AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Light It Up

Page 52

by Jennifer Bernard

They huddled around Benny Lee’s woodstove, on which sat a pot of lobster chowder that Benny stirred now and then. As chaotic as the old fisherman was, he kept his little home in order. A Formica tabletop on hinges, a mattress tucked into the bow cabin, a bookshelf with a bungee cord holding an array of paperbacks in place. It was cozy, and better than a shelter, which would have been the other option, since Benny couldn’t hold on to money to save his life. It all went to liquor, and then some.

Benny was a wiry, stoop-shouldered man who rarely remembered to put his hearing aids in, and never thought to comb his hair. Fortunately, there wasn’t much left to worry about, just a few tufts that made him look like a hyper-alert marmot.

With Fergus next to her, Marigold felt like a pair of giants who had come to pay a visit to a sea dwarf. The interior of the Home Fry was so small there was no way for their knees not to touch.

There was also no way for her to ignore that fact. The contact made her very aware of Fergus’ presence.

“Perry Atwater the Third, la di da.” Benny scratched at his leathery jaw, where a few hairs still felt inspired to attempt a beard. “A brat, that one. Caught him shooting seagulls with a BB gun. Told him to cut it out and he took a shot at me. Nearly hit me, too, shame he didn’t, cause they would have paid me even more if I’d lost a limb or something.”

“They?” She had to repeat the question a second time, more loudly.

“Parents, grandparents, ancestors, whatever.” He opened the stove’s cast-iron door to maneuver another stick of wood inside. The brief glow of heat felt good on her cheeks. “They had a fund. The ‘demon child’ fund, that’s what we called it, us service folk. They paid out all summer long, chambermaids, gardeners, everyone. Like a piggy bank.”

“So he was a bad seed, is what you’re saying,” said Fergus. His eyes picked up a deeper blue in the firelight.

“Bad rootstock, if you ask me. Never liked any of the Rushtons. They think their shit don’t stink, know what I mean?”

“Were you here the winter when he came here with his nanny?”

Benny snorted. “That poor girl. She tried to keep him under control, but every time I saw her she was running around tearing her hair out because she couldn’t find him. One time she woke me up in the middle of the night, come banging on my window, telling me to get up and help her with the search. Can you imagine, she wanted me to take this sailboat out. In a nor’easter.”

Fergus and Marigold shared a glance.

“There was a storm that night?” she asked Benny.

“Winds howling fifty miles an hour, whitecaps far as you could see. Cold too, sea smoke thick as fog. No way was I taking a boat out.”

“Why did she want you to?”

“She said his rubber boots were missing, and he only used those on the water. She was a sobbing mess, thought she was going to get fired, or maybe charged with murder for losing a Rushton. I drove around the island, didn’t find him. I only saw one boat out and that was your daddy’s, Marigold.”

Her mouth fell open. “My dad’s? He hasn’t fished in years.”

“Well, he did then. Don’t know why he was out. When I got back to the inn, there was Perry, cool as a cat, sitting in the kitchen eating chicken soup with the cook. Said he didn’t know what all the fuss was about, and he’d been there all along. But I could see by the cook’s face that it wasn’t true. That demon child must have used the fund to shut her up. She never said a word about that night.”

Marigold was scribbling furiously, getting down every word of this story. “Did you know Dennis Murphy, his friend?”

“Eh, he had a crew of kids he palled around with. The nanny didn’t like it but she couldn’t stop him, then she gave up trying. Probably figured it was just for a short time anyway, until she could drop him off at his school.”

“What about a girl? She would have been one of their friends, around their age.”

He cocked his head, like a tufted owl peering at her curiously. “That group stuck to the west side. I never saw them myself. Brave girl if she hung around those guys. It was the same winter—” He broke off, then blinked at Marigold. “Your brother. Ollie. He disappeared around that same time. Yeah, that’s right, it’s coming back to me now. Police came out, asked a few questions, then went away and that was it. We never knew what happened. I remembered I asked someone at the post office and they said the search was over and the family was in mourning, and that was that. Hey, maybe that’s what Bjorn was doing on the water that night. Sorry for your loss,” he added belatedly. Thirty years belatedly, she thought wryly.

“Thank you, that’s very kind.”

She felt Fergus’ gaze on her. She really should have filled him in on all this. But he was probably putting together the pieces on his own.

“Was there ever any talk of something illegal going on? Drugs, smuggling, black market something? Anything that might have needed to be kept quiet?”

“With them kids? I never heard anything. Don’t even know what there could have been. There was a thing with fireworks. That was ‘illegal’.” He used finger quotes for that. “But not the kind of illegal that would get anyone in serious trouble. We’re always in a gray area out here. Didn’t have a constable back then.”

“But we were under the jurisdiction of the Harbortown police,” Marigold pointed out.

“Yeah, and we always knew when they were coming and by the time they got out here, everyone was a perfect angel.” He flashed a mostly toothless grin. “I miss the good old days.”

“Lucky for you, I’m not taking that personally,” Marigold said wryly. “But since, as you point out, there wasn’t much in the way of law enforcement back then, was there something going on that the police never knew about? Something that Dennis Murphy and Perry Atwater were involved with?” She left out her brother. No need to bring a dead child into this.

“I don’t know. Why don’t you ask them?”