Page 95
“I'm not planning to see her again,” I said. “I actually think it's time to start dating again.”
Jay laughed. “Have you ever actually dated?”
I nodded slowly. “Yeah,” I muttered. “I was dating Bri when she disappeared and married another man.”
Jay swallowed hard. “Right.”
“You need to have that conversation with Bri. Make sure she's on the same page. She's the one who showed up last night. If someone had seen her…”
“I'm meeting her today,” he said. “After this. She wanted to see Sadie.” He picked up the coffee cup.
I nodded as I uncrossed my arms and leaned back.
I still didn't know why Bri was back, but I knew enough to know that she still couldn't be mine.
44
BRI
I got to the restaurant early.
I needed a few minutes to sit with my coffee and get my head right before they walked in because I'd only seen Jayden briefly since I got back. We'd spoken on the phone a handful of times over the years, but that was it. And now here I was, back in the same city, about to sit across a table from him and pretend I had good answers to every question he was going to ask me.
I didn't.
I wrapped both hands around my coffee mug and watched the door.
They came in together. Sadie looked incredible; that soft glow that people talk about when women are pregnant was absolutely real, and she had it in full force. She spotted me first, and her face broke into a genuine smile, and I felt something loosen in my chest. I liked her. I'd liked her from the first five minutes, and that hadn't changed.
Jayden was a different story.
I could tell from the way he came through the door that something had already gone sideways this morning. His jaw was set, and his eyes were doing that flat, careful thing they did when he was working to keep a lid on something.
I watched him drop into the seat across from me without a word.
“Okay,” I said. “What crawled up your ass?”
Sadie pressed her lips together and looked at the menu.
Jay looked at me. “Oh, I don't know. Maybe the fact that KJ chewed me out this morning because you showed up last night at a party you had absolutely no business being at.”
I sank back in my seat and crossed my arms. I'd known this was coming. I'd known it before I even pulled into that parking lot last night, which hadn't stopped me.
“It turns out,” I said, “it was harder than I thought to stay away.”
“Bri.”He said my name the way he'd been saying it my whole life, that particular tone that meant he loved me and was exhausted by me in equal measure. “You made your choice when you got on that plane and married Luca. You have a son with him.”He leaned forward slightly. “You destroyed KJ when you left. You can't do that to him again.”
Sadie looked up from the menu. “We had to pick up the pieces,” she said, her voice gentle, but she didn’t soften its edges. “Both of us. It wasn't pretty.”
I scowled at the table for a second. I knew that. I'd known it when I wrote the letter, and I'd known it every day after. Knowing something doesn't make it easier to hear out loud.
“I didn't have a choice,” I said.
Jay opened his mouth, but I pushed forward before he could cut me off.
“If I hadn't gone, you two wouldn’t be married and expecting a baby girl right now.”I looked at him directly. “Which, for the record, you are. So.”
The table went quiet.