Page 64
“You,” she says, literally holding her stomach she’s laughing so hard. And I’m pretty sure a tear is rolling down her cheek. “I don’t know what’s more unbelievable. You asking me that question or you rambling. I don't think anybody would believe me on either.”
Her laughter continues, and fuck it, she’s right. It is funny. Hilarious. Everything about it.
Now neither of us can stop laughing, and I’m pretty sure I feel a tear mimicking Sutton’s. Gabi walks past us to make sure we’re okay, and now I don’t need to worry about her telling Maddox I was on a date, she’s going to spend the rest of her day wondering where I learned to laugh like this.
“Okay, so we can agree it’s a stupid idea,” I say, finally able to calm myself.
“Disagree. I think it’s a great idea.”
Now it’s my turn to be shocked still.
“Asher?” she says, snapping her fingers in front of my eyes to get me to blink. “You there?”
“Yeah,” I say with a shake of my head. “Did you just actually say yes?”
“Yes.”
“Yes?”
“Yes.”
“Yes?”
“I think we’re going to end up in an infinite loop if I don’t stop you there.” Sutton takes my hands and looks me straight in the eye. I know because I’m still not blinking. “But I have a lot of questions about this.”
“Ask anything you’d like.”
Holy shit, is she actually saying yes?
“Okay. Let’s start with where this idea came from. Before we go any further, I really need to know that backstory and how your mom and sleepy-time tea are involved in this.”
I do as she asked, but not before I order a cup of coffee from Gabi, because this is going to take a second. Liquid fortification in hand, I tell Sutton about last night’s conversation with my mom, and how even though she didn’t say the words out loud about having a fake girlfriend, she definitely planted the seed. And that when I woke up this morning, this proposal to Sutton was the first thing on my mind.
“But I wasn’t going to act on it,” I say. “I’m not a spontaneous decision maker. Plus, I had practice this morning and preschool drop-off for Adalyn. And we leave for Game 7 in Vancouver tomorrow night. The last thing I needed was to jump into this without thinking about it from twenty different angles.”
“So what changed?”
“My fucking teammates,” I say with a touch of annoyance in my voice. “When I got to practice today, the first words I heard out of Liam’s mouth were ‘bachelor auction.’”
Sutton’s eyes are back to wide. “Did he sign you up for one?”
“Oh, not just me. Every Rockers player not in a committed relationship. Which ticked off your ex. He didn’t understand why he was being left out.”
“Please don’t remind me that I dated that guy,” she says with a long exhale. “Also, good to know he already has plans on cheating on my sister, if he hasn’t already.”
“Remember that for later in the story,” I say. “But Liam signing me up for that was my last straw. Especially when he said, ‘Who knows? Maybe that’s how you’ll get back out there.’ It…That’s not how I want to date. I’m all for charity, but I’d rather write them a million-dollar check than be forced to go on a date with a woman who won me.”
“Fair enough,” Sutton says. “So that’s what pushed you to this?”
“Yes, it was the final straw. The guys pushing me to date. Erika’s grabby hands. Bachelor auctions. Our kids asking us about dates. It was just too much.”
“And you thought I’d be the right one to do this with?”
I can’t tell if she’s flattered or pissed, so I play this as evenly as I can.
“Yes. But I want you to know, it’s not because you’re one of the only single women I know.”
“Thanks?”