Page 2
“Let me replace the cider,” he says.
“You don’t have to do that.” I’m the one who freaking made the mess.
“I know.” He doesn’t move toward the stand. He just keeps looking at me, and I realize he’s waiting for me to say yes.
The woman in the quilted vest has stopped pretending she’s not watching. The two men by the hay bales are definitely talking about us now. I can feel the weight of the fair’s attention settling on my shoulders, and I don’t know what to do with it. I’ve been in this town for less than a week.
“You’re not going to let this go, are you?” I ask.
“No.”
“Why?”
He tilts his head slightly, like the question surprises him. “Because I want to welcome you to town,” his words turn my insides to mush, “and get to know you.” That sounds promising.
Just like that. No preamble, no hedging. I feel my face get warm, and I hate that I’m probably blushing. My fingers are still gripping the empty cup, and I make myself loosen them, smoothing the paper flat between my palms. “That’s very direct.”
“I don’t see the point in beating around the bush.”
I can’t argue with that. I’ve met exactly one person in this town who talks the way he does, and that’s Millie, and even she wraps her observations in enough warmth that you don’t notice she’s already figured you out. Noah Stafford doesn’t bother with the wrapping.
“Fine.” I toss the cup in the trash can. “I can’t turn down another cup of cider.”
He smiles and steps aside to let me lead the way to the cider stand. The teenager hands me another cup without comment, though his eyes flick between the sheriff and me with obvious curiosity. I take a sip, still hot, still good, and start walking toward the craft stalls because that was my plan before I christened the sheriff’s boots with hot apple cider, and I’m not going to let his presence derail my evening.
He falls into step beside me, close enough that I can feel the heat coming off him but not so close that we’re touching. The crowd parts around us in a way it didn’t when I was walking alone, and I notice the way people smile and greet the sheriff warmly. I wonder if he notices it, too, or if it’s been so long that it just feels like the way the world works.
“How long have you been Sheriff?” I ask.
“Ten years.”
“That’s a long time.”
“I’m comfortable in the job.” He says it simply, like that’s the whole explanation.
We pass a stall selling beeswax candles, and I stop to smell one, inhaling the honey and lavender. The vendor, a woman with braids and a hand-knit shawl, starts to tell me about the wick material, but I’m only half-listening. I’m aware of Noah standing behind me, patient and silent, and I’m aware that I like having him there more than I should.
I buy a candle I don’t need and tuck it into my bag. When we start walking again, I angle us toward the apple-bobbing line because it’s crowded and noisy and maybe the chaos will make this feel less like a date.
“You’re avoiding the quieter stalls,” Noah observes.
“I like the noise.”
“You like the cover.”
He hit that right on the head. “Are you profiling me?”
“I’m paying attention.”
“That’s the same thing.”
“It’s not.” He stops walking, and I stop too because it feels strange to keep moving when he’s planted like that. The fiddle music swells from the bandstand, and somewhere behind us a child shrieks with laughter. “You’re trying to figure out whether or not to give me a chance.”
“What makes you say that?”
“You’re holding your cup like a shield.”
I look down at my hand, and he’s right. I’ve got the cider clutched against my chest, both hands wrapped around it like it’s armor. I lower it slowly, and the movement feels more revealing than anything I could say.