AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Reindeer Ex for Christmas

Page 5

by Noelle Drake

Jack disappeared without another word, his legs moving quickly as he rushed towards his truck. Theo took the time to be nosy. Usually, there’d be a heavily decorated wreath and some sort of corny welcome mat, but today’s mat said a simple “welcome” and there was nothing hanging off the door. He tried to look through the opaque curtains. Maybe someone else was in there, and if that was the case, he really needed to mentally prepare himself.

He shuffled over the icy entry steps until he was closer to the gap in the curtains. From here, nothing seemed decorated. There wasn’t even a Christmas tree. He tried to get a closer look, but the ground was slippery and his wet feet made the situation ten times worse.

Maybe if he shuffled very slowly, he could get a quick peek before Jack came back.

“Theo, what are you doing?”

Drawn out of his plotting, Theo’s effort to maintain his balance and stealth disappeared. He twisted his entire body around without thinking and he immediately tried to distance himself from what he was looking at.

It happened before he could even realize it.

Suddenly, the world underneath Theo lurched. He tried to grab a hold of something—anything—, but his arms were flailing and his body was tilting forward at the speed of light.

He tried to cry out, but the sound died in his throat. It was too late now. He was already falling forward into a terrifying blur of snow.

Theo squeezed his eyes shut and waited for the pain.

Chapter 4

Theo was floating in the air.

Wait…no he wasn’t.

Strong arms closed around him and Theo realized Jack’s scent was a mix of rosemary and peppermint. The simple aromas transformed into something more tantalizing as he inhaled. Everything about the way the man in front of him was still familiar, even though they hadn’t seen each other in two decades. Theo tried to wrap his mind around it, but he couldn’t figure it out.

He wasn’t sure what to expect, but when he opened his eyes and his brown pair met with Jack’s even gaze, he let out a breath.

“Jack.” He exhaled.

Under him, Jack’s body was like a flame and the warmth lit Theo up. Jack had always dressed simply. Today was no exception. The red flannel that stretched over his muscles was the softest cotton he’d ever felt and he couldn’t help but lean further into him.

He peeked at Jack through a thick fan of lashes. The light outside the front door created a crown-like ring around Jack’s messy head of auburn waves and Theo’s mouth hung open in awe. Snowflakes danced around the two of them, a distracting amount landing on Jack’s flushed face.

Much to his surprise, Jack’s expression was not difficult to read.

The two of them seeing each other for the first time after so many years should’ve been much more awkward than it was, but Jack had always been the kind of person who didn’t care about the elephant sitting in a room with him. Knowing he would eventually address it made Theo’s insides swirl with anxiety, but he tried to focus on literally anything else.

Maybe the incredibly direct part of Jack had changed over the years. Theo tried to read his face to figure out what was going to happen next, but the expression on Jack’s face was one of worry.

Theo tried to blink the dream away.

When his eyes reset, Jack Claus was still holding him close.

Okay, this isn’t a fucked up dream, Theo told himself.

“You’re shivering.” Jack’s voice was soft, as if he was coaxing a scared animal. His lower lip jutted out as he waited for a response that didn’t come.

Theo’s response was a nod. Now that Jack had pointed it out, he could feel the dull ache of cold in more areas of his body. Despite that, his brain only had enough space to think about Jack.

Close up, he noticed more about the other man’s face. Like the paleness of his freckles in the winter and the tiny gold gem that sparkled on the side of his nose.

“We’re going inside now” was all Jack said.

With that, Jack lifted Theo into a bridal carry and opened the front door. The second they stepped over the threshold, the sweet scent of sugar wrapped around Theo like a hug. Butter. Cinnamon. A hint of caramel sauce that he remembered from all those summers in their childhood.

His stomach rumbled.

When was the last time he’d eaten? He didn’t know. He’d been too focused on getting to his second flight on time to find a place to charge his phone, let alone to think about food.