Page 4
“I have dresses that will do just fine. And you always look beautiful.”
Mariah hoped the compliment might make her mother smile. This last year, worry had etched a vertical line between Mother’s brows. She had developed a new habit, ironing the spot with her index finger. The promise of a seaside party and life beyond that party should have made her happy. But she only looked worried.
Granny, who had been banished during what was supposed to be Mr. Whitten’s visit, came into the room. Her blue eyes looked hopeful and rheumy. “Has he come and gone? Is it good news?”
Mother collected herself, smoothing her hands down her sides. Raising her chin in determination. “He has,” she said. “And it is.”
“Oh my dear.” Granny doted on her only child, born late in life after many miscarriages. “You have done it.”
“Not yet,” Mother cautioned.
“Oh, but you will.” Granny clapped her hands together then brought the prayerful shape to her breast. “No man could ever resist you. Another wedding. And to Mr. John Whitten!”
Mariah thought of her parents’ wedding photograph, transferred from its silver frame—sold before they left Boston—to a wooden one, resting on the mantel downstairs. Two beautiful faces, incandescent with youth. Mariah could not, she would not, indulge in sadness at the thought of another man taking her father’s place. This marriage would save them from Hoboken. From poverty and exile. Maybe Mariah could be forgiven. Maybe she could deserve a life outside this room.
But even if that never came to pass, for now, there was an invitation. Out of this house, out of New Jersey. Back to New England. Not Boston—not home—but still the right scents in the air. The sea. A summer party. With people. Maybe even young people. Mariah felt like she could raise her arms and fly out the window, catching the wind of her happiness all the way to Newport. She was included. She was released.
3.
For the Bishops, life would always be divided into two segments: before the Morrigan sank and after. The steamer’s manifest was lost with the vessel, and the bodies never recovered. Among those on board were Mariah’s father, sister, and two brothers. Mariah wished she had been on board too.
Before the Morrigan sank, Jay took Mariah to a West End fortune teller. Miss Marva smoked a pipe. She wore men’s trousers cinched with rope, a billowy white shirt, and colorful scarves draped over her hair. She’d held Mariah’s face in her hands and said, “You must go with them. Or else you must stop them from going.”
“Who? Go where?”
But Miss Marva hadn’t answered. Instead she told Mariah to watch out for the fair-haired woman. “She’s thwarted you in other lives. She’ll do it again if she has the chance.” This sounded so foreboding, Mariah forgot about the first warning until it was too late.
Father’s plan had been for all of them to spend New Year’s Eve in Maine, so they could ring in the twentieth century at their house on Sebago Lake. They’d never traveled there during the winter; her father must have known they were about to lose the house and wanted the family to be together where they had always been happiest, one last time.
“He dreams and he schemes,” Granny complained, when she heard of the plan. “He schemes and he dreams.”
“Oh, Granny,” Mariah’s brother Leo had said, excited for the adventure. “It’s only winter, nothing to be scared of if you have a fireplace and the right clothes.”
The day before their departure, Mother came down with a fever. She wanted Mariah to stay behind and take care of her.
“That’s not fair.” Evelyn, the more rebellious of the sisters, spoke up on Mariah’s behalf. “Why should Mariah have to stay, and miss our trip, and get sick herself?” She and Mariah were barely a year apart. They operated as a united force but Evelyn was their voice.
Their father urged Mariah to do as his wife asked. And so she had lived—warm and safe at home when the Morrigan sank on its way to Portland, the crew and passengers lost in the freezing Atlantic. She knew she should feel grateful for living, but she never did. The Morrigan would have been one terrifying night, the worst part—for all of them—watching Samuel, only four years old and unable to swim. Father, Leo, or Evelyn would have held on to him, keeping his head above water, until temperature and exhaustion won the battle. Mariah pressed her fists against her eyes to erase memories that didn’t belong to her.
An unpredicted gale. A steamer with a wooden hull, unequal to the storm. One hundred souls sinking to the ocean floor. Policemen arriving at dawn to deliver the news. The mortgaged town house on Louisburg Square echoing with silence, except for their mother’s sobs.
Jay visited on the day Evelyn’s piano was dismantled. He walked past the enormous carriage waiting out front, swallowing the street between the Bishops’ house and the neighborhood’s private park. Once inside there were no servants to greet him; he picked his way around the team of men in the music room.
“What’s all that?” he asked.
“Mother’s selling Evelyn’s piano.” Mariah stepped into his arms in a way she knew was too forward. Before the Morrigan, he’d loved her lightness; now the air around her hung heavy with sorrow. She found herself touching him, too often, to make up the difference.
“Why on earth would she do that?” Jay blinked a dust mote out of his eye. He had long lashes and perpetually pink cheeks, but somehow—maybe it was his height, or insouciance—never seemed girlish.
“Our money’s gone,” Mariah said. Had she not mentioned this before? Had she only wept about her siblings, her father, the four humans whose molecules she longed to rearrange back into existence? “We have to sell everything, even the house.” She held up her hand, to show him her ring finger, empty of the sapphire ring that matched Evelyn’s.
Mariah couldn’t see it. The way Jay’s goals shifted. One hope evaporated but another presented. With her mother’s voice safely in the other room, instructing the piano removers, he kissed Mariah on the lips instead of the cheek.
Les Misérables. The Scarlet Letter. Lady Audley’s Secret. Mariah had read them all. She knew the rules and the aftermath of breaking them. Still, she let Jay take her hand and lead her into the garden shed behind his mother’s house in Cambridge. With light breaking through the wallboards, and the sounds of horse hooves from the road, and the neighbors’ new automobile chugging by. She tilted back her head. When he lighted his lips upon her neck she did not stop him but closed what little space there was between them, pressing her body against his.
“Don’t,” she said, when a minute had passed, because refusing was expected.
Jay halted his unbuttoning. The water rushed back in. Mariah amended.