AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Christmas at the Cabin

Page 25

by Katie Winters

Pepper shrugged. “It was some kind of land and money dispute. Back in their day, not much money was going around. People in Whistler’s Hollow were dirt-poor. Probably they hated their lives so much that they had to pick out an enemy, and they decided on each other.”

“Huh.” For some reason, Hazel thought of Polly, whom she’d chosen as her enemy, even though Polly was sort of lovely—and certainly someone the girls adored. Marvin was the one who cheated on Hazel. Polly hadn’t respected their marriage, but that was different.

“Did I lose you there?” Pepper asked. “I know, these are boring stories from long ago. Why don’t you tell me more about you?” He reached for the bottle of wine and refilled his glass without asking, as though he’d done so in this cabin before.

For a little while, Hazel opened up about her daughters, about Polly, about the divorce. She talked about her father, Timothy, and how strained their relationship was. “He’s at the resort in a suite right now, and I’m here, wondering why I left Manhattan,” Hazel said. “Meanwhile, I’m petrified about what’s going to happen tomorrow or the next day. Where is Grandma Clara?”

Pepper shook his head. “It’s a real head-scratcher.”

“She didn’t tell you about a hike she was going on? Or a night ski she was headed out on?” she asked.

“Nothing,” Pepper said. “I can show you our text exchange if you want.”

“Do you mind?” Hazel asked, rubbing her thighs. “Any hints would be appreciated.”

At this, an emotion Hazel couldn’t quite read passed over Pepper’s face. Slowly, almost clumsily, he tapped the pockets of his jeans, then said, “Oh. I guess I left my phone at home. That’s me. I’m too old for all this technology.”

Hazel furrowed her brow. The tension in the room felt different, shockingly so. Was it her imagination, or had Pepper only suggested she look at his phone to endear her to him?

The clock on the wall read ten thirty, and Hazel was clear on one thing, if nothing else. She wanted Pepper Sikes to be on his way. “Listen, Pepper. Maybe I can get your number? We’re going to start looking for my grandmother again tomorrow, and any help would be appreciated,” Hazel said, getting up, praying he’d follow her to the front door.

Pepper remained on the sofa, drinking his wine and staring at the fire.

“It’s just that I drove all the way to Whistler’s Hollow from Maine this morning,” she explained. “I really need to get to bed. If you don’t mind?”

“You can do whatever you need to do,” Pepper said, his voice higher-pitched than before.

Hazel’s heart thudded. She considered ways she could tell him to get out of there, words she could use. Get out! was probably not the nicest thing to say to a man who was probably lonely and possibly her grandmother’s boyfriend. Nor was you’ve overstayed your welcome!

But what could she say? It was clear this man was not getting the hint.

“Pepper?” she said delicately. “Pepper, can you please…”

“I had many plans for that resort,” Pepper said. “Back in the seventies. You should have seen the plans I’d drawn up for the site. It was my father’s and my dream, the thing that would bring us together. The grand opening of a ski resort that would finally name us as the proper owners of Whistler’s Hollow. By then, we had money, but we didn’t have respect. Respect is harder to gain.”

Hazel crinkled her forehead. “You wanted to open a different ski resort?”

Pepper turned and raised his eyebrows. “It was supposed to be my ski resort,” he said. “And although I’ve lost almost everything—my children won’t speak to me, and my wife left me and won’t let me call or visit—that ski resort is still there, ready for me to take over. It’s taunting me, Hazel. As is your grandmother. Now she’s ‘missing.’” He used actual air quotes. “She’s driving me mad.”

Hazel’s stomach twisted in fear. Searching around her, she reached for a candlestick, praying that, as she’d learned in the game Clue, it could serve as a weapon if she needed it. Oh, what was she doing?

“That sounds really hard, Pepper. But I can’t talk about that right now,” Hazel said quietly. “I have to go to bed, remember?”

Suddenly, Pepper erupted from the sofa and careened into the bedroom, calling, “Clara? Clara, I know you’re in here. You can’t keep playing these games with me. For fifty years! An endless string of games!”

Hazel listened as Pepper tore the sheets off the bed, as though Clara really were playing hide-and-go-seek, giggling in the dark and waiting for him. When he didn’t find her, he howled. Hazel hurried to find her cell phone, then dialed 911, her eyes on the bedroom door. But then, Pepper appeared, his eyes manic, and cried, “You think I don’t own the cops? The cops are my best friends, Hazel. I went to high school with them. I fund them. They’re mine.” He smiled such a heinous, white-toothed smile that Hazel nearly dropped her phone.

But maybe because he was done playing with her, or maybe because he was now convinced that Clara wasn’t really there, Pepper shot out the door and went back into the snow. Hazel hurried to slam and lock it before he could come back in. She watched from the window as Pepper started his truck's engine and fishtailed through the trees and out of sight.

“Oh my gosh,” Hazel gasped, her heart exploding. What had she been thinking, letting a strange man into the cabin like that? Clearly, Clara was hiding from him, and clearly, she was in danger.

Hazel dialed her father’s number and waited, panic-stricken, until it rang and rang and rang and went to voicemail. Rather than wait around the cabin for her father to answer, Hazel put out the fire, packed up her things, and got back into her car. Luckily, she’d only drunk half a glass of wine with the creepy Pepper Sikes, so she snaked the route back to the resort, shaking the entire time.

When she reached the resort, she parked in the front row, grabbed her bag, and hurried inside. The same woman was working the front desk, and she put on a slightly confused smile as Hazel approached. “Was there any trouble with your father’s suitcase?” the woman asked.

“No. I mean, I don’t think so. But I need to talk to him, and he’s not answering his phone. Would you mind telling me his room number?”

The woman, whose name, Hazel now saw, was Audrey, continued to look bemused. Hazel leafed through her wallet to find her driver’s license, which said Hazel Walton, because she’d never gone to the trouble of changing her last name when she and Marvin had gotten married. Thank goodness for that, she thought now.