Page 124
Henry has come around the bed. He’s standing at her shoulder, and he doesn’t touch the photograph. He’s looking at it with the focus he gets when he’s reading a track.
“The hand,” he says, finally. “On her arm.”
“What about it?”
“It’s a carpenter’s.”
I see Oliver look at his own hands. He does it without meaning to. He turns them over in the lamplight and looks at the calluses, at the scarred knuckles, at the long, strong fingers. He doesn’t say anything at all. His face gives nothing away. But he looks, for a long moment, at the tall figure in gray wool at the back, and then away.
“Do you know them?” Katie whispers.
“No.” Oliver’s voice is hoarse. “I don’t. I never… no.”
“They look happy.”
“They do.”
“They look like…” She stops. She looks at the photograph for a very long time. Then she lifts her eyes and looks at the three of us, standing around her in the lamplight in our rumpled shirts, with our hair on end and our hearts on our faces, and I see the question arrive in her eyes before she asks it.
“Every pack has a story,” she reads, softly, from the back.
“Katie,” I say.
“Do you think…?”
“No.”
“Luca, I haven’t even…”
“I know where this is going.” I put up both hands. “I can see it in your face. You’re already making a list. You’re about to say what if we looked, and then what if there’s a room we haven’t found, and then what if there’s a box in the round room marked nineteen sixty-eight, and then it’s the middle of summer, and we’ve all got shovels.”
“I’m not saying that.”
“You were about to.”
“I was somewhat inclined to.”
“Absolutely not,” I say.
It comes out of me at a pitch I’d rather not describe. I fold my arms. I put on my sternest face, the one that Dot says looks like a toddler guarding a cookie. “I’ve been through a lot this year. I have been through a haunting, a heat, a trust fund, a tunnel, and a cake that cost me four hundred dollars in fondant. I have just gotten the pantry right. I refuse to be dragged into another mystery.”
There’s a pause.
Then Katie starts to laugh.
She does it quietly at first, into her hand, with her shoulders shaking. Then it comes up in a rush, free and helpless and bright, until she’s bent over the photograph with tears in her eyes. I look at Oliver, who has put his hand over his mouth. I look at Henry, whose shoulders are going up and down in the lamplight in a way that I would describe, in anyone else, as silent hysterics. And I find that I’m laughing, too. I can’t help it. It breaks out of me like sun through clouds.
“I’m serious,” I say, weakly.
“I know,” Katie gasps. “I know you are.”
“I want it on the record.”
“It’s on the record.”
“I’ll bake a protest.”
Above us, the house gives a long, low, contented creak, the sound of an old, old woman settling into a favorite chair. The clocks tick. The moth beats softly against the glass. The air smells of cinnamon and apples and warm, clean wood.