Page 33
Either way, she was glad for his presence on this dark, frightening night.
14
An hour later, they’d collected the doll and the rope, and searched every particle of the surrounding snow for clues. The only thing they found was a fishing lure, an ancient BIC lighter, a crumpled up foil wrapper, probably from a stick of gum, and a small penknife.
Marigold held up the latter so the others could look at it. “What do you think?”
“I think we have to call Luke and see if he recognizes it,” said Noah. “He might have dropped it when he was fishing.”
Marigold turned it around to look at it from all angles. Its outer shell was Swiss Army red, but it was a knockoff of the original. It had the usual complement of retractable tools—tiny scissors, a knife, a nail file. “I don’t think it’s Luke’s, but it also doesn’t really give us much. No initials or anything like that.”
“That would have been nice of the perp,” said Fergus. “A signed confession would have been handy too.”
“Right?” Noah smirked. “It’s the least they could have done after burning up the dock.”
“Criminals these days,” Marigold said. “So inconsiderate.”
They were all feeling punchy by now. Searching for clues in the freezing cold could really form a bond.
She slipped the penknife into a clear plastic evidence bag and sighed. “I’ll send all this into Harbortown for fingerprinting. I’m thinking we should wait until daylight to check out the lake for footprints.”
“What if it snows?” asked Noah.
“No snow in the forecast. Then again…”
They all nodded. Better do it tonight. Forecasts for the island were notoriously unreliable. The closest weather monitoring instruments were out at the lighthouse, a hefty distance from Sea Smoke Island.
They fanned out, taking different paths along the lake, each with a flashlight. It was getting late now, past eight. Every so often, Marigold would straighten and roll her shoulders, change her eye focus to the sky above. Lit only by the stars, without a trace of moonlight, the sky had a deep velvety darkness that felt somehow absolute.
When it was this clear, the temperatures tended to drop even lower, and her evidence gloves didn’t offer much protection from the cold. She kept switching the flashlight from one hand to the other and slipping her free hand into her pocket.
After some time, a shout sounded from the far side of the lake. “Got something,” Fergus called.
She backtracked, not wanting to disturb the snow that she hadn’t yet explored. Following his prints, she joined him and Noah, who had been searching along the road.
They all peered at the tracks Fergus had found. “I have no idea what this is, but it stood out,” he said.
“Ice skates,” Noah and Marigold said at the same moment.
Marigold played her flashlight along the marks, which went down to the frozen lake, then back up into the woods. “I see marks from a sled, too. He dragged the sled through the woods, then put on skates to cross the ice.”
“So we’re looking for someone with a sled and ice skates,” Fergus said triumphantly.
Noah and Marigold both snickered. “That eliminates exactly no one,” she said. “Everyone here has a sled, even if it’s just to haul firewood across the snow. We have an epic sledding hill, too.”
“What about ice skates?”
She shrugged. “Maybe not. That probably does eliminate some of the older folks.” She bent down and directed her beam onto a dark spot in the snow. “Is that gas or blood?”
“Get it into a bag so we can look at it inside,” said Fergus. Directing again, she thought, her jaw setting. “That was a suggestion, by the way. Something to consider.”
Good save. It was the correct thing to do, so she scooped the substance and its surrounding snow into another bag.
“It could be a teenager or someone with kids,” Noah mused as they carefully made their way deeper into the woods. “They’d be guaranteed to have sleds and skates. That’s about all there is to do here in the winter. No skiing to speak of,” he told Fergus.
“No big loss. I tried to ski one time in my life and pitched right into a snowbank head first. Took three guys to pull me out.”
Noah laughed and launched into a story about his last time skiing at Sugarloaf.