Page 95
“A little, yes. Over the years, he got better. He did a decent job managing his depression, but by then, I was already an adult. I no longer needed him the way I did when I was a kid. He missed out on my childhood and had no idea who I had become. I was practically a stranger to him. And a constant reminder of what he’d lost. It hurt seeing the grief in his eyes every time he looked at me.”
My gaze drops to my hands, my vision blurring.
“Losing my mother left him petrified of losing me too, and he became suffocating. Every day, he stared at the spitting image of the love of his life, and maybe that’s why he holds on to me so tight. Because I’m the only piece of her he has left.” I swallow, remembering all the times I wished I could be someone completely different. After all these years, the memories are still sharp. “Once, I even dyed my hair blond, hoping that’d be enough for him to see me for who I was. His own daughter.”
“Lola,” Tyler murmurs, dropping his fork onto his plate with a clattering sound. There’s so much tenderness in the way he says my name that my chest aches. After a heavy breath, he gently, cautiously weaves his fingers through my hair, rubbing a strand between his thumb and index finger. His attention stays on the movement. “When I close my eyes at night, your black hair is all I see.”
My throat closing, I grasp his wrist, clinging to him as if he were a raft in the waters of my lonely sea. “You wouldn’t have survived the blond version, then.”
He lets out a sharp laugh. “Believe me, I’m hanging by a thread as it is.” He tucks the strand behind my ear, then drops his hand to my thigh where he rests it, heavy and comforting. “This is a lot to carry on your shoulders,” he murmurs. “Hard to imagine that twenty years later, your father hasn’t moved on. That he still relies on you so much.”
“Yeah.” I sigh. “For a while there, things were looking up. But about five years ago, he found out that my mother had remarried and had children.” A whole new life. Perfect and with no messy past to drag her down. “I made my peace with her absence a long time ago, but learning she built a new family with kids she chose to keep stung more than I’d ever admit to my dad.”
Tyler strokes my thigh with the tip of his thumb, grounding me.
“The news sent him back into a tailspin,” I add. “He went through several jobs, and I had to help him out financially. Still do because he’s so unpredictable. But I can’t give up on him, you know? He’s my dad, despite how shitty he can be. He’s my only relative, and I love him.”
His face softens. “Of course you do. I don’t think kicking him out of your life is the solution, but a good talk and some healthy boundaries might help him realize this dynamic is hurting you.”
I shrug. “Doubt he’d see where I’m coming from. Setting boundaries would mean distance, and that’d freak him out. Now that I’m an adult, he’s terrified that I’ll walk out on him too. That I’ll disappear overnight. Living in different towns is already hard enough.”
“So he’s intrusive, calls you all the time, monopolizes your attention, and makes you feel guilty when you’re not with him,” Tyler finishes.
“Exactly.” I sniffle. “But I understand his fears. So I do my best to reassure him that I’m not going anywhere. That he won’t lose me too.”
I don’t find the courage to tell him that while I spend so much time reassuring my father, I’ve never figured out how to stop drowning in the same fear myself. That I grew up terrified that the people I cared about would walk away, so I made myself indispensable. That I never learned how to love at a safe distance because I was too scared that if I held back, if I didn’t give and give and give, no man would ever want to stay. That every time a guy takes the slightest interest in me, I hand him my whole heart on a silver platter and get left holding the broken parts when he eventually tosses it away.
That he’s the first man other than my friends who didn’t disappear when I showed him the vulnerable, messy pieces of me.
So I keep those truths to myself, tucking them somewhere safe in my chest for a little while longer. Until I can make sense of them.
“Saying ‘It’s nothing tragic’”—he uses air quotes—“when you started explaining why you’re spending Christmas alone, and then proceeded to share the most devastating story I’ve ever heard, tells me all I need to know about how little you value yourself in all of this.”
He leans in closer and cups my knee, his large hand engulfing it, his gaze demanding my attention.
A tear rolls down my cheek as I force myself to look at him.
“Who took care of you, Lola?” he whispers. “Who listened to you? Who treated you like the kid you were? Gave you the childhood you deserved? Who comforted you when not only your mother, but your father neglected you?”
“I did?” I choke out through a sob.
Expression crumbling, he shakes his head. “Oh, Lola. No child is capable of that.”
Dammit.
Why am I crying on Christmas Eve? Why am I crying about this? It happened so long ago; I can’t even remember the last time I shed a tear over it. I furiously wipe away the tears streaming down my cheeks, but Tyler stops me.
“C’mere, angel.”
He pulls me onto his lap, draping my legs over one side, and hugs me tight against him. I bury my wet face in the dip of his neck, breathing in that scent that is so him.
“I’m so sorry,” he whispers, rocking me. He kisses the slope of my shoulder, his mustache tickling my skin and sending a long shiver down my spine. “No one should have to go through that. Least of all you.”
We stay like that for a while, the candles on the table nearly melted away, the lasagna gone cold. Tyler continues to apologize, though all he’s done since waltzing into my life is patch the holes in my heart. He apologizes for my dad. He apologizes for my mom. He apologizes for asking me to tell him that story on Christmas Eve and making me cry. He apologizes for being a dick to me when we saw each other that day at the lodge and for running away the first time we met last year.
He apologizes, and apologizes, and apologizes.
And as he does, his arms like a shield around my most tender wounds, it feels like everything I’ve lived through has brought me to this moment. And deep down, I know I’m not sorry about any of it.