Page 42
“It’s only during the day,” Mr. Gowler said. “When Mr. Whitten can’t be here himself.”
“Yes,” Annabelle said. “Thank goodness Mr. Smythe doesn’t live here. Can you imagine?”
“Where does he live?” Hetty asked.
“I’ll let you know when he invites me for tea,” Mrs. Sisson said.
Paul spoke up. He had to clear his throat first. “He wouldn’t need to trust Smythe if he’d only trust Mariah. It’s not an ordinary thing for a man to hire another man to follow his wife. She shouldn’t be a prisoner.”
“Mariah,” Mrs. Sisson tsked.
Paul slunk in his chair, refusing to correct himself. Felicia took the opportunity to place a comforting hand upon his shoulder. If he noticed her touch, he gave no indication.
24.
Whitten had returned from England in a conflicted state of bluster. Mariah could tell he was furious about her trip to Boston, but thanks to Smythe he bore the guilt of a greater wrongdoing. At dinner he watched her with brimming eyes, torn between scolding her and begging her to love him. His distress did not prevent his coming into her room at night. She moved a chair against her bedroom door but he only pushed it open, scraping the chair’s legs across the door noisily and saying, “Really, Mariah,” as if this poor bit of self-defense were a practical joke.
A few days later Whitten returned from work early, carrying a tiny black pug. He found Mariah in the garden, drinking tea in the sun.
“No thank you,” Mariah said, when he presented her with the puppy. Her arms ached to hold it, but she kept them by her side. What gifts had Henry VIII bestowed upon Catherine Howard before lopping off her head?
“Look at her,” Whitten said. He held the puppy nestled under his chin. “Your grandmother picked her out. She’s like a little piglet, isn’t she.”
The puppy was entirely black, even her nose, and sleek despite the wrinkles in her face. A darling, minuscule seal, wriggling in Whitten’s hands, trying to get to Mariah.
“Look,” Whitten said. “She loves you.”
“Thank you,” Mariah said. “But I know what happens here, to anything that loves me.”
“I love you. Quite frankly it hurts me, to think how happy I was that you wanted to see me off. I thought we were making progress, but it was just a trick. So you could run off to God knows where.”
“Have they renamed Boston God-Knows-Where?”
He took a seat on the other side of the wrought iron table. “Oh my dear,” he said. “I am sorry about your dog. It was a misunderstanding. A misinterpretation. Damn telegrams.”
“Will you dismiss him?”
“Smythe? Oh, no. He’s worked for me an awfully long time. He’s the one who found you for me.” When Mariah didn’t answer Whitten said, “You must admit your own culpability. You left without my permission after declaring yourself unfit to travel.”
“To Europe.”
“You should never have snuck off without telling anyone,” Whitten said, for what seemed like the hundredth time. “We still don’t know what you were up to in Boston.”
“We? What a team the two of you are.”
Whitten reddened and amended, “I don’t know what you were up to.”
He petted the puppy, then put it on the ground. It took a few steps before squatting, round little ears flat with concentration. Mariah half longed to scoop the dog up and hold it close and half wished a hawk would swoop out of the sky and carry it away. A swifter, better ending than Smythe’s hands.
“I’ve told you again and again,” she said. “I only wanted some time to myself and to visit old friends. And if I’d told you I was going, you would have sent him with me.”
“I’ve told Smythe in no uncertain terms, nothing like that’s to happen again. And I’ll say the same thing to you.”
“He’s not a safe person,” Mariah said. “He frightens my maid. He blocks her path in a threatening manner.”
“Nonsense.”
“He frightens me. I don’t see how you can claim to love me then leave him here with me all day.”