AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Unlikely Pair

Page 137

by Chelle Sloan

SUTTON

Asher didn’t let go of my hand the entire time we drove to the cabin.

We didn’t say anything either.

I know he’s not a big talker, but this was more than that. He knew I needed to decompress. To come to grips with what just happened. That I finally did what I should’ve done years ago when it comes to my family.

And now that we’re in the cabin, under a blanket on his oversized sectional, a fire crackling, his arms around me as I sit between his legs, I don’t even know how to start talking again. Because what do I say? Conduct a postmortem on the fight? Ask him to text Liam for the video so we can break down the game film? I don’t need to do any of those, but I do need to say one thing before anything else.

“Thank you.”

If he’s startled by my words, he doesn’t react that way. Instead, he pulls me in tighter, his lips grazing my temple. “I want to say you’re welcome, but I’d like to know what for.”

“No one has ever had my back like that,” I admit, my hand mindlessly drawing circles around his forearm. “It’s always been me against them. Even before Rob did what he did…he never took my side. Maybe that should’ve been my first clue.”

“You’re welcome, but Sutton, you never need to thank me.”

“That’s where you’re wrong. I know we’re…not actually really dating…but I appreciate you standing up to them for me. With me. It means more to me than I can ever say.”

Asher doesn’t respond. Instead, he moves me away from him, only to somehow pick me up and turn me to face him. If this wasn’t such an emotional conversation, I’d be all sorts of turned on.

Oh who am I kidding? Of course I’m turned on.

“Sutton, I meant every word. I wish I could’ve said more, because they’re horrible people. I know I’ve only seen the surface of how they act toward you and the things they say. But you need to know everything I said was real. You. Maverick. You’re my family. And there’s nothing fake or fabricated about that.”

My heart skips a beat and my throat swells shut. I know I’ve needed to have this conversation with Asher. Things have definitely become blurry between us and I know I’ve been feeling things that were not part of the original agreement.

I’m falling in love with him. Hell, I am in love with him. If I didn’t know it before, I know it now.

And for the sake of my sanity, and my heart, we have to have this conversation. Here. Now. Everything on the table.

“You mean it? That…I’m…we’re…you’re family?”

If I wasn’t already sitting down, the smile he gives me would knock me on my ass.

Yup. I’ve fallen in love with Asher Reed.

“You are,” he says, taking both of my hands into his. “I’ve felt it for days now, but I didn’t want to admit it to myself. Or maybe I was too scared to. I knew you said you weren’t in a place to commit to someone. And God knows I’m a trainwreck who probably needs years more therapy before I should enter into a relationship.”

“We can call my therapist. See if we can get a two-for-one.”

My joke makes him laugh, and it also earns me a quick kiss. “But Sutton, these feelings I have for you? These aren’t fake. These are as real as anything I could ever have. Ever dreamt of having for anyone ever again. And then when I saw you tonight? You and Adalyn in your matching jackets. Maverick proud to wear my name on his back. My mom smiling next to you guys. You’re my family. You’re it for me. That is…if you want this too?”

I feel the tears building up, but I need to say what I need to before I become a blubbering mess. “Asher, since I first saw you in the salon, when I looked like an alien wrapped in a cape, I think I’ve had feelings for you. I’ve tried to convince myself from that moment that I didn’t want you. That I didn’t need you. Thinking I could pretend to be your girlfriend and not develop feelings?” I huff out a sardonic laugh. “I’ve done a lot of stupid things in my life, but that was probably the dumbest. Actually, thinking we could have a physical relationship and not catch feelings, that was even worse.”

“Only you could make me laugh during such a serious conversation.”

“I deflect with humor,” I say. “But what I am saying is that it’s real for me, Asher. It’s been real for a while, but I’ve been too scared to say anything. I didn’t want to push you. I didn’t want to rush into something you weren’t ready for. I’ve made some mistakes in the past, and I didn’t want to be a mistake to you. But I can’t deny it anymore. I…I love you, Asher Reed.”

Oh shit.

Shit shit shit.

Did I not just give a spiel in that monologue about doing things too fast? And then I’m the one to drop the I love you first? Stupid, Sutton. Stupid, stupid, stupid.

“I love you too, Sutton. So fucking much.”

I quit breathing as I hear Asher say those words back to me. I only start again because I open my mouth as his comes toward mine, kissing me like he’s never kissed me before.