AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Disturbing Prospect

Page 60

by Elizabeth Barone

My shoulders sag. I lower the gun. As the adrenaline ebbs, I feel ridiculous. Still, I check the entire apartment. Room by room, I make sure windows are locked. I sweep Esther’s bedroom, then close the door behind her. Then I double check the front door.

Locked.

Feeling a bit paranoid, I head to my bedroom. I pass by Dio sleeping on his back, his tummy rising and falling with each breath.

"Goodnight," I whisper, and slip into my room.

I change into a Mindless Self Indulgence T-shirt and peel back the covers on my bed. Another set of shiny keys rests on my pillow. This time, I flat out scream.

Turning, I snatch the gun from my vanity. Tears prick at my eyes. I gasp for breath, feeling as if my chest is being squeezed. Chills dot my body. Still sucking in sharp breaths, I turn back to the bed.

They’re still there.

A whimper escapes my lips. He’s fucking with me. Probably watching through my window right now and laughing at me. Except my blinds are down, the way I usually keep them. I stare at the window, wondering: If I pull them up or peek through, will I find him standing out in the yard?

"Think, Olivia," I whisper to myself. I can’t let him scare me. If I get hysterical, he wins. I need to flip this around on him. Take back the higher ground.

But I can barely think with my heart pounding in my ears.

My phone vibrates in my bag. I dart across my bedroom and grab it. I don’t recognize the number on the screen. It must be Eli. My thumb slides toward the green button to answer it, but I halt.

I can’t play his game. If I answer it, he’ll just keep playing with me.

I put the phone down on my bed. Then, leaving the light on and the door cracked open, I ease out of my room.

On the balls of my feet, I prowl the apartment. I tuck sleepy Dio into his carrier and close him in Esther’s room. The whole time, I hear my phone vibrating in my bedroom.

Shrouded in shadows, I park myself in a corner of the living room. I drop to a crouch, gun drawn. If he comes in—no, when he comes in—he won’t make it far.

I swallow hard, muscles coiled. My arms aren’t used to being straight out for long, and after only a couple of minutes, they start to fall asleep. I flex my elbows, getting the blood pumping again. But my eyes never leave the door.

In my bedroom, my phone stops ringing.

Every beat of my heart is a hollow echo in my ears. Tears sting my eyes, whether from fatigue or fear, I don’t know. I turn off the safety.

The door knob jiggles, the distinct sound of a key fitting into the lock cutting across the room to me. Even after seeing the spare keys he left for me, hearing it sends shockwaves of nausea through me.

He made copies of my apartment keys.

I picture him sitting in a dim cellar with an old fashioned key-making machine. My parents had one that was my great-grandfather’s. All he had to do was take the blank to my apartment, notch it in the lock, and voila. Chills ripple up and down my spine.

I’ve put too much trust into this world, even after all I’ve seen. Safety is only an illusion. One that I’ve gladly wrapped myself in.

Until now.

Time slows, and I take a long, deep breath in through my nose. As the bottom lock disengages, I form a fast plan.

I’m not an experienced shooter. I won’t be able to hit him while he’s moving. My best bet is to let him come all the way in. Let him think I’m in my bedroom. Follow him. And then close in. There won’t be anywhere for him to run.

The deadbolt clicks.

I snap to attention.

The knob turns, and the door pushes open slowly. It doesn’t even make a sound. I think of all the nights I’ve slept here, oblivious, while he probably came in and watched me. Touched my cat. Fury flashes through me. I lift my chin.

Eli steps inside. In the dark, it’s hard to make out his face, but he isn’t even wearing a ski mask or anything like that. Cocky motherfucker. He glances around, his eyes unadjusted to the dark. His head swivels in the direction of the light peeking out from under my bedroom door. I can’t see it, but I know he’s smiling, that blank clicking spinning in his eyes.

My blood freezes at the thought of it.