Page 22
I raise a brow. “You know I’m gonna spend the rest of the night trying to change your mind now, right?”
“Always so competitive.” He shakes his head, a slow smile stretching across his lips.
The expression is like a blow to the solar plexus.
Charlee and Oli’s engagement party flashes through my mind. The easy banter between the two of us. The soft tension that grew and grew until he burst out of the photobooth and never looked back. What would have happened if he hadn’t? If I hadn’t made that dumb suggestion to pose like a couple? I asked myself that question for weeks afterward.
“Can I get you two lovebirds drinks?” Our server appears, wearing a grin and interrupting my thoughts. “Our special tonight is the French Kiss cocktail—Prosecco, gin, and raspberry liqueur.”
Heat floods my cheeks. “Oh, no, we’re not—”
“Water’s fine for me,” Tyler cuts in, his voice definitive. The server’s expression falters, his enthusiasm crumbling like he’s been slapped.
“I’ll take a glass of white wine, thank you,” I say with an apologetic smile, then turn to Tyler. “Are you sure you don’t want something? A Scotch, maybe?”
“Nope. Thanks.”
The server nods stiffly and retreats with our order.
As silence stretches, settling uncomfortably like the third guest at the table, I look down, fidgeting with the napkin on my lap. Why does this man have to make everything so weird?
“So,” Tyler finally says, leaning back and draping one arm over the back of the booth like he’s unbothered by the awkwardness. “Who is Lola when she’s not diving headfirst into romance novels?”
“She’s diving headfirst into rom-coms?”
His face falls and I let out a small laugh.
“I spend a lot of time working, to be honest with you.” I place the menu on the table and angle forward. “And when I’m not, I’m either with my dad or with my friends.”
“The ones I met today?”
I nod. “And a few others from Charlee and Oli’s engagement party.”
His hazel eyes flash at the mention of the party in a way I don’t understand. Weird.
So I move on, straightening a little. “What about you?”
“What about me?”
“What do you do when you’re not grumbling over romance novels?”
He tilts closer, elbows resting on the narrow table, his knuckles almost brushing mine.
“Grumbling over rom-coms.”
A pig-like laugh erupts from me. Horrified, I clamp a hand over my mouth and stifle the sound.
Tyler’s eyes glint, like he’s entertained by the embarrassing noise that escaped my lips. But he quickly glances away.
“I play rugby with my buddies when I can and help with our club’s operations. I also crochet in my spare time.”
I gape at him. “You crochet?”
He arches a brow. “Why? Is that weird?”
“No, no, not at all.” I tuck a strand of hair behind my ear. “More… unexpected. I have a tough time picturing you with yarn and a crochet hook in those big—” I swallow hard, my eyes dropping to his intertwined fingers resting on the table.
His lips curve into a smirk, heat flickering in his irises. “In those big what, Lola?”