Page 33
Gina struggled to pull herself out of a deep sleep and sit up. As she sat on the edge of the bed, waiting for the room to stop spinning, she realized that Bubba had once again drugged her, and she soon spotted the needle mark in her upper arm. She wasn’t sure how long she’d been out, but it really didn’t matter. Stumbling into the bathroom she realized the Depends had done their job. The ones she was wearing were soaked.
Sitting on the toilet, Gina felt lost. That last thing she remembered was eating ham and eggs and drinking a cup of coffee. Whatever had taken her out must have been one of those, but how long ago was that? She had no idea. And how long was she going to be stuck in this rolling prison? She had no idea how many days it had been, but it seemed like forever. Obviously Bubba had no intention of killing her, but where was he taking her and why?
“What the hell’s taking so long?” he demanded from the other room. “Do you need me to come in and help you?”
Jarred out of her reverie, Gina went to wipe herself. That’s when she realized that her period had started. Crap, she thought. How can things get any worse? Aloud, she said, “I’m okay. I’ll be out in a minute.”
Taking a deep breath, she tried to clear her head. She had a packet of tampons in her luggage, but she was damned if she was going to ask Bubba to bring her one. Whatever was going on with her body was none of his damned business. Instead she reached for the packet of dreaded Depends that was well within reach on the bathroom floor. After pulling a new pair up to her knees, she padded the crotch with several layers of toilet paper to guard against leaks.
“There’s another Waffle House just down the road from here,” Bubba said. “How about another helping of ham and eggs?”
“Why, so you can drug me again?” she demanded.
He seemed somewhat startled by the fact that she’d figured it out. “Sorry about that,” he said. “I may have overdone it last time.”
“You think?” she returned.
But the truth was, she really was hungry, and what did it matter if she was knocked out cold as they traveled? Chained to the bed, she wasn’t exactly seeing the sights.
“Ham and eggs sound good,” she added finally. “And coffee too.”
Chapter 19
Bellingham, Washington
Saturday, May 31, 2025
Over the years I’d become accustomed to Mel sleeping in on Saturday mornings. I had thought that might change once she retired, but we seemed to be continuing on that path. Sarah, however, doesn’t believe in sleeping late. She cold-nosed me out of bed at seven on the dot, asking to be let out. She has a doggie door that she chooses not to use, so I’m her doggie doorman.
Sarah was back in the house, fed, and I had my first cup of coffee in hand when I opened my iPad and discovered I had eighty-three new emails. Six were junk messages from different senders but almost the same verbiage, all them wanting to know if I was interested in selling my Seattle condo to an all-cash buyer. One was from my Medicare professional reminding me it was time for my annual physical. Thanks to Mel, we’d both done those back in April. The problem is, our long-term doctor is not on our health-care provider’s approved physician list. Instead, they’ve assigned me to a female doctor I’ve never met in person. Her office was the one attempting to set up the physical. Also on the health-care front was a message from Sarah’s vet saying it was time for her annual tooth cleaning ordeal.
Surprisingly enough, one was from my daughter’s new husband, Roger Billings, thanking me for inviting him to the wonderful party and saying how much he and Kelly had enjoyed it. That was another checkmark in the philosophy professor’s favor. As for my daughter? Not so much. Evidently her nose is still out of joint and likely to remain so.
I saved the vet’s email as new and replied to Roger, telling him he was more than welcome and that we’d all enjoyed having a chance to meet him. I deleted the rest and then turned to the seventy-four emails from Todd Hatcher. The first one from him was essentially a cover letter:
Below you’ll find the dossiers I’ve created on your missing girl problem. As I said, they’re listed in reverse chronological order with the idea in mind that the most recent cases are the ones where we might be able to do the most good.
Hoping this helps.
Todd
I knew what he meant in terms of “doing the most good.” The most recent cases were the ones where we had the best chances of recovering surviving victims as opposed to human remains. The subject line of each subsequent message contained a full name, starting with the most recent victim, Regina Louise Holt.
Scanning down the entire list, it was difficult to keep from being overwhelmed. Each of those names represented an endangered individual girl as well as a family living with the unfolding tragedy of losing a loved one. Unfortunately, for most of those, we were probably coming on board with too little too late.
In situations like this it’s important to approach each case with new eyes. While we were in Banff, Mel and I had talked about Gina Holt’s situation, but we hadn’t discussed it in the kind of detail provided by Todd Hatcher’s dossier, so I forwarded Gina’s dossier to Mel’s email account.
With Gina handed off to Mel, I tackled the next one down, one Alyssa Marie Pemberton. I wasn’t sure how Todd had obtained a copy of the missing person report, but I was grateful he had.
Alyssa, age twenty, had been a drama major junior at the University of Arizona in Tucson at the time she disappeared from campus on the morning of Monday, May 5, 2025. She had attended her two morning classes—Drama of the 20th Century and The Plays of Shakespeare. Later that evening, however, she had failed to turn up at a Cinco de Mayo party at a bar called Gentle Ben’s. Her roommate, Jodi Franks, became concerned when Alyssa didn’t attend the party, and had launched her own search that very night by calling area hospitals. When Alyssa hadn’t returned the following morning, she had contacted Alyssa’s parents in Prescott. They, in turn, had filed a missing person report with Tucson PD.
That same day—Tuesday, May 6—Alyssa’s vehicle, a 2018 Honda CRV, was located abandoned on a stretch of desolate desert along Sandario Road, some ten miles southwest of a town called Marana. A search of the immediate area by Pima County Search and Rescue had turned up nothing. The vehicle was towed to the Arizona Department of Public Safety Crime Lab in Tucson for processing. It was determined that the CRV had been thoroughly wiped down. No DNA other than Alyssa’s had been located inside the vehicle.
Detectives had interviewed all Alyssa’s friends and acquaintances and come up with nothing. At this point, the investigation seemed to have stalled out. I had gotten that far when Mel turned up, iPad and coffee in hand.
“How’s it going?” she asked.
“I’m about to call the parents of a girl from Prescott, Arizona, who went missing from the University of Arizona in Tucson on the fifth of May. There are some similarities to Gina’s case, and I need to check this out.”