AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

10 Reasons Why Ethan Parker Vanished

Page 78

by Lilith Alba Carmin

“He set the trash bag down. I thought that was it. Then he came over and waved me inside. Said he couldn’t leave me hanging around out here in the alley. Before I knew it, I was sitting inside at the counter, soaked through. And he came back with a plate.”

Ezra pressed his lips together.

“Two pieces of cake,” Julian continued. “Not even the ugly end pieces. Good pieces. With frosting and everything. I immediately started coming up with excuses for why I couldn’t… I mean, I didn’t want him to think I—”

He broke off, dragged the flat of his hand over his forehead as though he wanted to scrape the memory off the bone by force.

“He lied so I could keep my pride,” Julian said then. “‘I have to throw these out after closing anyway, don’t worry about it, you need to eat.’ Exactly like that. As if it were all just store logistics and not alms that break your spine.”

The image formed in Ezra’s mind: Ethan holding out the plate, his brow furrowed to sell the lie. That expressive look saying: Play along, I’m giving you a stage where you don’t have to fall.

“He didn’t wait for me to start eating,” Julian continued, his voice rough now. “He just shoved the thermos into my hands. That silver one. The same one he later…” He faltered, swallowed visibly. “…used for that damned clue.”

Ezra’s gaze dropped as if remote-controlled to the cup holder. There it stood. The brushed silver caught the pale stray light from the alley—not a mute piece of evidence anymore, but the reliquary of an unrecorded act of grace. A cold knot formed in his stomach.

“He poured me coffee. Wasted on someone he barely knew. My hands were so cold… they shook so badly around the paper cup that he had to steady me for a second so I wouldn’t dump it all over my pants.”

Three hours earlier, Ezra had grabbed Julian’s arm in the restroom: a hard, possessive grip to secure himself a shield. Ethan’s fingers on that cup had been the exact, shameful opposite: he had reached out to keep someone from being scalded.

For a few seconds, all that could be heard was their irregular breathing.

“And I couldn’t stand it,” Julian finally whispered. “That… unconditional kindness. That he didn’t ask. That he didn’t want to know how deep in the dirt I already was, just: plate, cup, done.”

He closed his eyes briefly.

“I started crying like a little kid.”

The words hung heavy in the cabin. No performative self-loathing, but naked, unprotected shame.

“Right there at that damned counter. Designer jacket, overdue rent, tears on my face. It was…” He laughed soundlessly. “Not my best performance.”

Ezra saw the image whether he wanted to or not: Julian, whose whole existence otherwise consisted of controlled posture, crumpled in on himself like a soggy cardboard box while Ethan silently held out the thermos and acted as if it were the most normal thing in the world for someone to break apart at the counter on a Tuesday evening.

“He didn’t touch me,” Julian said softly. “Didn’t hug me, didn’t give some big comforting monologue. He just sat down next to me. The plate between us. The coffee between us. And… sat there.”

Ezra knew that kind of help from him. The calm, windless endurance of pain that could not be fixed, only borne beside you.

“Later,” Julian continued, “when I could sort of talk again, he asked if I needed a job.”

He inhaled—slowly, as if forcing himself to push the syllables cleanly out of his lungs.

“He didn’t offer me money. No ‘I can lend you something’, nothing that would have made me smaller. Instead he told me about the assistant who had quit. That the Copper Owl was looking for new hands. That he could put in a good word for me.”

A tiny, utterly absent smile twitched at the corners of his mouth.

“He said: ‘Arthur Pendelton is a fair boss. The environment is family-like. But never call him Arthur, even if it says so on the name tag. Artie is allergic to formality.’”

Ethan’s voice resonated almost physically in that sentence—that inimitable mixture of seriousness and playful warning.

“That’s how I knew about the spare key,” Julian concluded. “That’s why I knew how to get in after closing. Because he didn’t want me to starve. Not on the outside. Not in my head.”

The interior of the SUV seemed to close in. The yellowish display of the digital clock cast a mercilessly weak light across their faces. Ezra had let go of the steering wheel by now; his hands lay heavy on his thighs, his nails digging through the dense fabric of his pants into the flesh.

The suffocating pressure in his throat had built layer by layer until swallowing had become a dry, painful click.

“How could you betray him then?” he finally asked.

The question was quiet. There was no shouting in it, no theatrical anger. But something in the tone cut deeper than any volume. It was the naked incomprehension of someone who already knew his own ugliness and was now finding it again in someone else.