AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Unwrapped

Page 36

by Taryn Quinn

“She was disappointed in us,” he said quietly.

Matt didn’t reply because he’d suspected the same. “It’s hard for a chick to acknowledge a pretty boy might like the other team as much as hers,” he said with a shrug, though he guessed it went way deeper than that.

“You’re pretty too.”

“Aww, how sweet.” Before Tristan could kick him under the table, Matt signaled the waitress, Telula, over with a smile. She perked up instantly at Matt’s attention. “Hey, Tel, could you grab us one of those chocolate and raspberry cakes from the bakery case? To go.”

“Sure, honey. You want some French vanilla ice cream to go with that?”

“That’d be perfect.” Oh hell yeah. Now that’s what he was talking about. Then he remembered Cait would need real food beyond the frozen crap he had in the freezer. He had stuff for breakfast, but she probably wouldn’t want bacon and eggs tonight. “Can you box up some other stuff for us too? Onion rings and one of your awesome turkey clubs.”

“She’ll want root beer,” Tristan put in.

“Right. You got any two-liters?”

“We’ll fix your order up just the way you want it. No problem, honey.” Telula patted his shoulder and began clearing away plates.

“You need some help with that?” Tris asked as she balanced their dishes and glasses in her arms.

“Nope. There’s a trick to it.” She winked at them and headed off to the kitchen, a jaunty spring in her step.

“She’s nice. Reminds me of your mom,” Tristan said, wiping up the crumbs from the Formica like the good little boy he’d always been. With a mile-wide streak of naughty he just couldn’t reconcile, even with himself.

“My mom’s planning on visiting soon, by the way. She’s going to try to get in for New Year’s. Says Boise’s winter has been hell already, and she needs to escape.”

“Yeah? She get some time off work?”

“A week and a half. She wants to spend it with her two boys and her extra daughter.” He grinned at Tris, but Tristan wasn’t looking at him. He was staring at the table.

“How’re we gonna tell them?”

Matt knew very well who Tristan meant, but he played dumb. Anything to stall. “Them?”

“Your mom, my parents, Caity’s mom. We can’t hide this.”

“Says who?” Matt bit off a sigh as Telula returned with the check. “What’s the rush?” he asked once she’d left again.

“I don’t want to sweep this under the rug. If we’re doing it, we’re doing it all the way.”

That was Tris. Hotheaded and emotional and, more than anything, invested. He’d reserve judgment for a long time, then go all hell-bent on getting what he wanted at a moment’s notice.

Matt didn’t work that way. He knew Tris saw him as impulsive, but if he did something, you could sure as shit bet he’d thought through every angle first. He didn’t just run everything behind the scenes at Tristan Designs with precision, he ran his life that way too. And he hadn’t worked out telling everyone about their ménage yet, mainly because he wasn’t sure how he’d handle it. At his core, he was almost as wary of unusual setups like this as Cait, but he also wasn’t used to denying his needs. And when it came to her and Tris, he’d denied for as long as possible.

He also had a wonderful, sweet mother he wasn’t about to hurt. She wouldn’t get this. He didn’t think she’d condemn it either, because she loved all three of them. But still. If they didn’t have to rip the lid off this right now, why borrow trouble? Couldn’t they just work on getting Caity to come around without planning some big reveal to the rest of the world?

“Let’s just take it slow,” Matt said as he casually slipped the bill out from under Tris’s card. He reeled at the figure but shrugged it off. It was a damn diner tab, and he had to loosen the purse strings occasionally. TD was doing well—due in no small part to their amazingly creative lead designer—and they could afford a few meals out, even if he’d tried and failed to put Tristan on a budget years ago. “We’ll convince Caity to give us a shot, and then we’ll worry about the rest. All right?”

“You’re not convinced either, are you?” Tristan clenched his jaw. “This is just a lark to you. A good fuck. Not what it is to me.”

“You know better than that. I love her every bit as much as you do.”

Words unspoken hung in the air between them, and Matt pressed his lips together to keep from saying more. He’d assumed Tristan knew how he felt, but maybe not. Maybe he needed an affirmation beyond Matt’s feelings for Cait.

Shit, did he really expect him to bust out with an “I love you” in a dingy diner while the Chipmunks’ Christmas song played in the background?

As the silence deepened, Matt took a slow, bracing breath. Apparently he did.

“Look, Tris⁠—”