Page 36
“She talked to her boyfriend earlier in the afternoon, telling him she was on her way to an important meeting,” Mel continued. “That’s the last time anyone heard from her. Three days later her vehicle was found abandoned on a stretch of dirt road near a small body of water called Gilbert Pond. Divers searched the pond but found nothing. At this point, her case is still officially classified as a missing person, but unofficially it’s being treated as a homicide.
“According to her boyfriend, one Max Lawford, he had proposed to her the previous Saturday night, and she turned him down. He claims there were no hard feelings—that she didn’t really turn him down, she said that she just wasn’t ready. So far, the boyfriend seems to be law enforcement’s only person of interest. Janelle’s mother, on the other hand, one LeAnn Williams, doesn’t believe the boyfriend had anything to do with it. I’ve got her number right here. Do you want to call her or should I?”
“How about we call her together?” I suggested. “Two heads are better than one.”
We did. Unfortunately the call went straight to voicemail, so I left a message.
After leaving my number, the only thing to do while waiting around for LeAnn to call us back was to continue combing through the records Todd had shipped us. The next two calls were heartbreaking. In both instances, one in Wyoming and one in California, we learned that human remains had been discovered but not yet positively identified. In other words, those two missing persons were most likely no longer missing. They were dead.
“It’s beginning to feel like this is a hell of a lot bigger than just one girl from Alaska going missing in Seattle,” I said at last.
“Obviously,” Mel agreed. “So what are we going to do about it?”
“What we always do,” I told her. “We solve it.”
Chapter 20
Palm Beach, Florida
Saturday, May 31, 2025
A deep rumbling sound, similar to distant thunder, awakened Alyssa out of a sound sleep. Rather than stare into the unrelenting glare from the overhead light bulb, she closed her eyes and lay there listening. After so many days of living in complete silence, hearing any kind of sound was somehow unnerving. After a few moments, she realized that something else was different. The boat or ship or whatever she was on was no longer tied up at a dock. It was moving. Where to? Why?
But why was a question she could neither answer nor deal with, so she got out of bed. There was no need to get dressed. She wore the same oversize jumpsuit waking and sleeping. Every three or four days—at least that’s what it seemed like—she’d find a clean jumpsuit on the floor next to her food tray, but today wasn’t one of those days. She did her daily routine—using the toilet, putting on a new pair of Depends, washing her face, checking the food tray where she learned it was once again a Special K breakfast. If she ever got out of here, she swore she’d never touch another bowl of dry cereal for the rest of her life.
After choking down breakfast, when it was time for her Pilates workout, the rumbling suddenly stopped and so did the sense of motion she’d felt earlier. Obviously something was happening, but she didn’t know what or why, and that terrified her.
Today’s play performance should have been Romeo and Juliet, but this time the show didn’t go on. She was too upset to remember the lines—her lines or anybody else’s either. That posed another problem. Reciting all those words—putting herself into the lives of all those characters—acted as an emotional buffer that kept her from thinking about the here and now. It also kept her from dwelling on how her parents were dealing with things—not only what had already happened but what was likely coming. Today that strategy didn’t work. Instead of putting on a show, she lay back down on her narrow bed where she found herself thinking about her parents.
Her father had always appeared to be gruff, but Alyssa knew he was really a teddy bear at heart. Her mother, on the other hand, someone who was petite and seemingly a lightweight, was tough as nails—your basic iron fist in a velvet glove. Alyssa had learned that lesson in spades on a fall Sunday afternoon when she was ten. She’d been in her room when her next older brother, Wayne, had come tearing into the house after wrecking his bike, screaming at the top of his lungs, “I broke my arm! I broke my arm!”
It wasn’t just a broken arm—it was actually an open fracture, with a piece of bloody bone protruding from Wayne’s forearm. Alyssa’s father had taken one look at that hunk of bloodied bone and fainted dead away. Fortunately he was watching an NFL game at the time and seated in his recliner. Before he came to, Alyssa’s mom had already loaded Wayne into the car and packed him off to the ER.
Later on the kids had tried teasing their dad about that fainting spell, but he’d had the perfect comeback. “I may have missed out on that trip to the ER,” he’d told them, “but I took care of dinner, didn’t I?”
Her dad had somewhat recovered and was getting ready to head to the hospital himself, when her mom had called saying she’d just been told that Wayne’s injured arm would require surgical intervention and that Wayne was on his way to the OR. Before leaving the house, her father had ordered a pizza for Michael and Alyssa, so yes, he had taken care of dinner. Then he’d headed for the hospital where he’d stayed at Wayne’s bedside until he was released two days later.
For Alyssa, remembering that long-ago incident gave her a sense of peace. Her parents were partners. Whatever they were dealing with now and no matter what might come at them in the future, they would fight that battle the same way they had faced everything else—together, shoulder to shoulder and side by side.
She was finally feeling better when the steady rumbling of the engines suddenly ended along with the sense of movement. Once again absolute silence returned to her cell. What was going on? Was this the end? Was this the time when whatever was going to happen to her would finally happen?
Turning over on her narrow bed, she buried her face in the thin pillow and sobbed—something she had somehow kept herself from doing the whole time she’d been here, mostly because she didn’t want whoever was watching her from that overhead camera to see her defeated. But in that moment she was done.
Finally, when no more tears came, she turned back over, stared directly into the eye of the camera, and began to speak. The words she spoke aloud weren’t part of any role she’d ever played onstage. They were ones that had been instilled in her long before her entry into that long ago freshman drama class. These she had memorized far earlier than that, back when she used to go to Sunday school every week.
“The Lord is my shepherd. I shall not want . . .”
Chapter 21
Palm Beach, Florida
Saturday, May 31, 2025
Alyssa Pemberton wasn’t the only prisoner locked in her cell and listening to the rumbling thrum of the engines. So was Janelle Williams. She had awakened that morning—she supposed it was morning—and was sitting on the toilet in the corner of her room when the door of her cell slid open and her food tray was shoved inside. But then, before the door could close again, she heard a woman’s desperate cry coming from somewhere else, most likely another room just like this one.
“Please, help me,” the voice pleaded. “I’m so sick. Can’t you give me something?”
At that point the door slid shut. If the woman said anything more, Janelle couldn’t hear it. There was soundproofing everywhere—on the walls and even on the door—that blocked out all sound except the low growling noise from the engines. But that overheard cry for help suggested that everything Janelle had dreaded in this appalling nightmare was probably about to come to pass.