Page 71
“Sit down, Luca,” Mara says.
“I am sitting.”
“You’re levitating.”
“It’s the sugar.”
Mara opens the first box.
It’s an ordinary cardboard box, the kind that holds copy paper, soft at the corners from age. On the lid, in the blue ink of a fountain pen, someone has written MISC. BELLAMY. Underneath, in a different, sharper hand: DO NOT DISCARD.
“Where did you find it?” I ask.
“St. Anne’s. The church basement. Behind the boiler, under a Christmas pageant display.” Mara lifts the lid with the care of a woman defusing something. “The county kept the official files. The church kept the unofficial ones. Someone invariably holds onto a duplicate of something.” She takes out a thin stack of papers, held with a rusted paper clip. “I told you.”
She lays the first sheet on the table. It’s a newspaper page, browned with age, folded in quarters and slightly damaged at every crease.
The whole room has gone quiet. Even Luca has put down his knife.
THE THISTLE HOLLOW GAZETTE, reads the masthead. Monday, November 3, 1969.
Beneath it, in thick black type: HILLTOP HOME FOUND EMPTY.
I read it aloud, because somebody has to, and because my voice is the only thing I trust to stay level.
“Sheriff Dunmore reported on Sunday that the Bellamy house on Thistle Hollow Road was found lit from cellar to attic by neighbors who noticed lamps burning in every window. A search of the premises found no sign of Miss Evelyn Bellamy, twenty-five, who has lived alone at the property since the death of her mother. The doors were unlocked. The kitchen table was set for one. An upstairs crib was empty, its bedding gone.”
My mouth is dry.
“Neighbors report seeing a man at the front gate on the evening of October 31st, though none were able to describe him. The sheriff’s office has asked anyone with information to come forward.”
I keep going. The next paragraph is shorter.
“Mr. Harlan Monroe, a family friend who called on Miss Bellamy frequently, told this reporter he feared for her state of mind. ‘She hasn’t been herself,’ he said. ‘She’s been saying strange things for months. I only hope she’s somewhere safe.’”
“H.,” Henry says.
“Harlan,” I say. “H. came to the porch with flowers. He smiled with all of his teeth.”
The name sits at the center of the table, like a stain.
At my left, Oliver has stopped moving. It’s the oddest thing. I notice it out of the corner of my eye: the way he has gone pale, a quick drain of color from his face, and the way his jaw has tightened until a muscle jumps beneath the ear. His hands are on the table. He is looking at the newsprint, at one line, and he’s not reading it. He’s viewing it in the same manner as you’d view a name you’ve seen before.
“Monroe,” he says. His voice comes out flat.
“Do you know it?” I ask.
“No.”
It’s too quick. I register that, and put it away, and then Oliver stands up so fast that his chair scrapes.
“I’m going to check the oven,” he says.
“The oven’s off,” Luca says.
“The other oven.”
“We have one oven.”