AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Unlikely Pair

Page 67

by Chelle Sloan

“I guess,” I say. “But what I’m trying to say, Sutton, is that you’re a beautiful woman. Smart and warm and good with kids, and I’m pretty sure if you went into a forest, small animals would start singing with you.”

“I don’t know about that,” she says. “My voice is pretty horrible.”

“And funny. You’re a catch. Any man would be lucky to have you. And I know you’re in a place where you want to, and should be, dating. So why would you put all that on hold to pretend date me?”

“Because we both need this,” she says. “And friends help friends.”

I’m just realizing she’s taken my hand in hers. And that’s not the shocking part. The shocking part is that I don’t flinch. I don’t feel like my hand is on fire. I don’t immediately wonder if I’m weirdly cheating on Hailey.

Maybe I can do this.

“Okay then,” I say, feeling like a box has been checked. “So…what now?”

“I think we need rules,” Sutton says. “Timelines. Expectations. Because since neither of us want to actually date, but we need to convince the people in our lives we are, we need guidelines.”

“I guess that means we have to go on dates?”

“Yes, being seen together will help,” Sutton says. “And we…probably need to touch. Hold hands. Maybe a kiss. Are you comfortable with that?”

I nearly choke on a breath at that thought. In my racing brain that came up with this dumb idea, I never even thought about all the things you do with a girlfriend. My tunnel vision had me convinced I could just say I had a girlfriend and everyone would get off my back.

But Sutton’s right. We need to sell this. No one is going to believe me if I say I have a girlfriend but we’re never seen together, and when we are, we’re acting like strangers.

“Asher, we don’t have to do this,” Sutton reminds me. “I don’t know much about your wife, but I read the news back then. I know the accident was tragic. I can’t imagine how hard that is to move on from, if you ever do. If doing this is too much…if you’re not ready for this…we can call it now. No harm, no foul. This can stop before it even gets started.”

I relax slightly at Sutton’s words, suddenly feeling more at ease than I expected about this situation. It’s not just what she says, but how she seems to really understand how difficult this is for me. “Can I confess something?”

“Of course.”

“I’ve never even kissed anyone else,” I admit. “I started dating Hailey when I was sixteen, but I fell in love with her at the beginning of high school. And while most of my classmates were going to parties in middle school and playing seven minutes in heaven, I was at hockey practice or with her. She was it. She was…my person.”

“Oh Asher…” Sutton says, and I didn’t mean to make her cry, but I see her eyes getting glassy. And that’s not what this disclosure was about.

“All I’m saying is…being with someone—dating, intimacy, sex, all of that—scares the shit out of me. It was only ever her. Which is a big reason why I’m hesitant to get back out there. It feels…”

“Wrong,” Sutton says, finishing my sentence. “I think that’s beautiful. She was the love of your life. Some people dream of ever finding that. And you found it when you two were so young. No woman should ever fault you for being hesitant. Or nervous.”

“Thank you. I know I need to start picking myself up. As my mom said—and my teammates and my friends and Adalyn probably if she knew what was going on—it’s been four years. And maybe with you, with something that’s not real and there are no expectations, I can start figuring myself out. Learn how to do this without pressure.”

“I think that’s a good plan,” she says. “Plus, since I’ve sworn off hockey players, and I doubt you’re changing careers in the next few months, I’m guaranteed to not fall in love with you.”

I don’t know why that makes me laugh, but it does. “We’re really doing this?”

“We are,” she says, giving my hand a squeeze before she pulls them back. “I guess the first thing we need to do is start telling people?”

“I guess,” I say. “Who are we telling first?”

“Easy,” she says. “The ones who will call us out immediately if they don’t believe our story.”

CHAPTER 16

SUTTON

“Mommy? Where are we going?”

I wasn’t sure if Maverick was going to notice that we didn’t take our normal way home when we left Lana’s house. I forgot who my kid is. “What would you say if we went over to Adalyn’s house?”

“Adalyn’s? Yes!”