AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

10 Reasons Why Ethan Parker Vanished

Page 98

by Lilith Alba Carmin

“Everyone admires you for your focus, C.,” Ethan went on. “For the way you never blink when it comes to your goals.” He drew in an audible breath, the vapor steaming into the air again. “But I know what that focus costs you.”

Something cracked once in the background of the video, as if wood had shifted somewhere in the room. Ethan blinked briefly, not because of the sound, but as if he had to force himself to say the next part.

“I saw you that January night.”

The words fell like stones.

Everything in Ezra’s chest tightened. The image: January, the quarry, the night after Derek’s escalation—everything drew tight like a noose.

“I was lying on the ground,” Ethan continued calmly. “And you were standing in the shadows.”

The camera shook, just enough to reveal that he had a hand on the edge of the laptop. It was not a dramatic tremor, only a microscopically fine betrayal of his muscles.

“All you had to do was open your mouth,” he said. “Just one word. ‘Stop.’ ‘That’s enough.’ You wouldn’t even have had to say my name.” His voice remained quiet. Every syllable landed. “And you could have prevented the worst of it.”

Chloe moved her hand as if to push the screen away, but let it hang there in the air. Her breathing turned shallower.

“But you looked away,” Ethan said. No accusation in the volume, only in the clarity. “Because my blood on your white vest would have ruined your precious scholarship.”

The sentence hung in the air like smoke. The algorithm would turn it into headlines: “Scholarship student sacrifices classmate for career?”—the comment sections would explode. To everyone watching, Chloe was no longer the quietly admired fighter in that moment, but a calculating egotist clinging to the surface no matter what—or who—sank beneath it.

The reactions in the dorms and group chats were already roaring through Ezra’s mind, soundless but deafening. That mixture of sensational hunger and moral outrage. The scholarship students who had looked up to Chloe until now would strike her name from their motivation boards. Honest students would grit their teeth and tell themselves: This is exactly why they hate us. Because people like her ruin our reputation.

But here, in the quarry, there was no comment section. Only these three bodies, circled by the wind.

Ethan lowered his gaze for a moment, as if he had to gather himself. His hands moved out of frame; all they could hear was the soft scrape of fabric. He had shoved his fingers into his jacket pockets to hide the trembling.

“I didn’t save you in the quarry back then,” he began again, and now his voice was different. No longer an accuser’s voice, but the voice of someone repeating an old truth: “so that you would owe me something.”

His gaze lifted to the camera again. His pupils were black now.

“I did it because your life was worth living.”

Something twitched in Chloe’s face. A tiny web of cracks started at the left corner of her mouth and spread to her eyes. She clenched her jaw so tightly the muscles under her skin quivered.

“But look at yourself, C,” Ethan continued, and this time the “C” was not an affectionate nickname, but a mirror. “What good is this scholarship to you, what good are all these perfect grades, if to get them you had to sacrifice the last thing that makes you human?”

He put no mockery into the word “human.” It was almost tender. That was exactly what made it unbearable.

“You survived,” he said. “Congratulations.”

A tiny pause. Only a heartbeat, but it felt like a fall.

“But inside, you’re far more dead and colder,” Ethan concluded, “than you ever were that night on that tree stump.”

The tree stump stood no more than ten feet away from them.

The sentence and the reality overlapped, as if someone had laid one transparency over another. Ezra had to take a step just to feel ground under his feet again. Julian stared at the screen in his hand as if he had forgotten how to lock it. Chloe was no longer looking directly at the video. But she heard every word as if it had been nailed to the quarry walls.

In the distance came the soft sound of an incoming group chat ping, muffled by fabric. Julian’s phone vibrated again, this time briefly, then once more, because the world was already reacting. He turned off the screen as if that could erase the contents from existence.

In the last second of the video, Ethan was no longer looking into the camera, but past it. His lips still moved, as if he wanted to add something, but the clip ended abruptly. Black screen. Then the comment section automatically popped up.

Chloe made a choked sound that was neither sobbing nor laughter. She tilted her head back as if she could physically escape the video, even though it was already over.

“He…” Her voice broke. She drew breath, and the wind tore it apart at once. “He…”

She did not collapse like in a movie. She stayed on her feet, but her body looked as if some invisible hand were tugging at a dozen strings. Her hands hung limp, as though she had forgotten how to use them.