Page 12
Charlie’s Café sits on the corner of Elm Lane and Oak Avenue, its front windows painted with curling fall leaves and little white ghosts that probably came from the elementary school down the block. The sign glows warm against the dark, and inside I can already see Charlie himself at the counter, talking to a college kid in a beanie over a chipped white mug.
Orange string lights trace the front window, and someone has gone aggressively festive with the decor. I’d bet money Charlie approved every inch of it.
Jaxon glances at the windows as I park. “You weren’t kidding about the fall obsession.”
“You should see this place in December,” I say as we climb out. “Charlie nearly puts the Hallmark channel out of business.”
The bell above the door jingles when we walk in, and warmth folds around us along with the rich smell of coffee, cinnamon, and sugar. Charlie looks up from the counter immediately.
“There’s my prodigal menace,” he calls when he sees me, his face lighting up. “I was starting to think Hollywood finally stole you back.”
“Never,” I tell him, smiling despite myself. “You’ve got cheesecake.”
Charlie thumps a hand over his heart. “And this, son, is how true love sounds.”
Jaxon lingers half a step behind me at first, taking in the place with a careful sweep of his eyes.
Charlie grins and turns that bright, grandfatherly attention on Jaxon. “And who’s this? You bringing handsome company into my café now?”
Jaxon’s entire body goes a touch more formal, which makes me want to laugh and protect him at the same time.
“This is Jaxon,” I say before he has to decide how to answer. “He’s staying with us for the next two weeks.”
Charlie sticks out a hand across the counter. “Charlie. Owner, barista, therapist, and unwilling witness to half the bad decisions in this town.”
Jaxon shakes his hand and, to his credit, handles the teasing better than most. “That seems like a lot of hats.”
Charlie shrugs. “I’m old. We collect jobs.”
I get my usual latte and a slice of cheesecake with blackberry topping because restraint is for daylight hours. Jaxon studies the pastry case, then orders a black coffee and—after Charlie scolds him for trying to live joylessly—a slice of plain cheesecake too.
I pay before he can object, and when he gives me a look for it, I only tell him, “House rules. You’re new in town.”
Charlie points us to a booth near the front window, tucked far enough from the counter to give us privacy without making us feel isolated.
The café is only half full this late. A couple in matching college sweatshirts share fries in a back booth. Two nurses in scrubs sit near the pastry case, tired-eyed, with sugar packets scattered between them. Some old country song plays softly through the speakers. It’s all warm light, clinking mugs, and the strange peace that belongs only to places open this late.
For the first few minutes, we sit in a quiet that feels less loaded than the one in the car. I stir foam into my latte with a spoon I don’t need and watch Jaxon wrap both hands around his coffee mug.
He looks better out of the lake house. Or maybe just less trapped. Tension still sits in his shoulders, that ingrained stillness, but here it has room to spread out instead of pressing against walls and expectations.
He breaks the silence. “I’m sorry,” he says, eyes on the coffee instead of me.
I set my spoon down. “For what?”
He gives a short, humorless breath. “Avoiding you.”
There’s no point pretending I didn’t notice. “You were.”
“I know.” He drags his thumb along the handle of his mug once, then lifts his gaze. “I just… didn’t know how to act after the maze.”
I lean back against the booth and let my expression stay open. “You didn’t owe me anything after the maze.”
He laughs quietly, but it sounds too bitter to be amusement. “Maybe not. But I’ve never had anyone see me like that.”
“Vulnerable or human?” I ask, knowing he means both.
Jaxon’s jaw tightens once, then he keeps going. “No one’s seen me lose it before,” he says. “Not really. I’ve always been the one who holds it together. I could never let anyone see me vulnerable, and I never wanted Luca to see his big brother can get scared, too.”