AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

’Tis the Season to be Spellbound

Page 6

by Harper Wynn

Recognition sparked behind Carter’s fierce, blue eyes. He shrugged off his coat and hung it on a hook beside the door. His chest was broad beneath a thin, black long-sleeve. Another fleeting glance, another nervous fidget. Odd, Adrian thought, movements like that, how uncertainty furrowed his brow and ran across his skin.

“Yeah, Carter Monroe.” His voice was gentle on the edges, and Adrian wondered if he’d always been as soft-spoken as he was right then, caught like a fox in a coop, or if this was a front to keep their deal intact. “And you’re Adrian…?”

“Adrian Sibley.” He gestured to the sign above the register with a shrug.

Carter took off his beanie and fingered through short, wheat-blond hair. “This place is yours, I’m guessing?”

“My grandmother left it to me.” Adrian rolled his bottom lip between his teeth. He remembered the way she’d danced through the shop, mortar in one hand, pestle in the other, grinding flowers, tea and Himalayan salt together. Sometimes her voice slipped through the window, causing candles to flicker and smoke to shift. He was scared to say her name—Virginia—afraid his loneliness would spill at Carter’s feet if he did. “You’ve met…my—Bilbo,” he said, battling awkwardness. The rabbit nibbled on a celery stick next to the register. “And she’s obviously met you.”

“Yeah, I think we’re pretty well acquainted.” Carter laughed, and it was a surprise. A good surprise. The sound was rusty from going unused. He turned, eyes crinkled at the corners by a lovely, wide smile. “You did this, bunny,” he said under his breath. He crossed the store, careful to step over broken glass and a puddle of shower gel, and leaned down to look Bilbo in the eyes. “Can I pet her?”

Adrian had been wondering how long Carter had gone without laughing like that, and didn’t catch the question until Carter turned to look at him, smile fading into something smaller, something watched. “Oh, yes. Go ahead. You can pick her up.”

“Oh-hoh, I can pick you up,” Carter cooed. He pushed his sleeves to his elbows, revealing harsh, black lines. A wolf howled on his forearm. Koi swirled together over his hand. Black and grey tails fluttered across his knuckles. He scooped Bilbo into one hand and cradled her against his chest. “You’re so soft,” he mumbled, then turned his attention to Adrian. “She’s not even squirmy.”

“Yeah, she’s a good one. Likes to cuddle.”

“Is that right? Well, you still tripped me,” Carter whispered. He set his cheek on the top of her head. “Tried to break my neck.”

“And broke the store instead.” Adrian hoped the joke didn’t fall flat.

Thankfully, Carter smirked. “Injured it, remember?”

Adrian could’ve looked at him for hours. Not because he was handsome—he was very handsome—but because he was scarred in ways Adrian hadn’t seen before. They manifested differently than visible scars. These went deeper. Lived closer to bone. He saw them when Carter swallowed, how he occupied the least amount of space possible. Shoulders pinned to his body. Feet shuffling nervously, bumping together. And in his eyes, mostly. Incredibly blue in some lights and like coastal fog in others.

Carter’s lips parted. “Did I do something?”

Adrian steeled his expression. That was an accident, feeling for Carter’s wounds. He’d wanted to, but he hadn’t actually meant to. “What’d you get arrested for?”

There. Sadness filled the shadowed place behind Carter’s eyes, but only for a moment. Then he was all heat, blistering and sparking. His mouth pressed into a line and his brows pulled together, hands going still on Bilbo’s small body. Adrian’s mouth dried. He watched Carter sigh, noticed defeat settle over him like a cloud.

“I’ll give you my information if you want. You can run a background check on me,” Carter said. Same softness. Same hesitation.

Adrian crossed his arms over his chest. His binder was a comfortable weight, something heavy and his, a shield in times when closeness made his pulse quicken and his breath quake. “Or you could just tell me. I won’t gasp, I promise.”

Carter responded as if he’d walked into a test knowing he wouldn’t pass. “Armed robbery.”

“And?”

Silence. Got you. Adrian lifted a brow and met Carter’s gaze. His pupils fanned, eyelashes fluttered—an animal baring its teeth in the face of a rescue. Hostility was always the last-ditch effort before accepting help.

Carter opened and closed his mouth. Bilbo tried to climb onto his shoulder, and he curled his hand under her belly, placing her back on his chest. “There’s no and.”

Adrian nodded. “Thank you for telling me.”

“Thanks for…letting me make this right, I guess.”

Adrian studied the way his hands moved gingerly across Bilbo’s back, how he refused to make eye contact for too long and held his breath when he knew he was being watched. Carter Monroe had skeletons in his closet. Big ones, probably. But he held himself quietly. Uniquely so. And after getting a peek at him, a real one, Adrian found it hard to look elsewhere.

They took their time wiping sticky puddles off the floor and making trips to the dumpster on the backside of the shop. The morning deepened. Sunlight glittered on a dusting of snow and birds nestled in the garland strung over the doorway. Sibley Apothecary fell into comfortable silence, disrupted by the sound of shoes on freshly mopped floors.

Throughout the day, Carter perfected the art of small smiles and flighty glances. He cradled candles in his big palms as if they were porcelain and stayed mindful of the space he occupied as he dipped between displays. Quiet filled the empty pockets between them until Carter cleared his throat.

“What’s Yule?”

Adrian paused, finger hovering over the touch screen tablet on the edge of the cash wrap. “You’ve never heard of it?”

Carter shook his head. “Just in Christmas songs.”