Page 12
“Pizza’s keeping warm in the oven,” he says. “I wasn’t sure what you liked, so I got pepperoni and mushroom. Millie said mushroom was a safe bet.”
I turn to face him. “You asked Millie what kind of pizza I like?”
“I asked Millie what kind of pizza people like. I didn’t mention you.”
“And she believed that?”
He almost smiles. “She didn’t ask.”
The living room looks the same as it did last night, the worn brown couch, the low bookshelf against the wall, the small television on a wooden stand, but tonight there’s a pizza box on the coffee table and two plates and a candle I recognize. It’s just like the beeswax one I bought at the fair. He’s lit it, and the honey-lavender scent threads through the garlic and the warmth, and I stare at it for a moment too long.
“You have a candle like mine,” I say.
“You have good taste, so I knew I couldn’t go wrong with your choice.” He says it like that explains everything. Maybe it does.
We sit on the couch, and he brings the pizza from the oven and opens the box. The cheese is still glossy, the pepperoni curling at the edges. I take a slice and fold it the way you do with good thin-crust pizza, and he watches me with an expression I can’t quite read. Not hunger. Something softer. Something that makes me want to look away and also never look away.
“What?” I ask.
“Nothing. You just…” He shakes his head and reaches for his own slice. “You look good in that sweater.”
“This old thing?”
“You’d look great in a potato sack, sweetheart.”
I take a bite instead of answering. The pizza is hot and salty and exactly what I wanted. We eat in a silence that isn’t uncomfortable, the kind where just being in the same room with someone and it’s enough. The candle flickers when I reach for a second slice. Outside, the wind has picked up. I can hear it moving through the bare branches of whatever tree stands in his yard.
Halfway through the pizza, he sets his plate down and says, “The lab has the note.”
I stop chewing. Swallow. “And?”
“And it’ll be a few days before we hear anything. They’re testing the paper and the envelope for prints, DNA, whatever they can find. It’s not fast.” He’s watching me now, and I can see the effort it takes for him to keep his voice level. “I want you to know I’m not letting it go. But I also don’t want it to be the only thing we talk about tonight. I just needed you to know I’m on it.”
I set my own plate down and wipe my fingers on a napkin. “Thank you. For telling me. And for not making me feel like I’m crazy for being scared.”
“You’re not crazy.” The words come out fast and hard, and he reins them back in. “Someone threatened you. That’s real. But right now, in this house, you’re safe. I need you to know that, too.”
“I know.” And I do. That’s the strange part. I’ve felt watched for days, a prickle at the back of my neck every time I unlock the library in the morning, but here, with the pizza going cold and the beeswax candle burning and Noah’s knee six inches from mine, the fear has gone quiet. It’s still there. It’s just not the loudest thing in the room.
He reaches over and takes my hand. His palm is warm and rough, and his thumb moves across my knuckles once, twice, before he stops himself. “I want you more than I want my next breath.” He stares down into my eyes. “But I’m not going to rush you. You set the pace. You decide what happens next. Always.”
I look at his hand wrapped around mine. At the small scar on his thumb that I noticed for the first time at the diner, a white line that’s marring his tan skin.
He doesn’t elaborate. He doesn’t list his qualifications or promise me a future or tell me all the ways he’s different from whoever hurt me before. He just says yes and waits for me to decide what to do with it. And that single syllable, plain and unadorned, means more than a polished declaration ever could.
I turn my hand over in his and lace our fingers together. “What movie are we going to watch?”
“How does the new Adam Sandler comedy sound?”
“Sounds great.” I settle back against his warm, muscular body as he aims the remote at the large flat-screen television.
CHAPTER SIX
CHARLOTTE
Over the next several days, we slip into an easy and addictive rhythm that starts with dinner at his place followed by us tangled on his couch, lips pressed together, hands greedy like teenagers, chasing heat until we’re breathless. Then every evening ends the same way: him trailing after me, headlights ghosting through the dark as he follows me home, never quite ready to let me go.
By the time Sunday rolls around, I’ve forgotten all about the threatening note and am starting to wonder why I ever considered fighting my feelings for Noah Stafford.