Page 67
“I had reason to be.”
“I am sure you did.” Kate rested her bare fingertips against the edge of the desk. The polished wood felt warmer than her skin. “A small child falls, her father becomes more cautious, and everyone is sensible until she recovers. What I cannot understand is why the rule remained after she had recovered.”
“Simple. The snow did not stop being slippery.”
“So do polished floors.”
“Trust me, Lady Kate, this is not the argument you want to pick with me.”
“I am trying to discover the boundary of your reasoning.” Her voice sharpened, and she let it. “Rose is nine. She was properly dressed. We stayed close to the house and the barn, and she had adults with her.”
“She is still a child.”
“Do you think I do not know that?”
“Well, you don’t speak like you do.”
Kate swallowed, letting whatever anger was about to rise in her settle. “I speak like someone who spent a big part of her life helping to raise her younger sisters. Children fall and frighten everyone who loves them. Once they are well, one does not ordinarily forbid the entire world that contained the bruise.”
His eyes narrowed. “You know nothing about what I ordinarily do.”
“Tell me why this is different.”
“I have told you enough. Rose is my responsibility.”
Kate pressed her fingertips harder into the desk before answering. “What would have made this morning acceptable? If she had asked you first?”
“Yes.”
“Then say that. I can understand a rule requiring a child to ask before leaving where you expect her to be. I cannot understand why the snow itself must remain forbidden years after the injury that caused the rule.”
“You will not understand because you are treating the distinction like it changes the risk. She is my responsibility. That should be enough!” His stare sharpened at the final words, but Kate held it.
“And because she is your responsibility, any decision you make for her remains correct forever?”
“That is not what I said.”
“Then correct me.”
His gaze shifted to her bare fingers against the desk before returning to her face. “I will not have my daughter put at unnecessary risk.”
He looked away from her for the first time, toward the papers arranged at one end of the desk. Kate waited, but his hand never reached for them.
“When she tells you no,” he said, “you have to accept it.”
Kate’s spine straightened. “When Rose tells me no?”
“You know perfectly well what I mean.”
“I do. I wanted to hear whether you did.” His eyes returned to hers, and she abandoned the easier argument about one morning in the snow. “Suppose we marry. Suppose I want to ride somewhere and you consider the road unsafe. Do you expect me to remain home because you have decided it?”
“You are not Rose.”
“Exactly.”
“That comparison is absurd.”
“Then give me a better one.” She moved along her side of the desk until she stood closer to its corner, close enough to see the small changes he could hide from across a room. “Suppose I wish to visit someone you do not like. Do I require your approval?”