Page 27
“But it will begin.” His voice betrayed the effort to make everything gentle. “It always does, I’m afraid. But things will come out all right in the end, Miss Bishop. I’m sure they will.”
That simple kindness, calling her yesterday’s name. It steeled Mariah enough to walk with him to the only place in the world she had to go.
The Whitten foyer showed no signs of life. Mariah knew servants would already be risen, baking bread, dusting rooms, lighting fires, readying the house for its day. The house? Call it what it was. A castle, here in the middle of the city. All over the world princesses were bought and sold, delivered like parcels to grand stone prisons.
Tartarus. That was what she’d call this place. Unlike Persephone’s mother, Isabelle was not frantically scouring the earth with a torch in hand, seeking to rescue her, or bargaining for six months of her freedom. She was the one who had handed her over.
The fire in her new bedroom was freshly lit, the quilt smoothed where Mr. Whitten had lain. Mariah went into the dressing room and saw exactly what she expected: a stain on the door in the shape of a lock. She imagined some poor servant rousted from his bed to remove it.
When she looked up, Mr. Smythe stood on the threshold of the bedroom. He had his arms folded over his chest.
“You think you’re clever,” Smythe said in a liltless monotone. “But I’ll tell you what you’ve done. Proven you need someone. To keep an eye on you.”
Mariah pulled the door closed, flattening her palm against the spot where the lock had been.
PART TWO The Blackford Widower
16.
What makes a villain?
Hetty stood on the steps of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, waiting for her mother to arrive. Deep into March, a fresh blanket of snow had fallen during the night. The view felt almost pastoral, like standing on the steps of a grand estate, with the deciduous garden before her, and Central Park spreading out behind and around. Clumps of snow fell from branches to the ground with muted explosions.
Dad’s latest short story, featuring a landlord crazed by greed, sat neatly copied in Hetty’s satchel. She knew the story was partly a censure of Mr. Whitten. She had struggled rearranging sentences to make the doppelgänger more interesting than his evil deeds, among them turning a poor family out onto the street after promising the eldest daughter clemency in exchange for “favors.”
“Why do you think the landlord behaves this way?” Hetty had asked her father at last week’s Monday dinner. “What happened in his life to make him so cruel?” She wanted to find something she might add, a sentence or two she could sneak between her father’s lines. The shape of his story was not terrible. It represented progress from his last one. But the didactic qualities Mr. Price objected to remained and she couldn’t bear to submit it only to receive the same critique.
“What made him cruel?” Dad responded. “This is America, Hetty. Greed is its one and only engine. For a man to live at the tip of the pyramid, when his brothers at its base are starving. That breeds depravity.”
“Yes,” Hetty said, frustrated that someone who read so voraciously could be oblivious to what she was trying to say. “But I think if we knew something about his past, or even if he had one redeeming quality…”
“You don’t understand the story,” he said. “But you don’t need to understand. Just copy it down.”
A carriage pulled too quickly into the museum’s circular drive, its wheel becoming stuck in a snowy rut. Out of it climbed a well-dressed couple. They headed up the stone stairs without a backward glance, leaving the coachman to fend for himself. Hetty stepped forward to offer help just as her mother arrived on foot, shivering in a too thin coat, an ugly brown shawl over her hair. After a quick kiss on the cheek, Hetty realized she’d given her mother the shawl two Christmases ago. Decades later, Hetty would see sketches of women’s fashions from 1902—adorned hats, corseted waists, lace trim. And she would think, No. Those aren’t the clothes we wore.
“Look,” Hetty said, pointing to the coffee cart on the sidewalk. “To warm you up. My treat.”
“We can get warm inside,” her mother said. Mom’s parents, whom Hetty had never met, owned a pickle cart that moved from corner to corner on the Lower East Side. Sometimes Mom would find them and yell news from across the street. They never looked toward her or acknowledged they could hear. Mom persisted in her belief that theirs was the only clean food cart in the city.
Mom put her arm through Hetty’s. They headed up the stairs, stepping carefully over the dusting of snow. “Here you go, from one castle to another.”
“There’s nothing more egalitarian than a museum,” Hetty said, wishing Mom would be more appreciative. Mariah had given Hetty this Sunday afternoon off so she could bring her mother here for the first time. “It’s a castle that belongs to the people. Like the public library. You can just walk in and enjoy everything inside, free of charge.” She didn’t admit to the pleasure she felt, looking at the art in Peregrine Hill, being one of a select few, the way she could touch the whorls of paint that had once been inside a tube belonging to Mary Cassatt or Thomas Eakins, squeezed and brushed by their brilliant hands.
“Have you heard anything about your father’s new story?” Mom asked.
“No,” Hetty said, not confessing it still sat in her bag. “No word yet.”
Inside, the entrance hall wasn’t much warmer than it had been on the steps. Hetty and her mother kept their coats buttoned.
“Your poor dad,” Mom said. “It’s not easy being an undiscovered genius.” Her tone was a combination of fondness and derision.
Would you marry him again, Hetty wanted, and did not want, to ask, knowing everything you know now? A negative reply would disillusion her, but a positive one would be even more unbearable, the idea her mother might not know Dad’s answer was different.
They made their way to John Kensett’s landscapes. “Wonderful light,” Mom murmured, and then added, “A rich man’s light.”
“Mom! Come now. You think even twilight belongs to the rich?”
“Romanticizing it does. Walking through the mist to a party, or watching it through the window of your parlor, instead of braving it home from a late shift.”