AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Christmas Legacy

Page 17

by Kimberly Thomas

The porch light cast a long yellow stripe across the snow, and Nancy stood just at its edge, half in the light, half in the dark, the way daughters stand when they’re learning that the people who loved them most were also the people who told them the least.

9

Liam

Sylvie was waiting for him on the porch.

That was the first sign that something had changed. She didn’t wait on porches. She waited in offices, behind desks, with documents organized and questions prepared and a pen already in her hand. But this morning she was sitting on the top step with the register in her lap and a cup of coffee going cold beside her boot. When Liam came up the walk, she stood and held the book out toward him in the way you hand someone a piece of evidence, flat, open, letting him see it before he touched it.

“Tell me what you know about this,” she said.

Liam took the register. He recognized the binding, dark blue cloth, the same fabric Delia used on her correspondence journals. He opened it and read the first entry. M.B. and infant. Lake Room. Twenty-one nights. He turned the page. R.G. Garden Room. Fourteen nights. He turned another. Another. The initials accumulated in Delia’s slanted handwriting, and the weight of what he was reading settled into his hands like something that had been waiting to be held.

He closed the register and looked at Sylvie. Her arms were crossed. Her jaw was set. Her eyes were direct and searching, and he understood that the next sentence out of his mouth was going to change something between them, and the only question was whether the change would be a bridge or a wall.

“I suspected,” he said.

Sylvie’s fingers tightened on her elbows. “What does suspected mean, Liam? What specifically did you suspect?”

He handed the register back to her and sat on the porch railing, bracing his hands on the wood. The December air was cold enough that his breath showed, and he watched it dissipate for a moment before answering.

“Three years ago, Delia asked me to carry a crib from the attic to the Lake Room. It was November. No guests were booked. I asked who it was for, and she said a friend’s daughter needed a place to stay for a few days.” He rubbed the back of his neck. “I didn’t push it. A few days turned into three weeks. I saw a woman on the back stairs once, carrying an infant, and she looked at me like I was someone she needed to decide whether to be afraid of. Delia told me later that the woman had left and everything was fine, and I let that be the end of the conversation.”

“And the deadbolt?”

He looked at her sharply. She’d been thorough. She’d gone through the house and found the hardware.

“Delia asked me to install an interior deadbolt on the Lake Room door. The kind that locks from inside only.” He dragged his hand across his jaw. “I knew what that meant. A woman who needs a lock that works from the inside needs it for a specific reason. I installed it. I didn’t ask who she was locking out.”

Sylvie pressed the register against her chest and stared at him. Her lips were pressed together, and a muscle worked in the side of her jaw.

“Why didn’t you push harder?” Her voice was quiet. The quiet was worse than volume.

Liam looked at the yard. The greenhouse. The birch trees with their white bark peeling in the cold. The property he’d been maintaining for five years, the woman he’d been respecting for longer than that, the line he’d drawn between helping and asking because asking felt like a door Delia hadn’t invited him through.

“Because it was easier,” he said. “Because Delia had a way of making you feel like she had it handled, and questioning her felt like you were questioning the one person in the room who actually knew what she was doing.” He looked back at Sylvie. “And because I was living in her cabin with my daughter, and I didn’t want to push a conversation that might end with her asking us to leave.”

The honesty cost him. He felt it leave his chest like something with edges. Sylvie’s expression didn’t soften—he hadn’t expected it to—but something in her posture shifted, a fractional loosening of the arms crossed against her chest, as though the admission had answered a question she hadn’t fully formed yet.

“Show me the storage room,” she said.

Nancy was already inside when they came through the kitchen door. She was standing at the table with her hands wrapped around a mug of tea, her face pale, her hair pulled back in a knot that looked like it had been tied in the dark. She looked at Liam and then at Sylvie and then at the register still pressed against Sylvie’s chest.

“You told him,” Nancy said.

“I showed him. He already knew part of it.”

Nancy’s gaze moved to Liam. He met it and held it because looking away right now would have been a kind of lie.

“The crib,” Nancy said. It wasn’t a question.

“The crib. The deadbolt. A woman on the stairs I saw once and never asked about.” He pulled a chair from the table and sat down heavily, resting his forearms on his knees. “I should have asked. I’m not going to pretend otherwise.”

Nancy turned her mug in her hands, a slow, deliberate rotation, her thumbs pressing against the ceramic. “At least you admit it. She never would have.”

The three of them went to the storage room together. It was a narrow space beneath the back staircase, crowded with overflow, forgotten items, and years of things no one had bothered to throw away. Liam had been inside it once, years ago, to check the plumbing access panel. He remembered boxes and old curtains and the smell of mothballs

The boxes were still there, but between them, stacked on shelves Delia had installed along the back wall, were things that didn’t belong to a guesthouse. Toiletries in bulk packaging. Trial-size shampoos and soaps, the kind you buy in cases. A basket of transit cards, most of them expired, from bus systems in Syracuse, Rochester, and Utica. A grocery bag filled with small stuffed animals, bears, rabbits, a frog with a missing eye, each one clean and carefully arranged, as though someone had washed and sorted them and placed them here for the next child who needed something soft to hold.