Page 67
“It’s alright. Tucker sorted himself out. He’s got one of those computer jobs now. Lives off in exotic locales, but he drops by to see me on occasion. He was here just recently.” Damien tucked his phone away. “I miss the days when my son was younger though. When I also still believed teaching could make a real difference. The innocence and idealism of youth.”
“Like when you’ve just started a book and haven’t gotten to the sad parts?”
“Exactly, Ms. Mercer.”
Footsteps rattled the spiral staircase. “Hey, is that dessert?” Josie asked. “Nobody told me!”
“Theo managed to figure it out,” Damien said. “You were probably too wrapped up in whatever you were doing upstairs.”
Josie shoved half a tartlet in her mouth. “Probably.” The word was muffled by pastry. “I was listening to a podcast about black widow killers.”
Damien rested an elbow on the counter. “Did you read that article I sent?”
Josie nodded as she chewed, eyes going wide. “Oh, yeah!”
“Fascinating read, wasn’t it? What’s your assessment? Could it be a lead?”
“What are we talking about?” I asked. “Black widows?”
Josie swallowed. “No, no. Damien’s talking about that case Ella and I were working on. I showed you my binder a few weeks ago. There hadn’t been any new leads in the case in months, but Damien just sent me one yesterday. It’s very intriguing.”
Oh, right. The creepy binder full of true-crime stories. Because I didn’t have enough things making me jumpy lately.
“Sure, I remember. Your mission to bring light to the dark.” I turned to Damien. “You’re working on this investigation too?”
“I’m a bit of an amateur sleuth. Caught the bug listening to Josie and Ella. I try to keep an eye on the true-crime message boards. I’ve been known to frequent a Facebook group or two.”
Josie gave me an amused look. “There are so many people I would follow on all the platforms about this stuff, but Dad doesn’t let me use social media. I’ll show you what Damien sent me.”
She set her tartlet on a napkin and ran back up the stairs. A moment later, Josie was back with her three-ring binder under one arm. “I printed out the new article on Ella’s printer in the office. That’s okay, right, Delaney? I figured you wouldn’t mind.”
“Sure, you’re welcome to.”
Josie flipped open the binder and turned it to face me. The top article was a printout from an online news site:
Missing Hiker’s Body Found in Hart County Cabin, Ending Months-Long Search.
“What do you think, Josie?” Damien asked. “Could it be the White Knight Killer?”
A shiver passed through me. “The what?”
Josie started flipping pages in her binder. “It’s not an official name. Just what other true-crime investigators online call him. The authorities won’t even acknowledge that he exists. But if you look at the patterns, I don’t see how you can deny it.”
“It is rather compelling,” Damien agreed.
I glanced over the articles. They detailed suspicious deaths spanning the last dozen years or so, all along the Western Slope of Colorado.
“So you’ve been researching a serial killer?” I asked.
Josie nodded, seeming far too grown up for a girl of fourteen. “They call him the White Knight because he always goes after bad guys at first. Like drug dealers or domestic abusers. Guys who hurt women. But afterward, one of those abuse survivors will start feeling watched. Eventually, she ends up disappearing. Or just dead. That’s his pattern. The deaths or disappearances always happen in pairs.”
I found myself scanning the articles, getting pulled into the rumors and the speculation.
One woman’s neo-Nazi brother had overdosed, and then she was later found dead of carbon monoxide poisoning. Both deaths were supposedly accidents, but online commenters believed both were murder.
An abusive husband supposedly skipped town with no trace, and then his wife disappeared months later while hiking. Her body had just been found in an abandoned cabin. Strangled.
There were others too, all fitting the same apparent pattern.