Page 5
Marigold snickered in that childish way that Noah could always bring out in her. It felt like sacrilege to talk about her lost brother in terms of ramen noodle soup. But Noah had a point. The pattern he described had happened every time either of them had asked about Ollie. “You’re a jackass,” she said easily.
“So they tell me,” he answered, without rancor. Even though they were twins, their personalities were very different, compatibly so. She was calm and levelheaded, while he was more restless and wild. “Did Aunt Dorothy say anything about Ollie?”
They reached the Clambake Grill, where she parked between Duffy’s motorcycle and Ernie O’Shea’s GMC truck. After five years as a constable’s assistant, she knew most of the vehicles on the island, especially those that belonged to people who might end up in the lockup after a night of drinking. Which wasn’t a small number.
She waited until they were inside, settled at a small table and watching three of the Clyde cousins play darts to answer his question.
“Not really. It was more about how she seemed. Scared, basically. She made it sound like if she talked about Ollie, she might get hurt.”
“By who?” Noah took a sip of his beer, which left a bit of foam on his upper lip. He licked it off like a milkshake. “Mom and Dad don’t like talking about Ollie, but they wouldn’t threaten her. Well, Dad might, just out of sheer spite because they hate each other.”
“They don’t hate each other.”
Noah waved that off. “Close enough. Too bad she’s probably going to have to move in with them at this point.”
As usual, their thoughts had followed the same path.
“She could always move in with us,” Marigold suggested, hiding her smile behind a sip of beer.
“Oh hell no, don’t even—” After his automatic first reaction, Noah broke off with a grin. “You have an evil streak, have I ever told you that?”
“Yup. But everyone knows you’re the evil twin. That’s never been in doubt.”
“Oh yeah?” Noah stood up and tapped a spoon against his beer bottle to get everyone’s attention. It probably wasn’t needed, as a towering wall of muscle like Noah tended to draw eyeballs no matter what. “Need a general consensus here. Who’s more evil, the twin who puts out all the fires or the one who puts you in the drunk tank?”
A chorus of laughter and shouted answers to that question rang through the restaurant. The clear answer was that Marigold was the evil one.
Marigold stood up and took a bow. “Thank you,” she said, holding her beer bottle as a microphone. “Thank you very much. I’d like to dedicate this honor to each and every one of you who thanklessly downed beer after beer until you would have driven off the dock if I let you get behind the wheel. Seriously, I could never have done it without you.”
More laughter and a few jeers followed. She had the feeling that she might have some work to do later tonight. Davey Randolph was already practically falling off his stool. She caught the bartender’s eye. Jasmine Cho was working tonight, moonlighting from her regular gig at the Lightkeeper Inn. Marigold gestured with her chin at Davey. Jasmine nodded and drew a line across her throat, meaning he was already cut off.
She and Noah sat back down and resumed their conversation as if no interruption had occurred.
“It made me wonder if there was more to Ollie’s death than we know,” she told Noah. “She made it sound like something’s being covered up.”
“What’s to cover up? He took a skiff out in a storm and capsized, got swept out to sea. That kind of thing happens a lot. There’s a reason that fishing is one of the most dangerous jobs you can have.”
True. Marigold had been so relieved and grateful when Noah had quit fishing that she’d actually gone to church to say thank you.
“I know, I know. But Aunt Dorothy—”
“Aunt Dorothy has dementia. You can’t take anything she says literally. If we did, we’d also have to arrest the nonexistent grasshoppers that keep getting in her hair. The other day she was covering her ears because the sky was filled with World War Two bombers. Should we alert the Air Force?”
Marigold dug her teeth into her bottom lip. It hurt to hear these details of her aunt’s mental state. “This felt different,” she muttered.
“Well, if you’re worried about it, can’t you investigate?”
“Investigate a non-crime that happened over thirty years ago, before there was even a constable out here? Where would I even start?”
Noah shrugged. He wore a thick gray cable-knit sweater that an ex-girlfriend had made for him. He had quite a few of those—both sweaters and ex-girlfriends. “Ask Mom and Dad?”
“Now I know you’re the evil twin.”
Noah laughed, showing zero signs of regret. “I’m busy with all these damn fires. Maybe you could get those podcasters on the job.”
“Finally, a good idea.” Heather McPhee and Gabby Ramon ran a true-crime podcast called Dirty Rotten Bastards that had tackled a few unsolved island mysteries. They’d probably jump at this one. “But Heather and Luke are on their honeymoon and Gabby’s somewhere working on a story. Maybe when they get back.”
“Right. It’s not like Ollie will be more dead if you wait a few weeks.”