Page 59
“That’s great,” I said. “Yeah, that’s… that’s, that’s really great. Let me know as soon as you know, okay? I gotta go.”
“Are you sure you can’t talk a little more?” Graham sounded disappointed.
“No, Anthony’s at a watch party, I’ve got to go pick him up,” I lied. “I’ll talk to you again soon, okay?”
“Okay, but Colton—”
“Bye.” I ended the call.
It was stupid to get my hopes up. So stupid. Our worlds were so different. There was no chance that we could ever connect beyond the show. When he came back, I already knew it wasn’t going to be a welcome home.
It was going to be a last goodbye.
Chapter twenty
Graham
Before I ever got to Hollywood, I already knew that success could be just as toxic as failure.
On the football field, the ultimate success was winning the Super Bowl. My team had done that. I’d also experienced the worst setback of my life after that win, when I came out and got laid out in the same week. I wasn’t naive enough to think that the events were unrelated, and neither was my agent, but he’d advised me not to fight it. I should get back in the game if I could, but not to stir things up any more than I already had.
My football career ended shortly thereafter. I hadn’t been able to get back in the game, I hadn’t stirred things up, and in the end I hadn’t stayed. I’d moved on to what I’d hoped were greener pastures, where people would at least be more understanding of my sexuality, and they were for the most part. Hollywood had been good about that, and I’d had a good run with Luka, but that didn’t mean the toxicity had come to an end. What had started well turned into a professional slog, a painful and bitter end to a relationship, and the creeping feeling that nothing I could do was going to leave me feeling satisfied and happy with my life.
I’d gotten to compete at the highest echelons of sport. I was known to people all around the world thanks to my show. And yet…
Was it me? Was I just unable to be satisfied? Even now, after our holiday special had turned into such a raving success that the network was sending us all back to Colorado to film a follow-up—on New Year’s Eve, nonetheless—I still wasn’t content. There was a piece missing, and I just didn’t know what it was.
At least, I wasn’t sure I knew what it was until I stepped out into the Aspen Airport and saw Colton waiting for me.
The bloom of happiness that started in my heart and spread throughout my whole body was like nothing I’d ever felt before. The high of winning the Super Bowl, the first flush of adoration I’d felt when I got into my relationship with Luka—neither of those moments felt like this. This, seeing Colton again, felt like coming home; like it was reminding me I could have one.
I wanted to keep it. I wanted to keep him, and I was pretty sure I had a plan that might make that happen. The only wild card was the reaction of the man stepping into my embrace.
Tell him now, part of me urged. Tell him now while you’re alone together. It was going to be rare for us to be alone for the rest of the evening. Filming had already started with Jim, Sunita, and an abbreviated crew back at the Lancaster doing follow-up interviews with our contestants. I was the last one to arrive, thanks to the aggressive negotiations that had been happening in Los Angeles, and the next twelve hours were going to be busy for me. Tell him now.
But then Colton pulled back, and something about the look in his eyes made me lose my nerve. “It’s good to see you,” he said.
“You too, you have no idea how good,” I told him. I wanted to lean in for a kiss, but he had already turned away.
“Car’s this way,” he said. I followed him out to his 4Runner , threw my bag in the back seat, and joined him up front. I let the seat slide back a bit and reveled in the fact that I was in a vehicle I could stretch out in. “You look beat,” Colton said as he started up his car.
“Thanks so much. That fills me with confidence over the fact that I’m about to be on camera for hours on end,” I joked at him. “How’s it been going at the Lancaster?”
“Fine,” Colton said surprisingly. “It helps that Chazz isn’t staying there this time.” The owners had been adamant that he was not allowed to come back, and Chazz himself hadn’t fought it all that hard. His social media following had actually dropped after the entire season aired, and he was desperate for a redemption arc.
“Where’s he staying?” I asked.
“Fuck if I know, some Airbnb who’s got a lot more faith in their insurance policy than I do,” Colton replied. “How was your Christmas?”
“It was good,” I said. “I was able to see my family for a while, that was nice.” Prying myself out of L.A. had been hard as hell. But it was also my parents’ fortieth wedding anniversary, and they’d insisted that my presence was non-negotiable. “And you?”
“Quiet,” Colton said, casting a little sidelong look at me.
Ah, right. His nephew had gone off to Vegas. “Is Anthony still with his mom?” I asked.
“Yeah, for another couple days. He tried to change his ticket when he found out you were coming back to film, but I convinced him to stick it out with Vanessa. He comes back on the third. Nana and I had a good time, though.”
“Good.” I didn’t like the small talk. It felt stilted, a little bit painful, a little bit cold. But I didn’t know how to break through it. Not yet, at any rate. “Are you going to be at the Lancaster tonight?”