestones were slick with frost, and their breath made separate clouds that briefly merged and then drifted apart.
“I always intended to leave,” Sylvie said. She was looking at the sidewalk, her hands in her coat pockets, her voice pitched for him alone. “New York was the plan before you. Before the summer.”
“I know,” Liam said.
“Did you resent me?”
He shoved his hands deeper into his vest pockets and watched the carriage lights disappear around the corner. “I resented that you acted as though leaving meant nothing had happened between us.”
Sylvie’s stride shortened. She turned her head and looked at him, and the Christmas lights from the shop windows caught in her eyes, small points of color, white and gold, reflected in the dark.
“Pretending it was easy made leaving possible,” she said. “If I’d let it matter, I would have stayed. And staying would have been wrong for both of us.”
“You don’t know that.”
“I know I was twenty-one and furious and carrying a secret that was eating me alive, and you were the one good thing in a summer that was falling apart.” She stopped walking. They were standing beside the window of a bookshop, its display filled with hardcovers and pine branches and a string of lights that blinked in a slow, patient rhythm. “You deserved better than what I was capable of that year. That’s the truth I didn’t know how to say at twenty-one. I’m saying it now.”
Liam turned to face her. The cold was sharp against his face, and the sounds of the town, the bells, the music, the distant laughter from the rink, felt far away and close at the same time.
“I met Catherine three years later,” he said. “She was the right person. I’ve never doubted that.” He rubbed his thumb across his opposite palm, pressing hard against the callus from the drill. “But the woman standing in front of me is not the girl who left. And I can’t pretend I haven’t noticed.”
Sylvie’s hand came out of her pocket. She pressed her fingertips against the bookshop window, a brief, unconscious touch, her fingers spread against the cold glass, and then she pulled them back and curled them into her palm.
“We should catch up,” she said. “Penny’s going to buy Benji a hot chocolate the size of his head.”
“She’s already bought it. She planned this entire evening.”
“She’s ten.”
“She’s her mother’s daughter.” He said it without thinking. Catherine’s daughter—a girl who orchestrated with a campaign manager’s precision.
They walked the rest of the way to Cedar & Crumb in a full but comfortable silence. The bakery windows were fogged with warmth, and through the glass Liam could see Penny at the counter, handing Dayton money from the zippered pocket of her coat with the seriousness of a business transaction.