Page 137
“I want to do it for me, Daddy. Um… I don’t understand my craving when it comes to stuffing me. I… I just know that I want to be stuffed in all the ways possible.”
When Alijah doesn’t continue, I prod him. “I need to know, Alijah. What kind of ways?”
“I want for you to double penetrate me.” He hurriedly adds, “With a dildo.”
At his kink request, I wonder in the future if our foursome with Otto and Henry would allow for Otto and me to penetrate him together. I always thought that I’d never share any boy that was mine. But even before Otto arrived, when I saw how Alijah, Henry, and I melded so seamlessly, thoughts of a threesome crept into my imagination even though I never articulated them even to myself. Not until now when my little cat is showing a kinky side of himself that I never would’ve presumed existed.
I swing my leg around and creep up to the headboard, then open my arms in invitation for Alijah to crawl into them. I hold back my smile at his pouty face. “I’m not saying no, little cat.”
“Then what Daddy, since we’re cuddling instead of fucking or fisting?”
“Would you be Daddy’s good baby boy and let me explain?”
“Yes, Daddy. Can I just say something first?”
“Go ahead, baby boy,” I urge. “I’m listening.”
“A while ago, you mentioned that you’d want to fist me when I was ready. I never heard about fisting before that so I looked it up. I became aroused just reading about it, Daddy. And when I watched a man fist a woman on porn, I had an orgasm. I was kind of stunned at the time. But the more we’re having sex and you’re teaching me how to ready my body and what pleases me, I’m coming to understand that you filling me is my sexual, slash love language. Whether you fuck my mouth or my hole, I keep craving more.”
“And yet,” I say, half to myself as I’m pondering his admission, “impact play or other kinds of pain don’t appeal to you, with the exception of a good spanking.”
I wipe the sheen of perspiration from his brow and stare into the smokey taupe makeup around his eyes that highlight the blue and grayish white. “Alijah,” I say softly. “Depending on the porn sites you were on, did any of them caution about safe procedures?”
Alijah hides his face in my T-shirt and I hear a muffled, “Yes, Daddy.”
I want to laugh at how adorable he is but this is a serious topic. “Look at me, please.”
He comes out of hiding and straightens. “The BDSM sites that teach safety habits explained about the best ways, and they all included having a tub of lube on hand. They even make special kind just for the purpose of fisting.”
“That’s why as much as wish I could be watching my hand disappear inside you right now, I won’t hurt you, Alijah. You’ll feel the pain of the stretch. That’s to be expected. But I refuse to tear you or abuse you beyond the ability to heal.” I pinch his lips together and pepper them with sweet pecks. “When Otto leaves and you won’t be doing any more videos, I promise that we’ll go to the adult store, buy the proper lube, and then we’ll come home and I’ll edge you until you’re desperate for my fist. Are you good with that?”
“Yes Daddy, you know best.”
Now that I have decided to be all in with Alijah, I’m also allowing myself to become aware of the many ways that he demonstrates his willingness to be my boy. This was a disappointment for him after the big high of the video. “Thank you, baby boy. Since fisting is out, what is your backup request?”
Alijah’s answer is immediate. “Can you be inside me, Daddy?”
“Yes, baby boy,” I answer and tell myself I will kiss Henry next time we’re alone. Even before Alijah came into my life, Henry suggested that we take hormone injections to keep our testosterone levels at normal. Since getting the injections for the last six months, I find that I’m aroused as easily as when I was thirty. And my orgasms have the same explosive force. If not for the hormones, I’d never be able to get my cock hard only fifteen minutes after shooting my load down his throat. “Does my little cat want rough or does the ballerina want me to make love?”
“The latter Daddy, please. Soft and tender like—”
“Like you’re my everything, Alijah. Like you’ve left your imprint on my heart in the same way that I’ve left my handprints on yours. Like two rivers converging into one as they spill into the ocean.”
“Just like all those ways, Daddy.”
Crawling between Alijah’s legs, that’s exactly what I do.
Two hours later, showered and dressed, the four of us convene in the family room with sated grins and as for Henry, a circle of hickeys around his neck. I watch Alijah the instant he spots them—a collar of hickeys. At every opportunity, Otto demonstrates his intention to make Henry his boy permanently. And God, I hope he doesn’t break Henry’s heart. My best friend has never fallen for anyone like he has for Otto.
Otto removes his hand from Henry’s shoulder, where he’s fingering a strap on the harness. “Are we back in business mode?”
“Semi-casual,” I answer. “Would you like a drink, Otto?”
Otto jumps up. “I’ll get it, Enzo. I need to rehydrate so only water for me. Anyone else?”
The three of us raise our hands and Otto trots off to the kitchen, returning with four bottles.
I twist open Alijah’s and hand it to him. Then after wetting my dry throat, I ask Henry, “What did you think?”