Page 17
If he had been on the other end, would he have forgiven Jack? After twenty years of silence and uncertainty, would Theo have welcomed Jack back with open arms, despite all his questions and hurt? He wasn’t sure.
“I don’t think I would ever have been as forgiving as you,” he said honestly.
Jack laughed. “I was always the better one between the two of us, wasn’t I?”
That was true. Jack was always the one who believed that people could change for the better. In high school, he’d been one of those popular jocks who found their way into everyone’s soft spot, and he’d used his persuasive powers for good. He was the sort of person who lent a hand, offered a shoulder, or simply listened. It was part of the reason Theo had fallen for him.
It was also part of the reason he’d run. He didn’t want Jack to follow him somewhere he wouldn’t be happy, especially if it was because of a dream Theo wasn’t even sure would work out.
It hadn’t worked out anyway. How ironic.
As the two of them ate, they talked about everything that had happened over the years they’d been missing from each other’s lives. Theo told Jack about his friends in Los Angeles, particularly Will, who had recently decided to become a vegetarian, even though that made his existence as a vampire a thousand times harder. He told him about his favorite bakery that served fresh croissants, but you had to come before eight in the morning or they’d be sold out. He even told him about his boss that he’d been sleeping with on and off for years, and how that got him fired and blacklisted. And now, there he was, ready to start his life again with no job. And he still hadn’t broken the news to his parents.
For his part, Jack told Theo about moving to Burlington for university, where he’d met his first wife, a human. Their relationship had been hot and heavy, but no matter how hard they tried to make it work, the constant fighting led to a divorce.
Then there was the fae he’d married in Vegas on a dare. He’d lasted longer than anyone had expected, but eventually, Jack divorced him after their differing opinions about kids became a deal breaker.
Finally, Jack told Theo about Madeline, the banshee who he’d been married to at the time of his parent’s death. Their relationship had felt more like a friendship than a romance, and although the two of them had created a good life together, the lack of passion led to an amicable split five years ago.
Theo listened with intense focus as Jack talked in detail about how lost he’d been his divorces; and how at the end of it, he’d finally decided that coming home was the right thing to do. He’d always been a Lake Falls kid, and setting his roots in the town his parents had loved so much just felt right.
“So yeah,” Jack finished. “That’s what happens when you go around marrying people before you fix your shit. You end up moving home in your mid thirties and opening a Christmas tree farm with your inheritance.”
Theo took another bite of the food. He couldn’t imagine being married. Everything about his life had been incredibly impersonal. He’d always had one foot out the door.
“A bit ironic, don’t you think?” He raised a teasing eyebrow.
“You think I’m the first reindeer that thought of it?” Jack’s smile was playful. “I’m just lucky Lake Falls doesn’t have a big deer population and our luck is actually something special here.”
“Your dad always had an eye for a good investment anyway.” Theo nodded. “So I’m sure no one else would’ve been proper competition.”
“Yeah.” Jack’s eyes were glassy with tears and he sniffed to hold them back. “It’s so hard figuring things out without him. I’ve been doing it for six years and I’m still not sure I know what I’m doing.”
“You’ve had a rough life since we broke up.” Theo pointed out.
Jack chewed thoughtfully, then spoke. “You could say that. My parents are dead, I’m a chronic divorcee, and I’m spending Christmas Eve tending to my first love’s wounds.” He said the words without an ounce of bitterness.
“You’ve changed in a lot of ways, but you’re still the same person, Jack Claus,” Theo said.
“I think you’ve changed for the better,” Jack told him.
Theo considered Jack’s words and accepted them. It was true. He didn’t feel like the same person he’d once been. For so many reasons, his life was already more hopeful than it had been even a day before.
He wasn’t as worried or ashamed about telling his parents he was starting over. His skills had served him well before and they’d continue to be useful. He was more confident about that now.
By the time they finished eating, it was past ten in the evening and Theo was exhausted. His immediate instinct was to blame it on the pain medicine Jack had given him after dinner, but he knew the accident was catching up to him.
They did the dishes together, Jack washing and Theo rinsing, like always. Theo’s shoulders bumped against Jack’s waist, and their fingers brushed every time Jack handed him a dish to dry. The routine was so mundane, but it tugged at Theo’s heartstrings.
He had been such a fool to let this man go. Every part of him knew that now.
They finished washing the dishes and dried their hands. Jack reached his thick, padded hand out, waiting patiently as Theo gave him his.
“Theo.”
Jack waited until Theo’s eyes met his.
“I don’t want the mistakes you made in the past to define the life we have in the present. I mean that.”