Page 145
But I had to call Sheriff Thorne.
Damien stepped into the shed. “Only one cookie left. Just thought I’d—what’s that you have there?”
After checking to make sure Josie wasn’t in the doorway, I waved him over. I didn’t want Josie to overhear us. She was still working outside with her music playing, but I kept my voice down anyway.
My heart wasn’t quiet though. It was thumping a drumbeat in my chest.
“You won’t believe it,” I whispered. “Remember how I said Ella suspected my dad’s death was connected to the White Knight Killer? Well, she started writing me a letter about it.”
Damien went pale. Putting on his reading glasses, he reached for the sheets of paper.
By now, I’d already read Ella’s letter twice.
At first, Ella didn’t suspect Freddy Mercer’s death was anything but an accidental, if predictable, end to his tumultuous life. She’d been far more concerned about taking care of me.
If she’d heard gossip about a lack of any real investigation into my dad’s death, well…Ella never did have any sympathy to spare for the man. I hadn’t either.
But years later, when she’d come across the online rumors about the White Knight Killer, an idea had taken root in her mind and wouldn’t let go.
And it wasn’t just pure speculation. Ella had found a piece of evidence back when I was eighteen, something she had never understood. Couldn’t have understood.
But it was freaking me the hell out right now.
“Delaney? Damien?” a voice called out.
He folded the top of the letter down. I swallowed my nerves and turned around. “Hey, Josie.” My voice sounded tight. Way too cheerful.
“What did you guys find?”
“Um, more old papers,” I said. Damien nodded.
Josie’s eyes narrowed, studying us. “Then why’d you both jump when I said your names? And Damien, you hid what you’re reading.”
I took a deep breath and tried to give her a reassuring smile. My hands were shaking, so I clasped them together. “It’s some of Ella’s research into that true-crime stuff.”
“Oh. I was wondering where she stuck that.” Josie glanced down, chewing her lower lip. “I get it. You don’t want to show me.”
“I can’t, JoJo. You know that.”
“Yes. It’s okay.” She smiled sadly and shook out her hands, like she was shaking off the entire subject. “I have to leave pretty soon anyway. I’m supposed to bike over to Sophia Jessup’s house. For the sleepover?”
“Oh, of course, honey.” Josie had been biking here more often instead of riding with me. That way she could go visit her friends when she wanted.
“But I can empty our trash box in the dumpster first,” she said. “And I was gonna take the stuff to keep and put it in Ella’s office for now. That box is almost full.”
“Thanks. I really appreciate it.”
“I’ll text you when I arrive at Sophia’s.”
“Text your dad too. Okay? Have fun.”
Damien hadn’t said a word.
As soon as Josie was gone, he went back to reading the letter. His eyes were blinking fast, and his hand lifted to rub below his sternum. Almost like he had the same reaction as me. Even though that wasn’t possible. There was no way Damien understood just how disturbing this letter really was.
“What’s this card Ella mentions?” he asked. “She says here that someone left a card for you a few days after your father died, and for some reason she thought it was strange. I don’t understand why.”
And that was the exact reason I was struggling to stay calm.