AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Plus-One Pact

Page 5

by Lana Ferguson

“Right, right,” she says, waving her hand. “I got excited. Ah! Maybe we’ll be back next year for your wedding!”

I feel Cole tense up again beside me, no doubt feeling awkward, and I try my best to put his mind at ease. “One step at a time. It’s still pretty new.”

“Of course, of course,” Katie says. “Well, come on, let’s get you guys checked in, and then I can show you how everything is coming together. We’re planning on taking a group skiing trip after lunch, but tonight is pretty much free.”

“I’ve never skied in my life,” I groan. “I’m going to make a fool of myself.”

“I can teach you,” Cole says softly, turning his face down to look at me. “I used to take ski trips as a kid with my parents.”

My brow furrows. “You did?”

“Yeah. Every Christmas until I went off to college.”

“Why didn’t I know that?”

His lips twitch, curling up at one corner to form a half smile. “Maybe you don’t know everything about me.”

“Clearly,” I scoff.

“Ooh, is this the first lovers’ spat?” Katie teases.

I laugh. “Hardly. We fight too much over where to eat for that.”

“Because someone can never make up her mind,” Cole grouses.

“I like to have options!”

“Options imply you actually make a choice at some point.”

“Well, not all of us can be happy with the same burger every single night!” I catch Katie grinning at us, and I shoot her a look. “What?”

“I knew you two would be good together,” she sighs. “That’s all. It makes me happy that you’re finally taking a chance on happiness again.”

My brain stutters over I knew you two would be good together, landing on the again part of her statement. I clam up when I remember why we did this in the first place, my eyes darting around as if Paul is going to jump out from behind one of the corners. Cole’s arm slides from my shoulders then, and weirdly enough, I feel the loss of it like some tangible thing. It admittedly felt . . . nice. Him touching me. Almost like he could ground me, reminding me that I’m not alone here.

“I’m going to go check us in,” Cole announces. He leans down then, pressing his lips to my temple, and it catches me off guard so much that I don’t even know what to say back. My skin tingles where his lips were, and all I can think about is how that’s definitely not something we’ve ever done before. I stare after him as he stalks off toward the check-in counter, noticing the way those shoulders of his fill out his sweater. They really are . . . so big.

I clear my throat, giving my attention back to Katie, who is watching my little dazed experience with glee. “Has everyone else arrived?”

“Oh yeah,” Katie tells me, letting me off the hook and not saying anything about how I was just staring at my pretend boyfriend. “Most of the groomsmen are hanging out in one of the ballrooms right now. I think Paul talked them into a round of pre-ski shots.” A shiver runs down my spine at the mention of my ex, but Katie gives me a sheepish look before I can even attempt to school my features. “You’re sure you’re okay with him being here, right? I figured it would be weird given your history, but since you said it was a mutual thing when you guys broke up, I thought . . .”

She looks so worried at that moment that I feel a strong urge to comfort her. I know it’s not her fault I never told her the truth about Paul and me, know that she would be beside herself if she knew what actually happened, and all I can think about is how this is her big day and that she deserves for it to go off without any drama. It’s not like she asked for Paul and David to have gone to college together.

“It’s fine,” I assure her, pasting on my best fake smile. “Water under the bridge.”

Katie looks visibly relieved. “Good. I’d hate for you to be uncomfortable. I’m so glad you and Cole are a thing now.” She leans in, lowering her voice. “Between you and me, he’s much cuter than Paul, anyway.”

She says it so conspiratorially, like she’s letting me in on some sort of secret, and I can’t help the chuckle that escapes me. This is what I love about my sister. She doesn’t have a thought in her head that she doesn’t let out immediately.

“Yeah,” I reply, my eyes glancing back at the man in question. “He is.”

And honestly, he really is. Not that I’ve never noticed or anything like that, because you’d have to be blindfolded not to, but it’s just now . . . sinking in. Today. How handsome Cole is. He could honestly have anyone. I almost feel bad that he has to waste his weekend doing this with me.

And yet . . . he didn’t hesitate to say yes. He always says yes when I’m asking. Am I somehow taking advantage of our friendship?

“I can hear you thinking,” Katie says.

I tear my gaze back. “Sorry. Zoned out there for a minute.”