Page 265
There’s a heavy, sinking feeling in my chest. This isn’t the first time a boyfriend has cheated on Abbie.
“No,” she scoffs, looking pained. “He was cheating with me. He’s married.”
My mouth falls open.
“I didn’t know.” The words rush out, and I hate the fact she thinks she even needs to tell me that. Her eyes fly to mine again. “I swear, I didn’t. Everything was so good with us during the summer. I thought, finally, maybe this could actually be the one. Then as we got closer, he started acting off. Cancelling plans, taking forever to answer texts, always having some excuse for why I couldn’t go to his place.”
A vicious anger burns low in my stomach. Apparently, the protective part of me doesn’t give a shit that I’m still hurt. Somebody fucked with my Abbie and it wants blood.
Her hands drop to her lap.
“I’d met some of his friends when you were away that time. Most of them were nice, but there was this one guy, Levi, who was so gruff. I thought he just didn’t like me.” She pauses and stares at the table. “I was Christmas shopping that morning. The day I saw you with the pizza.”
My stomach sinks.
“I had bumped into Levi in the shopping center. He looked horrified when he saw me and asked what the hell I was doing. I had no idea what he meant, then he told me I should be ashamed of myself for sleeping with a married man.”
I think I might be sick.
Her voice cracks. “I told Levi he had no idea what he was talking about. Then I drove straight to Paul’s house. I’d only been there once before. Once in six months. Sounds pretty stupid now, doesn’t it? But that one time, the place was perfect. No pictures, no women’s things. He must’ve hidden everything because when I knocked…” She presses a hand over her mouth. “There she was.”
“Fuck, Abbie.”
For all the anger I’ve carried around since that awful day, she’s still Abbie.
Still my girl.
Years of loving someone don’t vanish because they were awful to you one day.
I stand, walk around the table, and slide into the seat beside her. She doesn’t seem to notice until my arm goes around her shoulders. Then she leans into me.
“I’m sorry, C,” she whispers against my neck. “I’m so sorry.”
I hold her while she cries because I can still hurt and hate that this happened to her.
“And if it makes you feel any better, I fucked things up with my sister too. Snapped at her for setting me up with Paul. She said she didn’t know he was married—just knew him from work and he never wore a ring. Which tracks for a slimeball. Didn’t stop me trying to blame her.”
I close my eyes. That doesn’t make me feel better at all.
Eventually, she sits back and wipes at her face. I grab a fistful of tissues from the dispenser and shove them into her hand.
She gives me a watery smile. “Thanks.”
“You look like shit.”
A tiny laugh escapes her. For half a second, something familiar settles between us. There’s a softness in her face now, like because I’ve moved beside her and held her, maybe we’ve reached the part where I tell her it’s okay.
I almost do. The words are sitting on my tongue.
It’s fine. I understand.
Except it isn’t fine.
Understanding why she did it doesn’t undo what happened.
And I’m done pretending I’m okay in moments that I’m not.
“You really hurt me, Abbie.”