AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Sweet Hearts

Page 267

by Laura Kain

“I’d thought versions of that about myself for years. Too much. Too difficult. Too exhausting. People leave eventually, so don’t give them enough of you for it to destroy you when they do.” I breathe out slowly. “Then you said what you said, and suddenly it didn’t sound like something ugly I’d made up in my own head anymore. It sounded like maybe somebody else could see it all too.”

My eyes burn badly enough that I have to blink hard.

“And the worst part was that it was you. You’re one of the people who knows me best. So when you looked at me like that, I thought maybe you’d finally seen whatever I was terrified Aiden would see.”

She presses the tissues against her mouth.

For a long moment, all I can hear is the noise of the café. Cups clinking. Someone laughing near the counter.

“I need you to understand how much it hurt.”

For a while, she doesn’t say anything.

Her hands are clenched around the tissues in her lap, and I can see her breathing through whatever she wants to say. She doesn’t rush to grab me or tell me she didn’t mean it.

I’m glad. I need her to hear me more than I need her to make me feel better.

When she finally speaks, her voice is rough. “I’m sorry.” She wipes at her cheek. “What happened that day wasn’t because I thought you were horrible, C. It was because I felt horrible. I had just found out that the man I thought I loved had a wife. I found out people around him knew things about my own relationship that I didn’t. His friends knew he was married. Levi knew about me. Who knows how many people looked at me and knew I was the stupid woman sleeping with somebody else’s husband.”

Her voice breaks, but she keeps going. “I stood on his doorstep and looked at his wife, and suddenly every good memory I had with him felt humiliating. Every time he’d canceled. Every excuse I’d believed. I felt like the stupidest person alive.”

My anger softens, but it doesn’t disappear.

“Then I saw you with that pizza. I realized there was this massive thing you’d been keeping from me too, and for a few minutes, all I could see was somebody else lying to me.”

She shakes her head.

“You weren’t Paul. You weren’t using me. You weren’t laughing behind my back or keeping secrets because you enjoyed making me look stupid. Aiden wasn’t me either. He knew what was happening between you. He was choosing you the entire time.”

Her fingers keep twisting around the tissues. “I was hurt and humiliated, and I wanted to hit back at somebody. And because I knew you, I knew exactly where to do it.”

That lands with more force than all her other apologies.

Worse. Better too, somehow.

At least it’s true.

“That’s what I’m sorry for. I wanted somebody else to hurt because I was hurting, and you were standing there.”

My chest feels flayed open.

“I knew better. I knew you better. I should’ve stopped. I should’ve listened.”

A tear slips down my cheek before I can stop it.

She looks wrecked. “I am so sorry. I’ll always remember that as one of the worst days of my life. And not because of Paul. Because you mean so much to me, C. You’re one of my favorite people and I hate that I made you feel that way.”

I sit there for a while, looking at our hands resting between us.

“I’ve been seeing my therapist again,” I tell her eventually. “She brought up depression at the start of the year, and I freaked out, stopped going.”

Abbie turns toward me, but thankfully she doesn’t do that awful sad head tilt people do when they’re about to say something unbearable.

“I told Gabe. Told Aiden too. I’m getting help.”

“I wish you’d told me,” she says softly.

I sigh. “Me too. Was busy trying to avoid telling myself.” I turn my hand over and take hers. “I don’t think we’re going to walk out of here and suddenly everything’s exactly how it was before.”